New Rating List

As in chess tournaments and matches...
gaard
Posts: 127
Joined: Thu Jun 10, 2010 1:39 am
Real Name: Martin Wyngaarden
Location: Holland, Michigan

Re: New Rating List

Post by gaard » Fri Jul 16, 2010 12:12 am

gaard wrote:
giorgio wrote:Hi gaard,
great project! Thanks for your effort.

Only one question: why only 3-4 Scorpio BitBases and not 3-4-5 as all other endgame bases?

Bye.
It's a work in progress. Critter 0.70 is in the next batch to be tested, unfortunately without GTB's.

My justification is that these engines in my rating list that do use SBB's are no longer very popular, would not benefit much from the added 5 piece BB's, I am too lazy to download them, and I don't want to rerun 600 games :) If any of these engines approaches the Top 3, and I think BitBases or GTBs could be the deciding factor in determining standing, then I will download them.

Code: Select all

   1 Houdini 1.03              31.0 ( 25.5 :   5.5)
                                5.0 (  3.5 :   1.5) Rybka 4              
                                2.0 (  1.5 :   0.5) IvanHoe 9.57a         
                                5.0 (  5.0 :   0.0) Stockfish 1.8         
                                4.0 (  3.0 :   1.0) Naum 4.2               
                                2.0 (  1.5 :   0.5) Shredder 12 32-bit   
                                3.0 (  2.5 :   0.5) Critter 0.70         
                                5.0 (  4.0 :   1.0) Spark 0.4           
                                5.0 (  4.5 :   0.5) Zappa Mexico II     
Crushing the competition so far, after 31 games. Not near enough to draw conclusions but it is worth mentioning that after 31 games the LOS over Rybka 4 is 90%.

gaard
Posts: 127
Joined: Thu Jun 10, 2010 1:39 am
Real Name: Martin Wyngaarden
Location: Holland, Michigan

Re: New Rating List

Post by gaard » Fri Jul 16, 2010 4:15 am

Code: Select all

Rank Name                 Elo    +    - games score oppo. draws 
   1 Houdini 1.03         150   48   46   138   72%   -11   33% 
   2 Rybka 4              117   31   30   298   64%    15   38% 
   3 Houdini 1.02         111   21   21   674   69%   -27   38% 
   4 IvanHoe 9.57a        103   46   46   111   55%    71   54% 
   5 Stockfish 1.8         63   29   29   337   59%    -2   36% 
   6 Naum 4.2               5   34   34   237   43%    48   37% 
   7 Critter 0.70         -55   33   34   253   36%    38   32% 
   8 Shredder 12 32-bit   -57   32   32   284   45%   -25   30% 
   9 Spark 0.4           -112   31   31   318   30%    27   30% 
  10 Zappa Mexico II     -144   33   33   299   32%    -4   29% 
  11 Toga II 1.4beta5c   -180   33   34   279   30%   -30   29% 




   1 Houdini 1.03         150 138.0 (100.0 :  38.0)
                               19.0 ( 10.0 :   9.0) Rybka 4              117
                               14.0 (  8.5 :   5.5) IvanHoe 9.57a        103
                               19.0 ( 13.5 :   5.5) Stockfish 1.8         63
                               18.0 ( 13.5 :   4.5) Naum 4.2               5
                               17.0 ( 13.0 :   4.0) Critter 0.70         -55
                               14.0 ( 11.5 :   2.5) Shredder 12 32-bit   -57
                               19.0 ( 15.5 :   3.5) Spark 0.4           -112
                               18.0 ( 14.5 :   3.5) Zappa Mexico II     -144
I abandoned all of my old games and am rerunning a few thousand with a larger and more diverse suite. You'll notice that some of the engines have played few games so the margin of error is still high. However, in an attempt to get a more accurate measurement of the improvements in Houdini 1.03, I ran 670+ games with Houdini 1.02 against all opponents in this list, excluding Houdini 1.03.

