Crafty

General discussion about computer chess...
User avatar
Sean Evans
Posts: 173
Joined: Fri Jun 11, 2010 1:21 am
Real Name: Sean Evans

Crafty

Post by Sean Evans » Mon Sep 10, 2012 12:05 am

"I feel the program Crafty is no longer in the top 100 programs. I feel it is a run of the mill program now much like the author."

I made the above statements at CCC and the post was removed and Julien's PM told me I am libel. I broke some sort of CCC rule.

Telling the truth does not make someone libel and it is not against the CCC rules!

Cordially,

Sean Evans

hyatt
Posts: 1242
Joined: Thu Jun 10, 2010 2:13 am
Real Name: Bob Hyatt (Robert M. Hyatt)
Location: University of Alabama at Birmingham
Contact:

Re: Crafty

Post by hyatt » Mon Sep 10, 2012 5:34 am

"opinions are like assholes... Everybody has one, and NOBODY wants to look at anyone elses..."

Your opinion is your opinion. Doesn't mean it is fact.

BTW, remind me again what the name of YOUR program is? Or are you a "non-author" as opposed to a "run of the mill author"? Know which one I had rather be, for the record...

Adam Hair
Posts: 104
Joined: Fri Jun 11, 2010 4:29 am
Real Name: Adam Hair
Contact:

Re: Crafty

Post by Adam Hair » Mon Sep 10, 2012 5:45 pm

Sean Evans wrote:"I feel the program Crafty is no longer in the top 100 programs. I feel it is a run of the mill program now much like the author."

I made the above statements at CCC and the post was removed and Julien's PM told me I am libel. I broke some sort of CCC rule.

Telling the truth does not make someone libel and it is not against the CCC rules!

Cordially,

Sean Evans

libel
1) n. to publish in print (including pictures), writing or broadcast through radio, television or film, an untruth about another which will do harm to that person or his/her reputation, by tending to bring the target into ridicule, hatred, scorn or contempt of others.

Let's review your "statement" for a moment. Is Crafty a top 100 program? Despite what you may "feel", Crafty is a top 30 to 40 engine, as measured by the various rating lists. If it were tested at 64bits with 4 cpus and we considered only best versions for each engine family, it is easily a top 30 engine. So that is a false statement. An untruth. And it appears that the only purpose of your statement was to jab at Bob. It was a malicious statement, and there is no reason to allow one person to do that to another person. If you want to be critical of someone, do it in a way that is not an attack.

User avatar
Sean Evans
Posts: 173
Joined: Fri Jun 11, 2010 1:21 am
Real Name: Sean Evans

Re: Crafty

Post by Sean Evans » Mon Sep 10, 2012 9:16 pm

Adam Hair wrote:
Sean Evans wrote:"I feel the program Crafty is no longer in the top 100 programs. I feel it is a run of the mill program now much like the author."

I made the above statements at CCC and the post was removed and Julien's PM told me I am libel. I broke some sort of CCC rule.

Telling the truth does not make someone libel and it is not against the CCC rules!

Cordially,

Sean Evans

libel
1) n. to publish in print (including pictures), writing or broadcast through radio, television or film, an untruth about another which will do harm to that person or his/her reputation, by tending to bring the target into ridicule, hatred, scorn or contempt of others.

Let's review your "statement" for a moment. Is Crafty a top 100 program? Despite what you may "feel", Crafty is a top 30 to 40 engine, as measured by the various rating lists. If it were tested at 64bits with 4 cpus and we considered only best versions for each engine family, it is easily a top 30 engine. So that is a false statement. An untruth. And it appears that the only purpose of your statement was to jab at Bob. It was a malicious statement, and there is no reason to allow one person to do that to another person. If you want to be critical of someone, do it in a way that is not an attack.
Read'em and Weep :lol:

107 Crafty 23.1 JA 2534 9 10 3800 26% 2723 28%

User923005
Posts: 616
Joined: Thu May 19, 2011 1:35 am

Re: Crafty

Post by User923005 » Tue Sep 11, 2012 6:55 am

Single CPU, probably 32 bit version.
#29 on this list:
http://www.computerchess.org.uk/ccrl/4040/

At any rate, the purpose of your statements is clear to any thinking person.

There are some people who are truly desperate for attention, and even negative attention seems to fill the void (especially since it is so simple to obtain it). Do you know anyone like that?

Speaking of chessboards, I once saw a girl on the bus who had shaped the hair on her head into squares with a groove down to the scalp about 1/4 inch wide between each square. Each square was a different color. It certainly made heads turn.

User avatar
simonhue
Posts: 14
Joined: Sun Sep 02, 2012 12:02 pm
Real Name: Simon

Re: Crafty

Post by simonhue » Tue Sep 11, 2012 10:15 pm

@OP - I can understand some non-praising statements about Crafty in comparison with nowadays best programs (Although I wouldn't see the point of making such statement), but I can't understand your attempts to offend RH (What the whole statement looks to me). Both has their place in computer chess history IMO, regardless of Crafty's todays or tomorrows placement on any link.

BTW - your link to Crafty being #107 contains multiple entries of one the same engine (same codebase or older minor versions of it), so it's also factually incorrect (It's like if you enter 100 minor variations of the top engine, and then claim any other that exists is not in top100 any more).

Adam Hair
Posts: 104
Joined: Fri Jun 11, 2010 4:29 am
Real Name: Adam Hair
Contact:

Re: Crafty

Post by Adam Hair » Wed Sep 12, 2012 1:34 am

Sean Evans wrote:
Adam Hair wrote:
Sean Evans wrote:"I feel the program Crafty is no longer in the top 100 programs. I feel it is a run of the mill program now much like the author."

I made the above statements at CCC and the post was removed and Julien's PM told me I am libel. I broke some sort of CCC rule.

Telling the truth does not make someone libel and it is not against the CCC rules!

Cordially,

Sean Evans

libel
1) n. to publish in print (including pictures), writing or broadcast through radio, television or film, an untruth about another which will do harm to that person or his/her reputation, by tending to bring the target into ridicule, hatred, scorn or contempt of others.