If the games continue like this, Houdini 1.03 will be 30+ Elo improved over 1.02 and a clear #1 across the board.

gaard
Posts: 127
Joined: Thu Jun 10, 2010 1:39 am
Real Name: Martin Wyngaarden
Location: Holland, Michigan

Re: New Rating List

Post by gaard » Fri Jul 16, 2010 1:45 pm

220+ more games for Houdini 1.03 and now 29 Elo over 1.02:

Code: Select all

Rank Name                 Elo    +    - games score oppo. draws 
   1 Houdini 1.03         141   29   28   362   71%   -10   36% 
   2 Rybka 4              117   29   29   326   63%    25   39% 
   3 Houdini 1.02         112   21   21   674   69%   -26   38% 
   4 IvanHoe 9.57a        110   41   41   139   54%    85   55% 
   5 Stockfish 1.8         67   27   27   365   58%     9   38% 
   6 Naum 4.2               3   32   32   264   41%    58   37% 
   7 Critter 0.70         -55   32   33   280   35%    48   32% 
   8 Shredder 12 32-bit   -58   31   31   312   43%   -10   29% 
   9 Spark 0.4           -112   30   30   347   29%    37   29% 
  10 Zappa Mexico II     -145   31   32   328   30%     9   29% 
  11 Toga II 1.4beta5c   -180   33   34   279   30%   -31   29% 

   1 Houdini 1.03         141 362.0 (257.5 : 104.5)
                               47.0 ( 25.5 :  21.5) Rybka 4              117
                               42.0 ( 22.5 :  19.5) IvanHoe 9.57a        110
                               47.0 ( 29.0 :  18.0) Stockfish 1.8         67
                               45.0 ( 33.5 :  11.5) Naum 4.2               3
                               44.0 ( 33.5 :  10.5) Critter 0.70         -55
                               42.0 ( 33.5 :   8.5) Shredder 12 32-bit   -58
                               48.0 ( 40.0 :   8.0) Spark 0.4           -112
                               47.0 ( 40.0 :   7.0) Zappa Mexico II     -145


Stefan
Posts: 10
Joined: Wed Jun 16, 2010 5:43 pm
Real Name: Stefan Schiffermüller

Re: New Rating List

Post by Stefan » Fri Jul 16, 2010 6:25 pm

Hallo gaard,

great work! I will wait for the next results. Do you know that there is also the new Ivanhoe 54?

gaard
Posts: 127
Joined: Thu Jun 10, 2010 1:39 am
Real Name: Martin Wyngaarden
Location: Holland, Michigan

Re: New Rating List

Post by gaard » Fri Jul 16, 2010 7:54 pm

Stefan wrote:Hallo gaard,

great work! I will wait for the next results. Do you know that there is also the new Ivanhoe 54?

Code: Select all

Rank Name                 Elo    +    - games score oppo. draws 
   1 Houdini 1.03         142   24   24   530   71%   -10   36% 
   2 IvanHoe 9.57a        118   38   38   160   54%    92   58% 
   3 Rybka 4              114   28   28   347   61%    32   38% 
   4 Houdini 1.02         111   21   21   674   69%   -27   38% 
   5 Stockfish 1.8         66   27   27   385   57%    15   38% 
   6 Naum 4.2               1   31   31   285   40%    65   37% 
   7 Shredder 12 32-bit   -57   30   30   332   42%    -2   30% 
   8 Critter 0.70         -57   31   32   301   34%    54   32% 
   9 Spark 0.4           -114   29   30   369   28%    44   28% 
  10 Zappa Mexico II     -144   31   31   350   29%    17   29% 
  11 Toga II 1.4beta5c   -181   33   34   279   30%   -31   29% 

   1 Houdini 1.03         142 530.0 (378.5 : 151.5)
                               63.0 ( 32.0 :  31.0) IvanHoe 9.57a        118
                               68.0 ( 38.0 :  30.0) Rybka 4              114
                               67.0 ( 41.5 :  25.5) Stockfish 1.8         66
                               66.0 ( 49.5 :  16.5) Naum 4.2               1
                               62.0 ( 48.5 :  13.5) Shredder 12 32-bit   -57
                               65.0 ( 51.0 :  14.0) Critter 0.70         -57
                               70.0 ( 59.0 :  11.0) Spark 0.4           -114
                               69.0 ( 59.0 :  10.0) Zappa Mexico II     -144
530 games now and still showing an improvement of 31 Elo. I am aware of the new IvanHoe 54 and have it, but I think it is mostly RobbBuild bug fixes, along with some fixes for large page support. I never had an issue with 9.57a and don't use RobboBuild or large pages so the performance should be the same.
CHANGE_LOG wrote: 999956 Latest RobboBuild.....
999955 Robbo UnLoad plus DeRegister
fix bug in search.c with REPETITION and pointers
Bug: Qrrf fails compress
999954 ac-knowledge LARGE_PAGES (Linux)

Eduard Nemeth
Posts: 632
Joined: Thu Jun 10, 2010 12:50 am

Re: New Rating List

Post by Eduard Nemeth » Fri Jul 16, 2010 8:32 pm

Interesting Rating List!
(much better than all others)

Make it up!

Is possible that you set here an attachment with all variants as PGN Database?

ED.
Peace be with you!

gaard
Posts: 127
Joined: Thu Jun 10, 2010 1:39 am
Real Name: Martin Wyngaarden
Location: Holland, Michigan

Re: New Rating List

Post by gaard » Sat Jul 17, 2010 8:58 am

Eduard Nemeth wrote:Interesting Rating List!
(much better than all others)

Make it up!

Is possible that you set here an attachment with all variants as PGN Database?

ED.
http://www.mediafire.com/file/xgr7v5ka2s7l2t0/NewHRR.7z

Here is a link with the 60 position test suite I use and the games played so far and here are the ratings and scores:

Code: Select all

Rank Name                 Elo    +    - games score oppo. draws 
   1 Houdini 1.03         138   19   19   856   71%   -11   36% 
   2 IvanHoe 9.57a        117   34   34   199   53%   100   58% 
   3 Houdini 1.02         112   21   21   674   69%   -26   38% 
   4 Rybka 4              111   27   26   386   59%    43   39% 
   5 Stockfish 1.8         69   25   25   425   56%    26   38% 
   6 Naum 4.2              -1   29   29   326   38%    73   37% 
   7 Shredder 12 32-bit   -57   28   29   371   40%    13   29% 
   8 Critter 0.70         -60   29   30   343   32%    64   31% 
   9 Spark 0.4           -111   28   28   412   27%    54   27% 
  10 Zappa Mexico II     -140   29   30   393   28%    30   29% 
  11 Toga II 1.4beta5c   -179   33   34   279   30%   -29   29% 

   1 Houdini 1.03         138 856.0 (607.0 : 249.0)
                              102.0 ( 53.0 :  49.0) IvanHoe 9.57a        117
                              107.0 ( 61.0 :  46.0) Rybka 4              111
                              107.0 ( 63.5 :  43.5) Stockfish 1.8         69
                              107.0 ( 79.5 :  27.5) Naum 4.2              -1
                              101.0 ( 78.5 :  22.5) Shredder 12 32-bit   -57
                              107.0 ( 84.0 :  23.0) Critter 0.70         -60
                              113.0 ( 93.0 :  20.0) Spark 0.4           -111
                              112.0 ( 94.5 :  17.5) Zappa Mexico II     -140

Eduard Nemeth
Posts: 632
Joined: Thu Jun 10, 2010 12:50 am

Re: New Rating List

Post by Eduard Nemeth » Sat Jul 17, 2010 5:08 pm

gaard wrote:
Eduard Nemeth wrote:Interesting Rating List!
(much better than all others)

Make it up!

Is possible that you set here an attachment with all variants as PGN Database?

ED.
http://www.mediafire.com/file/xgr7v5ka2s7l2t0/NewHRR.7z

Here is a link with the 60 position test suite I use and the games played so far and here are the ratings and scores:
Thank you very much!