Let's review your "statement" for a moment. Is Crafty a top 100 program? Despite what you may "feel", Crafty is a top 30 to 40 engine, as measured by the various rating lists. If it were tested at 64bits with 4 cpus and we considered only best versions for each engine family, it is easily a top 30 engine. So that is a false statement. An untruth. And it appears that the only purpose of your statement was to jab at Bob. It was a malicious statement, and there is no reason to allow one person to do that to another person. If you want to be critical of someone, do it in a way that is not an attack.
Read'em and Weep :lol:

107 Crafty 23.1 JA 2534 9 10 3800 26% 2723 28%
Can you read? That is Crafty 23.1, which 80 to 100 Elo weaker than Crafty 23.4 (the most recent version). I do not remember the incremental gains Bob measured from v23.1 to v23.4, but I do know that Frank Quinisky measured the difference between v23.2 and 23.4 to be 61 Elo. I measured it to be 65 Elo. So I believe the gain over v23.1 to be 80 to 90 Elo.


As far as your link to IPON goes, there are 8 versions of Stockfish on that list ahead of Crafty. So each of them count? If that is the case, then Crafty can be pushed much lower than 107 (by the way, why not at least use the strongest version of Crafty that Ingo tested, which is v23.3). There must be 50+ different compiles of Robbolito and Ivanhoe out there. Or, I can make minute parameter changes to Stockfish and give a new version number each time. We can push Crafty lower and lower.

But wait! We do not have to go through that trouble. Look at this:

Code: Select all

Rank Name                                      Elo    +    - games score oppo. draws 
   1 Houdini 2.0c 64-bit 6CPU                 3561   15   15  2859   69%  3410   38% 
   2 Houdini 1.5a 64-bit 6CPU                 3552   21   21  1129   72%  3363   36% 
   3 Houdini 2.0c 64-bit 4CPU                 3518   17   17  2050   77%  3295   31% 
   4 Houdini 1.5a 64-bit 4CPU                 3496   15   15  2764   62%  3394   39% 
   5 Critter 1.4 64-bit 6CPU                  3494   18   18  1440   65%  3374   45% 
   6 Stockfish 2.2.2 64-bit 6CPU              3489   22   22   942   63%  3380   45% 
   7 Stockfish 2.2.1 64-bit 6CPU              3485   28   28   559   66%  3360   44% 
   8 Rybka 4.1 64-bit 6CPU                    3483   15   15  2665   57%  3424   45% 
   9 Critter 1.2 64-bit 6CPU                  3480   18   18  1425   64%  3368   43% 
  10 Stockfish 2.1.1 64-bit 6CPU              3475   15   15  2419   56%  3428   49% 
  11 IvanHoe 9.46h 64-bit 6CPU                3465   18   18  1417   63%  3360   44% 
  12 Critter 1.2 64-bit 4CPU                  3447   18   18  1381   67%  3307   40% 
  13 Rybka 4.1 64-bit 4CPU                    3445   16   16  2045   63%  3335   40% 
  14 Houdini 2.0c 64-bit                      3441   18   18  1504   69%  3283   32% 
  15 Vitruvius 1.11C HEM 64-bit 6CPU          3438   26   26   801   71%  3252   40% 
  16 Rybka 4 64-bit 4CPU                      3432   15   15  2339   70%  3273   40% 
  17 Stockfish 2.1.1 64-bit 4CPU              3432   16   16  1897   60%  3349   44% 
  18 Houdini 1.5a 64-bit                      3402   13   13  3147   69%  3243   31% 
  19 Rybka 3 Dynamic 64-bit 4CPU              3401   25   25   853   80%  3155   29% 
  20 Rybka 3 64-bit 4CPU                      3399   11   11  5174   77%  3168   31% 
  21 Stockfish 2.0.1 64-bit 4CPU              3399   17   17  1647   67%  3270   43% 
  22 Critter 1.01 64-bit 4CPU                 3386   19   19  1248   66%  3260   38% 
  23 Komodo 5 64-bit                          3383   22   22  1006   69%  3224   32% 
  24 Stockfish 1.9.1 64-bit 4CPU              3383   15   15  2338   71%  3215   38% 
  25 Strelka 5.1 64-bit                       3374   20   20  1078   64%  3258   42% 
  26 Critter 1.4 64-bit                       3373   18   18  1491   67%  3229   39% 
  27 Stockfish 1.7.1 64-bit 4CPU              3370   15   15  2052   68%  3228   38% 
  28 Stockfish 1.8 64-bit 4CPU                3367   18   18  1345   68%  3223   38% 
  29 Komodo 4 64-bit                          3358   12   12  3684   60%  3268   37% 
  30 Critter 0.90 64-bit 4CPU                 3357   17   17  1585   65%  3242   40% 
  31 Rybka 3 64-bit 2CPU                      3349   15   15  2596   79%  3106   29% 
  32 Rybka 4 64-bit 2CPU                      3349   29   29   537   74%  3163   33% 
  33 Critter 1.2 64-bit                       3347   17   17  1627   70%  3177   34% 
  34 Houdini 1.03a 64-bit                     3343   22   22  1183   80%  3075   28% 
  35 Stockfish 2.2.2 64-bit                   3342   19   19  1235   58%  3279   40% 
  36 Rybka 4.1 64-bit                         3337   13   13  2679   62%  3239   39% 
  37 Deep Junior 13 64-bit 6CPU               3334  111  111    32   36%  3438   34% 
  38 Komodo 3 64-bit                          3333   11   11  4535   58%  3265   36% 
  39 Rybka 4 64-bit                           3328   15   15  2109   70%  3167   36% 
  40 Naum 4.2 64-bit 4CPU                     3321   11   11  4708   52%  3304   42% 
  41 Stockfish 1.6s JA 64-bit 4CPU            3317   15   15  2185   67%  3186   39% 
  42 Stockfish 2.1.1 64-bit                   3316   17   17  1546   60%  3235   39% 
  43 Stockfish 1.6.3 64-bit 4CPU              3312   15   15  2172   65%  3191   38% 
  44 Stockfish 2.0.1 64-bit                   3312   22   22  1128   77%  3074   28% 
  45 Rybka 3 64-bit                           3303   10   10  6034   74%  3095   30% 
  46 Critter 1.01 64-bit                      3292   20   20  1252   73%  3086   31% 
  47 Komodo 2.01 64-bit                       3291   17   17  1563   57%  3235   37% 
  48 Komodo 2.03 64-bit                       3291   15   15  1918   56%  3246   39% 
  49 Naum 4.1 64-bit 4CPU                     3291   17   17  1439   61%  3204   40% 
  50 Critter 0.80 64-bit 4CPU                 3289   20   20  1098   59%  3221   40% 
  51 Naum 4 64-bit 4CPU                       3284   12   12  3691   66%  3148   37% 
  52 Stockfish 1.7.1 64-bit 2CPU              3280   23   23   906   74%  3092   35% 
  53 Rybka 3 Human 64-bit                     3280   29   29   650   80%  3019   25% 
  54 Stockfish 1.8 64-bit                     3278   21   21  1169   76%  3050   28% 
  55 Stockfish 1.9.1 64-bit                   3273   21   21  1094   74%  3063   30% 
  56 Critter 0.90 64-bit 2CPU                 3268   23   23   913   74%  3071   32% 
  57 Critter 0.90 64-bit                      3266   20   20  1207   75%  3055   30% 
  58 Stockfish 1.7.1 64-bit                   3265   16   16  1929   71%  3090   34% 
  59 Spike 1.4 Leiden 4CPU                    3264   14   14  2565   39%  3352   37% 
  60 Stockfish 1.6s JA 64-bit 2CPU            3264   29   29   499   63%  3164   43% 
  61 Deep Shredder 12 64-bit OA On 4CPU       3264   11   11  4672   52%  3247   38% 
  62 Rybka 3 32-bit                           3262   42   42   256   74%  3066   34% 
  63 Rybka 3 Dynamic 64-bit                   3257   28   28   648   79%  3019   27% 
  64 Rybka 2.3.2a 64-bit 4CPU                 3256   12   12  3407   70%  3093   36% 
  65 Deep Shredder 12 64-bit OA Off 4CPU      3250   15   15  1996   59%  3180   37% 
  66 Hiarcs 13.2 4CPU                         3249   15   15  1945   47%  3276   39% 
  67 Critter 0.70 64-bit 4CPU                 3248   28   28   515   51%  3243   44% 
  68 Stockfish 1.5.1 64-bit 4CPU              3246   17   17  1597   60%  3169   39% 
  69 Deep Fritz 12 4CPU                       3245   27   27   531   47%  3265   43% 
  70 Naum 4.1 64-bit 2CPU                     3245   22   22  1020   74%  3032   30% 
  71 Naum 4.2 64-bit 2CPU                     3238   21   21  1070   71%  3063   31% 
  72 Spark 1.0 64-bit 4CPU                    3236   12   12  3450   40%  3321   38% 
  73 Stockfish 1.6.3 64-bit 2CPU              3235   20   20  1127   66%  3108   38% 