ED.
Peace be with you!

gaard
Posts: 127
Joined: Thu Jun 10, 2010 1:39 am
Real Name: Martin Wyngaarden
Location: Holland, Michigan

Re: New Rating List

Post by gaard » Mon Jul 19, 2010 3:11 am

Last update for a while:

Houdini 1.03 vs Rybka 4: +37-22=50: LOS=98%

Code: Select all

Rank Name                 Elo    +    - games score oppo. draws 
   1 Houdini 1.03         141   19   18   898   71%   -15   35% 
   2 Rybka 4              125   17   17  1083   68%    -8   34% 
   3 IvanHoe 9.57a        114   27   27   313   51%   106   54% 
   4 Houdini 1.02         113   21   21   674   69%   -26   38% 
   5 Stockfish 1.8         73   23   23   540   55%    33   38% 
   6 Naum 4.2              -2   25   26   437   37%    83   35% 
   7 Shredder 12 32-bit   -51   26   26   456   38%    31   31% 
   8 Critter 0.70         -54   26   27   438   31%    76   31% 
   9 Spark 0.4           -119   24   25   547   26%    61   26% 
  10 Zappa Mexico II     -143   28   29   434   27%    36   29% 
  11 Toga II 1.4beta5c   -196   28   29   450   24%    13   25% 