  74 DeepSaros 3.0 64-bit                     3229  114  114    32   20%  3438   41% 
  75 Deep Junior 13 64-bit 4CPU               3228   22   22   948   45%  3272   35% 
  76 Deep Junior 12.5 64-bit 4CPU             3227   18   18  1447   42%  3292   36% 
  77 Hiarcs 13.1 4CPU                         3221   14   14  2531   44%  3268   38% 
  78 Rybka 2.3.2a 64-bit 2CPU                 3221   12   12  3541   73%  3041   36% 
  79 Stockfish 2.0.1 32-bit                   3217   45   45   237   75%  3017   30% 
  80 Naum 4 64-bit 2CPU                       3214   18   18  1619   76%  2977   29% 
  81 Rybka 2.2n2 64-bit 4CPU                  3214   14   14  2432   58%  3143   41% 
  82 Spark 0.5 64-bit 4CPU                    3210   17   17  1448   46%  3242   41% 
  83 Critter 0.80 64-bit                      3203   20   20  1194   71%  3022   32% 
  84 Komodo 1.3 64-bit                        3201   14   14  2451   56%  3152   39% 
  85 Deep Junior 12 64-bit 4CPU               3199   18   18  1345   43%  3251   38% 
  86 Spark 0.4 64-bit 4CPU                    3198   16   16  1614   47%  3225   42% 
  87 Stockfish 1.6.3 64-bit                   3198   16   16  1730   67%  3063   35% 
  88 Fritz 13                                 3197   12   12  3933   42%  3263   32% 
  89 Rybka 2.3.1 64-bit 2CPU                  3196   29   29   670   81%  2928   22% 
  90 Naum 3 64-bit 4CPU                       3194   13   13  2633   58%  3132   38% 
  91 Critter 0.70 64-bit 2CPU                 3193   21   21  1045   69%  3031   31% 
  92 Deep Shredder 12 64-bit OA On 2CPU       3193   17   17  1707   69%  3020   30% 
  93 Stockfish 1.6s JA 64-bit                 3192   17   17  1501   67%  3062   35% 
  94 Naum 4.2 64-bit                          3191   12   12  3400   50%  3192   39% 
  95 Rybka 2.3.2a 64-bit                      3189    9    9  6088   68%  3045   37% 
  96 Naum 3.1 64-bit 4CPU                     3186   12   12  3686   57%  3133   39% 
  97 Critter 0.70 64-bit                      3185   20   20  1425   74%  2966   24% 
  98 Stockfish 1.4 64-bit 4CPU                3185   17   17  1596   54%  3151   35% 
  99 Spike 1.4 Leiden 2CPU                    3183   21   21  1025   65%  3063   34% 
 100 Protector 1.4.0 64-bit 4CPU              3181   15   15  2435   31%  3344   32% 
 101 Deep Junior 12.5 64-bit 2CPU             3179   21   21  1083   66%  3044   29% 
 102 Chiron 1.1a 64-bit                       3177   19   19  1313   60%  3093   33% 
 103 Spark 0.3 64-bit 4CPU                    3177   14   14  2237   47%  3196   42% 
 104 Rybka 2.2 64-bit 2CPU                    3177   15   15  2432   73%  2983   29% 
 105 Rybka 2.1d3 64-bit 2CPU                  3177   33   33   479   80%  2919   24% 
 106 Komodo 1.2 64-bit                        3175   12   12  3232   60%  3081   34% 
 107 Zappa Mexico II 64-bit 4CPU              3174   10   10  6165   46%  3207   40% 
 108 Spark 0.3a 64-bit 4CPU                   3169   20   20  1093   45%  3209   38% 
 109 Protector 1.3.5 64-bit 4CPU              3168   30   30   455   37%  3268   40% 
 110 Deep Shredder 12 64-bit OA On 1CPU       3167   12   12  3065   55%  3130   37% 
 111 Komodo 1.1 64-bit                        3166   69   69   110   49%  3114   28% 
 112 Naum 4.1 64-bit                          3165   19   19  1158   62%  3073   38% 
 113 Rybka 2.3 LK 64-bit 2CPU                 3161   29   29   608   78%  2918   24% 
 114 Shredder 12 OA on                        3160   22   22   897   59%  3090   38% 
 115 Rybka 2.2n2 64-bit 2CPU                  3160   19   19  1279   70%  2994   31% 
 116 Protector 1.3.4 64-bit 4CPU              3157   15   15  2122   40%  3230   41% 
 117 Thinker 5.4c Inert 64-bit 4CPU           3157   11   11  4942   43%  3209   35% 
 118 Naum 4 64-bit                            3156   14   14  2154   63%  3056   38% 
 119 Rybka 2.1o 64-bit 2CPU                   3155   27   27   678   75%  2942   28% 
 120 Onno 1.2.70 64-bit 4CPU                  3155   14   14  2570   33%  3299   34% 
 121 Zappa Mexico 64-bit 4CPU                 3154   11   11  4198   53%  3132   39% 
 122 Stockfish 1.5.1 64-bit 2CPU              3152   31   31   415   54%  3124   43% 
 123 Gull 1.1 64-bit                          3149   14   14  2294   46%  3176   35% 
 124 Deep Sjeng WC2008 64-bit 4CPU            3148   10   10  5414   44%  3195   34% 
 125 Gull 1.2 64-bit                          3147   16   16  1696   53%  3126   34% 
 126 Deep Junior 11.1a 64-bit 4CPU            3146   16   16  1852   40%  3225   35% 
 127 Gull 1.0a 64-bit                         3146   12   12  3314   56%  3085   33% 
 128 Stockfish 1.9.1 32-bit                   3145  105  105    30   53%  3127   53% 
 129 Hannibal 1.2 64-bit                      3145   22   22   926   50%  3150   34% 
 130 Hiarcs 12 4CPU                           3144   10   10  5355   47%  3170   38% 
 131 Hiarcs 12.1 4CPU                         3144   12   12  3908   47%  3163   35% 
 132 Spark 0.5 64-bit 2CPU                    3144   24   24   697   56%  3100   36% 
 133 Deep Shredder 11 64-bit 4CPU             3143   11   11  4129   52%  3126   33% 
 134 Rybka 2.2n2 64-bit                       3142   21   21  1053   69%  2980   33% 
 135 Tornado 4.88 64-bit 6CPU                 3139   19   19  1323   40%  3225   31% 
 136 Bright 0.5c 6CPU                         3139  253  253     4   50%  3139   50% 
 137 Hiarcs 13.1 2CPU                         3137   22   22   810   56%  3086   41% 
 138 Komodo 1.0 64-bit                        3136   13   13  2822   48%  3150   39% 
 139 Zappa Mexico BugFix 64-bit 4CPU          3135   18   18  1391   55%  3096   41% 
 140 Hiarcs 13.2                              3135   17   17  1498   50%  3135   35% 
 141 Deep Sjeng c't 2010                      3134   21   21   980   47%  3156   37% 
 142 Deep Sjeng 3.0 64-bit 4CPU               3132   10   10  5046   42%  3201   34% 
 143 Hiarcs Paderborn 2007 4CPU               3131   15   15  1982   50%  3134   36% 
 144 Rybka 2.1c 64-bit 2CPU                   3131   26   26   709   75%  2922   27% 
 145 Zap!Chess Zanzibar 64-bit 4CPU           3131   18   18  1396   61%  3047   42% 
 146 Rybka 2.2 64-bit                         3130   27   27   627   74%  2931   29% 