   1 Houdini 1.03         141 898.0 (642.0 : 256.0)
                              109.0 ( 62.0 :  47.0) Rybka 4              125
                              104.0 ( 54.5 :  49.5) IvanHoe 9.57a        114
                              109.0 ( 64.0 :  45.0) Stockfish 1.8         73
                              109.0 ( 81.0 :  28.0) Naum 4.2              -2
                              103.0 ( 79.5 :  23.5) Shredder 12 32-bit   -51
                              108.0 ( 85.0 :  23.0) Critter 0.70         -54
                              116.0 ( 96.0 :  20.0) Spark 0.4           -119
                              115.0 ( 97.0 :  18.0) Zappa Mexico II     -143
                               25.0 ( 23.0 :   2.0) Toga II 1.4beta5c   -196
   2 Rybka 4              125 1083.0 (735.5 : 347.5)
                              109.0 ( 47.0 :  62.0) Houdini 1.03         141
                              111.0 ( 56.5 :  54.5) IvanHoe 9.57a        114
                              110.0 ( 56.5 :  53.5) Houdini 1.02         113
                              107.0 ( 65.0 :  42.0) Stockfish 1.8         73
                              120.0 ( 86.5 :  33.5) Naum 4.2              -2
                              112.0 ( 81.0 :  31.0) Shredder 12 32-bit   -51
                              120.0 ( 90.0 :  30.0) Critter 0.70         -54
                              107.0 ( 90.0 :  17.0) Spark 0.4           -119
                               94.0 ( 77.5 :  16.5) Zappa Mexico II     -143
                               93.0 ( 85.5 :   7.5) Toga II 1.4beta5c   -196
   3 IvanHoe 9.57a        114 313.0 (159.0 : 154.0)
                              104.0 ( 49.5 :  54.5) Houdini 1.03         141
                              111.0 ( 54.5 :  56.5) Rybka 4              125
                               53.0 ( 26.0 :  27.0) Houdini 1.02         113
                                2.0 (  1.0 :   1.0) Stockfish 1.8         73
                               31.0 ( 18.5 :  12.5) Naum 4.2              -2
                                2.0 (  1.5 :   0.5) Shredder 12 32-bit   -51
                                3.0 (  2.0 :   1.0) Critter 0.70         -54
                                2.0 (  2.0 :   0.0) Spark 0.4           -119
                                3.0 (  2.5 :   0.5) Zappa Mexico II     -143
                                2.0 (  1.5 :   0.5) Toga II 1.4beta5c   -196
   4 Houdini 1.02         113 674.0 (466.5 : 207.5)
                              110.0 ( 53.5 :  56.5) Rybka 4              125
                               53.0 ( 27.0 :  26.0) IvanHoe 9.57a        114
                               92.0 ( 51.0 :  41.0) Stockfish 1.8         73
                               63.0 ( 45.5 :  17.5) Naum 4.2              -2
                               54.0 ( 38.0 :  16.0) Shredder 12 32-bit   -51
                               62.0 ( 51.0 :  11.0) Critter 0.70         -54
                               54.0 ( 42.5 :  11.5) Spark 0.4           -119
                               93.0 ( 77.5 :  15.5) Zappa Mexico II     -143
                               93.0 ( 80.5 :  12.5) Toga II 1.4beta5c   -196
   5 Stockfish 1.8         73 540.0 (296.5 : 243.5)
                              109.0 ( 45.0 :  64.0) Houdini 1.03         141
                              107.0 ( 42.0 :  65.0) Rybka 4              125
                                2.0 (  1.0 :   1.0) IvanHoe 9.57a        114
                               92.0 ( 41.0 :  51.0) Houdini 1.02         113
                               41.0 ( 22.0 :  19.0) Naum 4.2              -2
                                5.0 (  2.5 :   2.5) Shredder 12 32-bit   -51
                               41.0 ( 26.5 :  14.5) Critter 0.70         -54
                              116.0 ( 91.5 :  24.5) Spark 0.4           -119
                                3.0 (  3.0 :   0.0) Zappa Mexico II     -143
                               24.0 ( 22.0 :   2.0) Toga II 1.4beta5c   -196
   6 Naum 4.2              -2 437.0 (161.0 : 276.0)
                              109.0 ( 28.0 :  81.0) Houdini 1.03         141
                              120.0 ( 33.5 :  86.5) Rybka 4              125
                               31.0 ( 12.5 :  18.5) IvanHoe 9.57a        114
                               63.0 ( 17.5 :  45.5) Houdini 1.02         113
                               41.0 ( 19.0 :  22.0) Stockfish 1.8         73
                                2.0 (  2.0 :   0.0) Shredder 12 32-bit   -51