 147 Thinker 5.4a Inert 64-bit 4CPU           3129   15   15  2096   51%  3117   35% 
 148 Rybka 2.1o 64-bit                        3128   31   31   504   76%  2917   29% 
 149 Deep Fritz 10.1 4CPU                     3127   18   18  1446   50%  3123   32% 
 150 Rybka 2.3.2a 32-bit                      3127   18   18  1482   66%  2999   35% 
 151 Spark 1.0 64-bit                         3126   13   13  2962   48%  3145   33% 
 152 Rybka 2.3 64-bit 2CPU                    3125   26   26   728   76%  2912   29% 
 153 Deep Junior 11.2 64-bit 4CPU             3125   19   19  1281   36%  3234   32% 
 154 Thinker 5.3b Inert 64-bit 4CPU           3125   17   17  1468   46%  3157   38% 
 155 Naum 3 64-bit 2CPU                       3125   20   20  1150   69%  2963   33% 
 156 Spark 0.5 64-bit                         3124   20   20  1108   53%  3099   35% 
 157 Naum 3.1 64-bit 2CPU                     3121   28   28   535   52%  3103   37% 
 158 Thinker 5.4a Inert 64-bit 2CPU           3119   15   15  1970   58%  3046   34% 
 159 Spike 1.4 Leiden                         3118   14   14  2266   47%  3139   33% 
 160 Hiarcs 13.1                              3118   20   20  1002   54%  3085   37% 
 161 Glaurung 2.2 64-bit 4CPU                 3116   13   13  2704   51%  3109   37% 
 162 Spark 0.4 64-bit 2CPU                    3114   20   20  1071   64%  2996   35% 
 163 Stockfish 1.5.1 64-bit                   3114   19   19  1170   60%  3040   40% 
 164 Rybka 2.1c 64-bit                        3113   34   34   423   75%  2904   26% 
 165 Hiarcs 11.2 4CPU                         3112   15   15  2954   53%  3093   46% 
 166 Zappa Mexico 64-bit 2CPU                 3111   20   20  1112   56%  3066   38% 
 167 Fritz 12                                 3111   15   15  1953   53%  3086   40% 
 168 Critter 0.60 64-bit 4CPU                 3111   26   26   649   37%  3212   35% 
 169 Thinker 5.3b Inert 64-bit 2CPU           3110   22   22  1017   70%  2935   28% 
 170 Bright 0.4a 4CPU                         3109   13   13  2889   42%  3169   34% 
 171 Hiarcs 11.2 (No TBs) 4CPU                3106   23   23  1033   49%  3112   63% 
 172 Thinker 5.4c Inert 64-bit 2CPU           3104   37   37   292   40%  3176   41% 
 173 Bright 0.5c 4CPU                         3104   17   17  1621   36%  3215   36% 
 174 Toga II 1.4 beta5c 4CPU                  3104   10   10  5121   37%  3209   35% 
 175 Naum 2.2 64-bit 4CPU                     3103   16   16  1787   54%  3076   40% 
 176 Deep Shredder 11 64-bit 4CPU (No EGBBs)  3103   21   21   941   51%  3098   41% 
 177 Zappa Mexico II 64-bit 2CPU              3102   12   12  3019   56%  3052   39% 
 178 Doch 1.3.4 64-bit                        3102   20   20  1024   53%  3080   39% 
 179 Rybka 2.3 LK 32-bit                      3100   26   26   753   77%  2872   23% 
 180 Deep Junior 12.5 64-bit                  3099   20   20  1148   52%  3085   31% 
 181 Toga II 1.4.1SE 4CPU                     3099   12   12  3446   44%  3146   36% 
 182 Hiarcs 11.1 4CPU                         3098   14   14  2190   54%  3064   39% 
 183 Deep Junior 13 64-bit                    3097   19   19  1177   52%  3082   34% 
 184 Glaurung 2.1 64-bit 4CPU                 3097   13   13  2786   45%  3139   35% 
 185 Rybka 2.3.1 32-bit                       3097   19   19  1494   76%  2884   26% 
 186 Quazar 0.4 64-bit                        3095   19   19  1392   68%  2944   30% 
 187 Onno 1.2.70 64-bit 2CPU                  3095   19   19  1169   54%  3061   35% 
 188 Hannibal 1.1 64-bit                      3095   16   16  1811   50%  3098   32% 
 189 Rybka 2.2 32-bit                         3095   17   17  1759   75%  2886   28% 
 190 Komodo 1.3 32-bit                        3092   39   39   280   61%  3003   41% 
 191 Fritz 11                                 3089   10   10  4910   54%  3053   39% 
 192 Bright 0.3d 4CPU                         3089   16   16  1889   43%  3142   35% 
 193 Protector 1.4.0 64-bit                   3086   16   16  1833   48%  3107   31% 
 194 Thinker 5.4d Inert 64-bit                3083   14   14  2412   46%  3116   36% 
 195 Hiarcs 12.1 2CPU                         3082   18   18  1402   64%  2965   31% 
 196 Thinker 5.4c Inert 64-bit                3082   10   10  4850   53%  3059   35% 
 197 Spark 0.4 64-bit                         3082   12   12  3231   57%  3020   34% 
 198 Hiarcs 12 2CPU                           3082   16   16  1731   59%  3007   36% 
 199 Thinker 5.4a Inert 64-bit                3081   16   16  1740   45%  3120   37% 
 200 Deep Sjeng WC2008 64-bit 2CPU            3077   16   16  1819   57%  3014   34% 
 201 Deep Sjeng 3.0 64-bit 2CPU               3077   15   15  1977   54%  3039   33% 
 202 Deep Shredder 11 64-bit 2CPU             3076   15   15  1997   53%  3049   35% 
 203 Deep Junior 12.5 nobook 64-bit           3076  113  113    31   34%  3197   29% 
 204 Loop M1-T 64-bit 4CPU                    3075   10   10  5759   44%  3122   36% 
 205 Rybka 2.3 32-bit                         3073   34   34   431   78%  2843   26% 
 206 Toga II 1.4.1SE 2CPU                     3073   34   34   342   42%  3134   40% 
 207 Stockfish 1.4 64-bit                     3072   21   21   930   54%  3046   39% 
 208 Bright 0.3b 4CPU                         3070   15   15  2193   41%  3142   33% 
 209 Naum 2.2 64-bit 2CPU                     3070   23   23   830   60%  2992   37% 
 210 Thinker 5.3b Inert 64-bit                3066   26   26   609   51%  3056   37% 
 211 Glaurung 2.2 64-bit 2CPU                 3065   14   14  2192   50%  3060   32% 
 212 Critter 0.60 64-bit                      3063   18   18  1249   47%  3091   35% 
 213 Rybka 1.2f 32-bit                        3063   16   16  1699   67%  2929   36% 
 214 Doch 1.2 64-bit                          3062   20   20  1048   48%  3078   37% 
 215 Naum 3.1 64-bit                          3062   16   16  1777   50%  3057   38% 
 216 Hannibal 1.0a 64-bit                     3060   14   14  2365   52%  3039   30% 
 217 Hiarcs 11.1 2CPU                         3059   17   17  1447   53%  3032   36% 
 218 Rybka 2.1o 32-bit                        3059   17   17  1554   69%  2901   31% 
 219 Deep Junior 11.2 64-bit 2CPU             3055   22   22   917   50%  3058   32% 
 220 Loop 13.6 (Loop 2007) 64-bit 4CPU        3055   19   19  1163   44%  3103   39% 