                               41.0 ( 24.5 :  16.5) Critter 0.70         -54
                                3.0 (  1.5 :   1.5) Spark 0.4           -119
                                2.0 (  2.0 :   0.0) Zappa Mexico II     -143
                               25.0 ( 20.5 :   4.5) Toga II 1.4beta5c   -196
   7 Shredder 12 32-bit   -51 456.0 (172.5 : 283.5)
                              103.0 ( 23.5 :  79.5) Houdini 1.03         141
                              112.0 ( 31.0 :  81.0) Rybka 4              125
                                2.0 (  0.5 :   1.5) IvanHoe 9.57a        114
                               54.0 ( 16.0 :  38.0) Houdini 1.02         113
                                5.0 (  2.5 :   2.5) Stockfish 1.8         73
                                2.0 (  0.0 :   2.0) Naum 4.2              -2
                               32.0 ( 14.5 :  17.5) Critter 0.70         -54
                              120.0 ( 67.0 :  53.0) Spark 0.4           -119
                                2.0 (  1.0 :   1.0) Zappa Mexico II     -143
                               24.0 ( 16.5 :   7.5) Toga II 1.4beta5c   -196
   8 Critter 0.70         -54 438.0 (136.5 : 301.5)
                              108.0 ( 23.0 :  85.0) Houdini 1.03         141
                              120.0 ( 30.0 :  90.0) Rybka 4              125
                                3.0 (  1.0 :   2.0) IvanHoe 9.57a        114
                               62.0 ( 11.0 :  51.0) Houdini 1.02         113
                               41.0 ( 14.5 :  26.5) Stockfish 1.8         73
                               41.0 ( 16.5 :  24.5) Naum 4.2              -2
                               32.0 ( 17.5 :  14.5) Shredder 12 32-bit   -51
                                2.0 (  2.0 :   0.0) Spark 0.4           -119
                                4.0 (  3.5 :   0.5) Zappa Mexico II     -143
                               25.0 ( 17.5 :   7.5) Toga II 1.4beta5c   -196
   9 Spark 0.4           -119 547.0 (142.0 : 405.0)
                              116.0 ( 20.0 :  96.0) Houdini 1.03         141
                              107.0 ( 17.0 :  90.0) Rybka 4              125
                                2.0 (  0.0 :   2.0) IvanHoe 9.57a        114
                               54.0 ( 11.5 :  42.5) Houdini 1.02         113
                              116.0 ( 24.5 :  91.5) Stockfish 1.8         73
                                3.0 (  1.5 :   1.5) Naum 4.2              -2
                              120.0 ( 53.0 :  67.0) Shredder 12 32-bit   -51
                                2.0 (  0.0 :   2.0) Critter 0.70         -54
                                3.0 (  1.5 :   1.5) Zappa Mexico II     -143
                               24.0 ( 13.0 :  11.0) Toga II 1.4beta5c   -196
  10 Zappa Mexico II     -143 434.0 (116.0 : 318.0)
                              115.0 ( 18.0 :  97.0) Houdini 1.03         141
                               94.0 ( 16.5 :  77.5) Rybka 4              125
                                3.0 (  0.5 :   2.5) IvanHoe 9.57a        114
                               93.0 ( 15.5 :  77.5) Houdini 1.02         113
                                3.0 (  0.0 :   3.0) Stockfish 1.8         73
                                2.0 (  0.0 :   2.0) Naum 4.2              -2
                                2.0 (  1.0 :   1.0) Shredder 12 32-bit   -51
                                4.0 (  0.5 :   3.5) Critter 0.70         -54
                                3.0 (  1.5 :   1.5) Spark 0.4           -119
                              115.0 ( 62.5 :  52.5) Toga II 1.4beta5c   -196
  11 Toga II 1.4beta5c   -196 450.0 (107.5 : 342.5)
                               25.0 (  2.0 :  23.0) Houdini 1.03         141
                               93.0 (  7.5 :  85.5) Rybka 4              125
                                2.0 (  0.5 :   1.5) IvanHoe 9.57a        114
                               93.0 ( 12.5 :  80.5) Houdini 1.02         113
                               24.0 (  2.0 :  22.0) Stockfish 1.8         73
                               25.0 (  4.5 :  20.5) Naum 4.2              -2
                               24.0 (  7.5 :  16.5) Shredder 12 32-bit   -51
                               25.0 (  7.5 :  17.5) Critter 0.70         -54
                               24.0 ( 11.0 :  13.0) Spark 0.4           -119
                              115.0 ( 52.5 :  62.5) Zappa Mexico II     -143

gaard
Posts: 127
Joined: Thu Jun 10, 2010 1:39 am
Real Name: Martin Wyngaarden
Location: Holland, Michigan

Re: New Rating List

Post by gaard » Fri Jul 30, 2010 9:30 am

2000+ games added:

Code: Select all

Rank Name                 Elo    +    - games score oppo. draws 
   1 Houdini 1.03         139   18   17  1038   72%   -28   35% 
   2 Rybka 4              127   17   16  1164   69%   -13   33% 
   3 IvanHoe 9.57a        114   18   18   870   64%    13   41% 
   4 Houdini 1.02         114   21   21   674   69%   -26   38% 
   5 Stockfish 1.8         71   17   17  1051   60%    -6   35% 
   6 Naum 4.2               6   17   17  1027   51%    -2   36% 
   7 Shredder 12 32-bit   -54   23   24   550   38%    26   31% 
   8 Critter 0.70         -63   17   17  1033   40%     6   32% 
   9 Spark 0.4           -125   17   17  1107   32%     6   29% 
  10 Zappa Mexico II     -137   18   18   993   30%     9   31% 
  11 Toga II 1.4beta5c   -191   19   19   973   24%    15   25% 



   1 Houdini 1.03        139 1038.0 (752.5 : 285.5)
                              115.0 ( 65.0 :  50.0) Rybka 4              127
                              120.0 ( 62.0 :  58.0) IvanHoe 9.57a        114
                              115.0 ( 68.0 :  47.0) Stockfish 1.8         71
                              116.0 ( 87.0 :  29.0) Naum 4.2               6
                              103.0 ( 79.5 :  23.5) Shredder 12 32-bit   -54
                              116.0 ( 91.5 :  24.5) Critter 0.70         -63
                              116.0 ( 96.0 :  20.0) Spark 0.4           -125
                              120.0 (102.0 :  18.0) Zappa Mexico II     -137
                              117.0 (101.5 :  15.5) Toga II 1.4beta5c   -191
   2 Rybka 4              127 1164.0 (799.0 : 365.0)
                              115.0 ( 50.0 :  65.0) Houdini 1.03         139
                              120.0 ( 62.5 :  57.5) IvanHoe 9.57a        114
                              110.0 ( 56.5 :  53.5) Houdini 1.02         114
                              116.0 ( 69.5 :  46.5) Stockfish 1.8         71
                              120.0 ( 86.5 :  33.5) Naum 4.2               6
                              112.0 ( 81.0 :  31.0) Shredder 12 32-bit   -54
                              120.0 ( 90.0 :  30.0) Critter 0.70         -63
                              115.0 ( 96.5 :  18.5) Spark 0.4           -125
                              120.0 (100.5 :  19.5) Zappa Mexico II     -137
                              116.0 (106.0 :  10.0) Toga II 1.4beta5c   -191
   3 IvanHoe 9.57a        114 870.0 (556.0 : 314.0)
                              120.0 ( 58.0 :  62.0) Houdini 1.03         139
                              120.0 ( 57.5 :  62.5) Rybka 4              127
                               53.0 ( 26.0 :  27.0) Houdini 1.02         114
                              120.0 ( 69.5 :  50.5) Stockfish 1.8         71
                              120.0 ( 73.0 :  47.0) Naum 4.2               6
                               27.0 ( 20.0 :   7.0) Shredder 12 32-bit   -54
                              120.0 ( 96.0 :  24.0) Critter 0.70         -63
                              120.0 ( 98.0 :  22.0) Spark 0.4           -125
                               35.0 ( 27.0 :   8.0) Zappa Mexico II     -137
                               35.0 ( 31.0 :   4.0) Toga II 1.4beta5c   -191
   4 Houdini 1.02         114 674.0 (466.5 : 207.5)
                              110.0 ( 53.5 :  56.5) Rybka 4              127
                               53.0 ( 27.0 :  26.0) IvanHoe 9.57a        114
                               92.0 ( 51.0 :  41.0) Stockfish 1.8         71
                               63.0 ( 45.5 :  17.5) Naum 4.2               6
                               54.0 ( 38.0 :  16.0) Shredder 12 32-bit   -54
                               62.0 ( 51.0 :  11.0) Critter 0.70         -63
                               54.0 ( 42.5 :  11.5) Spark 0.4           -125
                               93.0 ( 77.5 :  15.5) Zappa Mexico II     -137
                               93.0 ( 80.5 :  12.5) Toga II 1.4beta5c   -191
   5 Stockfish 1.8         71 1051.0 (631.0 : 420.0)
                              115.0 ( 47.0 :  68.0) Houdini 1.03         139
                              116.0 ( 46.5 :  69.5) Rybka 4              127
                              120.0 ( 50.5 :  69.5) IvanHoe 9.57a        114
                               92.0 ( 41.0 :  51.0) Houdini 1.02         114
                              115.0 ( 66.0 :  49.0) Naum 4.2               6
                               25.0 ( 16.5 :   8.5) Shredder 12 32-bit   -54
                              116.0 ( 82.5 :  33.5) Critter 0.70         -63
                              116.0 ( 91.5 :  24.5) Spark 0.4           -125
                              120.0 ( 91.0 :  29.0) Zappa Mexico II     -137
                              116.0 ( 98.5 :  17.5) Toga II 1.4beta5c   -191