 221 Deep Junior 11.1a 64-bit 2CPU            3055   20   20  1050   60%  2975   33% 
 222 Hannibal 05_24_10v2 64-bit               3055   34   34   350   43%  3107   33% 
 223 Strelka 2.0 B 64-bit                     3054   18   18  1325   56%  3008   33% 
 224 Doch 09.980 64-bit                       3053   19   19  1175   48%  3066   37% 
 225 Protector 1.3.5 64-bit                   3053   16   16  1814   58%  2982   30% 
 226 Glaurung 2.0.1 64-bit 4CPU               3053   14   14  2360   39%  3137   34% 
 227 Nemo 1.0.1b 64-bit                       3052   18   18  1279   55%  3015   35% 
 228 BugChess2 1.9 64-bit 4CPU                3051   23   23   795   57%  2998   32% 
 229 Naum 3 64-bit                            3051   19   19  1256   49%  3057   36% 
 230 Rybka 1.1 32-bit                         3051   23   23   769   66%  2923   39% 
 231 Rybka 2.1c 32-bit                        3051   18   18  1500   68%  2901   31% 
 232 Rybka 1.0 Beta 64-bit                    3049   16   16  1816   72%  2865   30% 
 233 Protector 1.3.4 64-bit                   3048   20   20  1055   46%  3081   37% 
 234 Thinker 5.4c Passive 64-bit 2CPU         3048   17   17  1637   57%  2987   32% 
 235 Bright 0.3a 4CPU                         3046   16   16  1757   43%  3098   34% 
 236 Deep Shredder 10 64-bit 4CPU             3045   14   14  2283   51%  3039   35% 
 237 Zappa Mexico II 64-bit                   3044   10   10  4866   45%  3085   35% 
 238 Shredder 11                              3043   14   14  2261   56%  2998   34% 
 239 Naum 2.1 64-bit 4CPU                     3043   18   18  1284   49%  3050   41% 
 240 Toga II 1.4 beta5c 2CPU                  3041   32   32   369   45%  3075   43% 
 241 Stockfish 1.3.1 64-bit                   3040   23   23   799   51%  3037   35% 
 242 Deep Fritz 10 4CPU                       3038   15   15  2060   49%  3044   34% 
 243 Spark 0.3 64-bit                         3038   12   12  3456   49%  3046   37% 
 244 Hiarcs 11.2 2CPU                         3038   26   26   625   56%  2992   37% 
 245 Deep Junior 11.2 64-bit 1CPU             3037   20   20  1119   40%  3120   30% 
 246 Deep Sjeng WC2008 64-bit 1CPU            3037   12   12  2955   44%  3080   36% 
 247 Onno 1.2.70 64-bit                       3036   18   18  1418   38%  3133   35% 
 248 Deep Shredder 11 64-bit 1CPU             3036   12   12  3164   51%  3028   35% 
 249 Zap!Chess Paderborn 64-bit 4CPU          3036   19   19  1197   57%  2985   38% 
 250 Hiarcs 11 4CPU                           3036   20   20  1148   54%  3005   34% 
 251 Deep Sjeng 3.0 64-bit 1CPU               3035   13   13  2900   46%  3071   34% 
 252 Onno 0.12.0 64-bit                       3034   16   16  1756   57%  2975   36% 
 253 Deep Junior 11.1a 64-bit 1CPU            3034   16   16  1846   42%  3097   35% 
 254 Booot 5.1.0                              3031   12   12  3117   47%  3057   32% 
 255 Onno 1.1.1 64-bit                        3031   12   12  2882   49%  3036   37% 
 256 Glaurung 2.1 64-bit 2CPU                 3031   18   18  1437   59%  2963   33% 
 257 Bright 0.4a 2CPU                         3030   15   15  1938   53%  3008   30% 
 258 Onno 1.0.0 64-bit                        3030   17   17  1548   56%  2987   37% 
 259 Hiarcs 12                                3028   12   12  3286   46%  3058   35% 
 260 MinkoChess 1.2 64-bit                    3028   16   16  1684   51%  3018   34% 
 261 Hiarcs 12.1                              3027   14   14  2103   45%  3068   38% 
 262 Loop 13.6 (Loop 2007) 64-bit 2CPU        3025   20   20  1025   46%  3053   39% 
 263 LoopMP 12.32 2CPU                        3024   16   16  1658   53%  3000   37% 
 264 Loop M1-T 64-bit 2CPU                    3023   18   18  1249   51%  3017   37% 
 265 Loop 13.5 64-bit 2CPU                    3023   19   19  1197   48%  3038   38% 
 266 Jonny 4.00 2CPU                          3021   18   18  1248   48%  3034   35% 
 267 Deep Junior 10 4CPU                      3021   13   13  3004   45%  3063   33% 
 268 Doch 1.2 32-bit                          3021   40   40   240   50%  3022   40% 
 269 Hiarcs 11 2CPU                           3020   18   18  1339   52%  3003   33% 
 270 Hannibal 05_20_10 64-bit                 3017   29   29   504   42%  3078   34% 
 271 Toga II 1.4.1SE                          3017   11   11  4110   50%  3016   34% 
 272 Gaviota 0.85.1 64-bit 6CPU               3016   23   23   984   37%  3130   25% 
 273 Junior 2010                              3013   38   38   280   43%  3063   35% 
 274 Thinker 5.3b Passive 64-bit              3012   28   28   500   47%  3037   35% 
 275 Zappa Mexico 64-bit                      3012   19   19  1216   55%  2973   35% 
 276 Hiarcs Paderborn 2007                    3011   17   17  1634   47%  3034   35% 
 277 Toga II 1.4 beta5c                       3011   15   15  1954   48%  3021   35% 
 278 Bright 0.3b 2CPU                         3003   23   23   839   60%  2922   30% 
 279 Glaurung 2.0.1 64-bit 2CPU               3003   16   16  1629   48%  3018   34% 
 280 Naum 2.1 64-bit 2CPU                     3002   19   19  1160   45%  3034   39% 
 281 Loop 10.32f                              3002   26   26   647   59%  2924   30% 
 282 Grapefruit 1.0 a2b                       3002   25   25   648   49%  3006   37% 
 283 Bright 0.3d 2CPU                         2997   24   24   767   45%  3041   33% 
 284 Bright 0.2c 4CPU                         2996   19   19  1294   35%  3117   30% 
 285 MinkoChess 1.1 64-bit 2CPU               2996   18   18  1351   50%  2999   32% 
 286 Hiarcs 11.2                              2995   18   18  1386   57%  2941   34% 
 287 Hiarcs 11.1                              2994   12   12  2940   61%  2910   34% 
 288 Glaurung 2.2 64-bit                      2994   14   14  2234   36%  3107   34% 
 289 Thinker 5.2i Passive 64-bit 2CPU         2989   22   22   925   60%  2907   28% 
 290 Fritz 10                                 2989   19   19  1248   54%  2954   29% 
 291 Critter 0.52 64-bit                      2988   20   20  1115   59%  2916   32% 
 292 Bright 0.3a 2CPU                         2987   20   20  1072   53%  2958   29% 
 293 Rybka 1.0 Beta 32-bit                    2983   14   14  2187   65%  2863   32% 
 294 Loop 13.6 (Loop 2007) 64-bit             2983   21   21   981   41%  3058   33% 
 295 Hiarcs 11                                2982   15   15  1982   57%  2929   33% 
 296 Thinker 5.4a Passive 64-bit              2981   24   24   700   43%  3034   33% 
 297 Texel 1.01 64-bit                        2979   20   20  1133   43%  3032   30% 
 298 Fruit 05/11/03                           2976   13   13  2792   49%  2984   35% 
 299 Shredder Classic 4 c't                   2975   34   34   373   47%  2997   36% 
 300 Loop M1-T 64-bit                         2975   18   18  1356   44%  3020   38% 
 301 Naum 2.2 64-bit                          2974   22   22   824   47%  2998   38% 
 302 Booot 5.0                                2973   16   16  1715   58%  2909   31% 
 303 Crafty 23.4 64-bit                       2973   14   14  2494   45%  3015   29% 
 304 Fruit 2.3                                2972   16   16  1826   62%  2878   34% 
 305 Deep Junior 10.1 2CPU                    2970   32   32   399   48%  2986   32% 
 306 Glaurung 2.1 64-bit                      2970   18   18  1397   40%  3052   32% 
 307 Loop 12.32                               2969   34   34   408   72%  2781   29% 
 308 Bright 0.5c                              2969   12   12  3252   45%  3010   31% 
 309 Strelka 1.8 32-bit                       2968   15   15  2087   48%  2977   35% 
 310 BugChess2 1.9 64-bit 2CPU                2967   18   18  1360   55%  2928   32% 
 311 Glaurung 080420 64-bit                   2966   29   29   499   42%  3028   35% 
 312 Bright 0.4a                              2966   11   11  3907   44%  3011   29% 
 313 Loop 13.6 (Loop 2007) 32-bit             2963   11   11  3903   56%  2918   32% 
 314 Ktulu 9.0                                2963   10   10  4540   42%  3030   31% 
 315 Scorpio 2.7 64-bit                       2961   16   16  1856   51%  2958   30% 
 316 Scorpio 2.7 64-bit 2CPU                  2959   64   64   126   77%  2735   27% 
 317 MinkoChess 0.9 64-bit                    2959   13   13  2552   53%  2933   29% 
 318 Deep Sjeng 2.7 4CPU                      2958   17   17  1714   34%  3089   31% 
 319 Toga II 1.3.1                            2957   10   10  4937   45%  2999   33% 
 320 Naum 2.2 32-bit                          2957   16   16  1647   56%  2909   37% 
 321 MinkoChess 1.0 64-bit                    2956   21   21   957   53%  2937   36% 
 322 Twisted Logic 20090922 64-bit            2955   11   11  4212   46%  2991   29% 
 323 Fruit 2.3.1                              2952   26   26   614   58%  2892   35% 
 324 Frenzee 3.5.19 64-bit                    2951   14   14  2244   49%  2963   29% 
 325 Bright 0.2c 2CPU                         2951   21   21  1004   50%  2947   34% 
 326 Twisted Logic 20100131x 64-bit           2951   12   12  3185   45%  2988   28% 
 327 Glaurung 1.2.1 32-bit 4CPU               2951   15   15  1993   42%  3018   32% 
 328 MinkoChess 1.1 64-bit                    2950   20   20  1162   53%  2927   25% 
 329 Loop 13.5 32-bit                         2949   20   20  1073   51%  2942   34% 
 330 Jonny 4.00 32-bit                        2948   13   13  3195   55%  2898   25% 
 331 Toga II 1.2.1a 32-bit                    2947   10   10  5319   49%  2949   34% 
 332 Zappa Mexico 32-bit                      2946   23   23   790   52%  2929   37% 
 333 Thinker 5.1e Passive 64-bit              2946   26   26   619   52%  2932   31% 
 334 BugChess2 1.9 64-bit                     2945   16   16  1748   52%  2927   29% 
 335 Chessmaster 11 4CPU                      2945   24   24   698   59%  2872   32% 
 336 Hiarcs X54 Hypermodern 32-bit            2945   21   21   953   46%  2979   34% 
 337 Scorpio 2.6 64-bit                       2944   14   14  2296   43%  3001   29% 
 338 Shredder 10                              2939   24   24   736   52%  2924   33% 
 339 Hiarcs X50                               2938   16   16  1836   47%  2963   31% 
 340 Crafty 23.3 64-bit                       2938   15   15  2064   45%  2981   29% 
 341 Bright 0.3b                              2937   28   28   547   38%  3028   34% 
 342 Bison 9.11 64-bit                        2936   13   13  2636   50%  2943   24% 
 343 Fritz 9                                  2936   11   11  4088   50%  2933   29% 
 344 Fruit 2.2.1                              2936   20   20  1076   56%  2885   33% 
 345 Naum 2.1 64-bit                          2936   19   19  1184   40%  3013   36% 
 346 Hiarcs X54 32-bit                        2933   17   17  1583   49%  2940   31% 
 347 Junior 10.1                              2927   45   45   200   49%  2941   33% 
 348 SmarThink 1.20 64-bit                    2926   12   12  3437   36%  3041   31% 
 349 Zap!Chess Zanzibar 32-bit                2926   42   42   220   50%  2927   37% 
 350 Glaurung 2.0.1 64-bit                    2924   12   12  3183   52%  2905   33% 
 351 Crafty 23.0 64-bit 4CPU                  2924   19   19  1436   28%  3102   28% 
 352 Hiarcs X50 Hypermodern                   2924   27   27   591   42%  2990   34% 
 353 Strelka 1.0b 32-bit                      2922   19   19  1202   55%  2876   31% 
 354 Naum 2.1 32-bit                          2922   15   15  1826   51%  2912   35% 
 355 Junior 10                                2921   24   24   796   56%  2873   28% 
 356 Bright 0.2b 2CPU                         2921   24   24   768   49%  2933   31% 
 357 Glaurung 2.2 32-bit                      2920   54   54   152   32%  3069   32% 
 358 Glaurung 2.1 32-bit                      2920   37   37   319   65%  2801   28% 
 359 Hiarcs 10                                2919   22   22   918   50%  2921   32% 
 360 Toga II 1.1a 32-bit                      2918   43   43   302   77%  2687   21% 
 361 Chronos 1.9.9 64-bit                     2918   11   11  3888   46%  2953   32% 
 362 Bright 0.3d                              2917   22   22   995   33%  3063   30% 
 363 Gaviota 0.85.1 64-bit                    2915   14   14  2409   55%  2877   24% 
 364 Hiarcs X54 64-bit                        2914   33   33   387   45%  2961   31% 
 365 Spike 1.2 Turin                          2911    6    6 16966   42%  2982   32% 
 366 SmarThink 1.10                           2908   15   15  1918   43%  2969   32% 
 367 Scorpio 2.0 32-bit 4CPU                  2907   23   23   955   29%  3085   29% 