   6 Naum 4.2               6 1027.0 (520.5 : 506.5)
                              116.0 ( 29.0 :  87.0) Houdini 1.03         139
                              120.0 ( 33.5 :  86.5) Rybka 4              127
                              120.0 ( 47.0 :  73.0) IvanHoe 9.57a        114
                               63.0 ( 17.5 :  45.5) Houdini 1.02         114
                              115.0 ( 49.0 :  66.0) Stockfish 1.8         71
                               26.0 ( 17.0 :   9.0) Shredder 12 32-bit   -54
                              115.0 ( 71.5 :  43.5) Critter 0.70         -63
                              115.0 ( 79.0 :  36.0) Spark 0.4           -125
                              120.0 ( 88.0 :  32.0) Zappa Mexico II     -137
                              117.0 ( 89.0 :  28.0) Toga II 1.4beta5c   -191
   7 Shredder 12 32-bit   -54 550.0 (211.0 : 339.0)
                              103.0 ( 23.5 :  79.5) Houdini 1.03         139
                              112.0 ( 31.0 :  81.0) Rybka 4              127
                               27.0 (  7.0 :  20.0) IvanHoe 9.57a        114
                               54.0 ( 16.0 :  38.0) Houdini 1.02         114
                               25.0 (  8.5 :  16.5) Stockfish 1.8         71
                               26.0 (  9.0 :  17.0) Naum 4.2               6
                               32.0 ( 14.5 :  17.5) Critter 0.70         -63
                              120.0 ( 67.0 :  53.0) Spark 0.4           -125
                               25.0 ( 16.0 :   9.0) Zappa Mexico II     -137
                               26.0 ( 18.5 :   7.5) Toga II 1.4beta5c   -191
   8 Critter 0.70         -63 1033.0 (412.0 : 621.0)
                              116.0 ( 24.5 :  91.5) Houdini 1.03         139
                              120.0 ( 30.0 :  90.0) Rybka 4              127
                              120.0 ( 24.0 :  96.0) IvanHoe 9.57a        114
                               62.0 ( 11.0 :  51.0) Houdini 1.02         114
                              116.0 ( 33.5 :  82.5) Stockfish 1.8         71
                              115.0 ( 43.5 :  71.5) Naum 4.2               6
                               32.0 ( 17.5 :  14.5) Shredder 12 32-bit   -54
                              115.0 ( 68.5 :  46.5) Spark 0.4           -125
                              120.0 ( 76.5 :  43.5) Zappa Mexico II     -137
                              117.0 ( 83.0 :  34.0) Toga II 1.4beta5c   -191
   9 Spark 0.4           -125 1107.0 (359.0 : 748.0)
                              116.0 ( 20.0 :  96.0) Houdini 1.03         139
                              115.0 ( 18.5 :  96.5) Rybka 4              127
                              120.0 ( 22.0 :  98.0) IvanHoe 9.57a        114
                               54.0 ( 11.5 :  42.5) Houdini 1.02         114
                              116.0 ( 24.5 :  91.5) Stockfish 1.8         71
                              115.0 ( 36.0 :  79.0) Naum 4.2               6
                              120.0 ( 53.0 :  67.0) Shredder 12 32-bit   -54
                              115.0 ( 46.5 :  68.5) Critter 0.70         -63
                              120.0 ( 56.5 :  63.5) Zappa Mexico II     -137
                              116.0 ( 70.5 :  45.5) Toga II 1.4beta5c   -191
  10 Zappa Mexico II     -137 993.0 (301.5 : 691.5)
                              120.0 ( 18.0 : 102.0) Houdini 1.03         139
                              120.0 ( 19.5 : 100.5) Rybka 4              127
                               35.0 (  8.0 :  27.0) IvanHoe 9.57a        114
                               93.0 ( 15.5 :  77.5) Houdini 1.02         114
                              120.0 ( 29.0 :  91.0) Stockfish 1.8         71
                              120.0 ( 32.0 :  88.0) Naum 4.2               6
                               25.0 (  9.0 :  16.0) Shredder 12 32-bit   -54
                              120.0 ( 43.5 :  76.5) Critter 0.70         -63
                              120.0 ( 63.5 :  56.5) Spark 0.4           -125
                              120.0 ( 63.5 :  56.5) Toga II 1.4beta5c   -191
  11 Toga II 1.4beta5c   -191 973.0 (231.0 : 742.0)
                              117.0 ( 15.5 : 101.5) Houdini 1.03         139
                              116.0 ( 10.0 : 106.0) Rybka 4              127
                               35.0 (  4.0 :  31.0) IvanHoe 9.57a        114
                               93.0 ( 12.5 :  80.5) Houdini 1.02         114
                              116.0 ( 17.5 :  98.5) Stockfish 1.8         71
                              117.0 ( 28.0 :  89.0) Naum 4.2               6
                               26.0 (  7.5 :  18.5) Shredder 12 32-bit   -54
                              117.0 ( 34.0 :  83.0) Critter 0.70         -63
                              116.0 ( 45.5 :  70.5) Spark 0.4           -125
                              120.0 ( 56.5 :  63.5) Zappa Mexico II     -137

Post Reply