 368 Ktulu 8.0                                2906   15   15  1875   52%  2885   30% 
 369 Bobcat 2.75 64-bit 2CPU                  2905   20   20  1094   58%  2838   34% 
 370 Tornado 4.40 64-bit                      2903   16   16  1851   51%  2895   28% 
 371 Crafty 23.2 64-bit                       2903   16   16  1652   56%  2855   29% 
 372 Scorpio 2.1 64-bit 4CPU                  2900   19   19  1495   27%  3096   23% 
 373 Crafty 23.0 64-bit 2CPU                  2899   19   19  1216   52%  2884   32% 
 374 Chess Tiger 2007.1                       2899    9    9  5984   46%  2938   34% 
 375 Glaurung 1.2.1 32-bit 2CPU               2897   27   27   570   50%  2900   34% 
 376 Chessmaster 11 2CPU                      2892   26   26   599   52%  2873   35% 
 377 Bobcat 3.25 64-bit                       2890   18   18  1341   52%  2871   34% 
 378 BugChess2 1.7 64-bit                     2888   14   14  2366   43%  2956   30% 
 379 Glaurung 1.2.1 64-bit 2CPU               2883   21   21  1122   32%  3034   27% 
 380 Chess Tiger 2007                         2883   11   11  3760   45%  2921   32% 
 381 Delfi 5.4 2CPU                           2883   14   14  2438   41%  2963   31% 
 382 Naum 2.0 32-bit                          2880    8    8  7164   50%  2876   32% 
 383 Hiarcs 10 Hypermodern                    2879   30   30   463   41%  2949   36% 
 384 Deep Frenzee May07 64-bit 2CPU           2878   17   17  1605   40%  2966   28% 
 385 Bison 9.11 32-bit                        2877   30   30   499   47%  2899   24% 
 386 Scorpio 2.1 64-bit 2CPU                  2876   19   19  1276   43%  2934   28% 
 387 Naum 2.0 64-bit                          2872   12   12  3345   44%  2926   33% 
 388 Frenzee Feb08 64-bit                     2872   10   10  4731   45%  2916   25% 
 389 Scorpio 2.0 32-bit 2CPU                  2870   17   17  1711   38%  2977   30% 
 390 Gaviota 0.84 64-bit                      2867   13   13  2702   54%  2837   25% 
 391 Chessmaster 11 Gil-Galad                 2866   26   26   600   49%  2873   35% 
 392 Bright 0.2b                              2864   33   33   372   50%  2864   32% 
 393 Bright 0.2c                              2863   15   15  2021   50%  2868   31% 
 394 Pharaon 3.5.1 4CPU                       2862   37   37   304   40%  2935   32% 
 395 Scorpio 2.5 64-bit                       2859   15   15  1972   51%  2851   29% 
 396 Delfi 5.4                                2858   10   10  4958   49%  2869   31% 
 397 Bison 9.8 64-bit                         2856   21   21   999   54%  2829   28% 
 398 Gaviota 0.85.1 32-bit                    2856   21   21   998   38%  2948   27% 
 399 Crafty 22.4 64-bit 2CPU                  2855   27   27   563   53%  2834   34% 
 400 Spike 1.1                                2854   26   26   590   48%  2866   32% 
 401 Bobcat 2.75 64-bit                       2853   15   15  1985   56%  2804   34% 
 402 RedQueen 1.0.0 64-bit                    2853   15   15  1848   58%  2789   27% 
 403 Daydreamer 1.75 64-bit                   2848   12   12  3225   49%  2858   31% 
 404 Dirty 25Aug2011 64-bit                   2846   16   16  1791   54%  2812   27% 
 405 BugChess2 1.6.4 64-bit                   2845   15   15  2052   47%  2879   28% 
 406 Gaviota 0.83 64-bit 4CPU                 2844   21   21   987   63%  2733   25% 
 407 Booot 4.15.1                             2844   14   14  2142   47%  2871   28% 
 408 SmarThink 1.00 32-bit                    2842   14   14  2284   47%  2872   29% 
 409 Scorpio 1.9 2CPU                         2842   61   61   123   31%  2994   28% 
 410 Deep Sjeng 2.5 1CPU                      2841   36   36   322   52%  2826   34% 
 411 Deep Sjeng 2.5 2CPU                      2840   32   32   406   34%  2966   34% 
 412 Fritz 8                                  2840   36   36   372   64%  2726   28% 
 413 BugChess2 1.6.3 64-bit                   2840   17   17  1498   46%  2871   30% 
 414 Booot 4.15.0                             2839   12   12  3008   46%  2876   32% 
 415 Alaric 707                               2839    8    8  8049   46%  2877   28% 
 416 Chessmaster 11                           2837   25   25   640   45%  2877   34% 
 417 Frenzee Dec07 64-bit                     2836   26   26   607   53%  2815   31% 
 418 CM10th Paralyse                          2832   16   16  1812   39%  2917   29% 
 419 Scorpio 2.0 32-bit                       2831   14   14  3437   51%  2826   41% 
 420 Glaurung 1.2.1 32-bit                    2830   10   10  4399   44%  2878   30% 
 421 Cheng3 1.07 64-bit                       2828   20   20  1054   51%  2820   29% 
 422 DiscoCheck 3.5.1 64-bit                  2828   18   18  1433   59%  2749   25% 
 423 Pharaon 3.5.1 2CPU                       2827   12   12  3739   34%  2969   28% 
 424 Scorpio 1.91 (egbb tbc)                  2827   32   32   469   30%  2990   26% 
 425 Naraku 1.31                              2827   15   15  2013   51%  2820   25% 
 426 Scorpio 2.0 64-bit                       2826   32   32   383   49%  2834   55% 
 427 Glaurung 1.2.1 64-bit                    2825   15   15  2223   40%  2910   28% 
 428 Alfil 12 MT 2CPU                         2824   20   20  1087   54%  2793   26% 
 429 Deep Sjeng 1.6 2CPU                      2824   20   20  1076   43%  2877   29% 
 430 Gaviota 0.83 64-bit 2CPU                 2824   16   16  1737   56%  2773   26% 
 431 Scorpio 1.9                              2823   22   22   862   45%  2862   31% 
 432 Naum 2.0 64-bit 4CPU                     2821  190  190    10   20%  3016   40% 
 433 Scorpio 1.81                             2820   16   16  2026   46%  2847   26% 
 434 Scorpio 2.0 32-bit (No EGBBs)            2820   23   23   997   48%  2831   56% 
 435 Bright 0.2a                              2818   30   30   466   44%  2862   32% 
 436 Chess Tiger 15                           2818   24   24   744   48%  2833   29% 
 437 Colossus 2008b                           2816    9    9  5725   46%  2855   29% 
 438 E.T. Chess 13.01.08                      2813    9    9  6527   46%  2846   31% 
 439 Dirty 24Apr2011 64-bit                   2813   17   17  1369   51%  2803   32% 
 440 Bright 0.1d                              2813   24   24   712   52%  2798   31% 
 441 Scorpio 1.91                             2811   15   15  1962   46%  2839   34% 
 442 Chronos 1.9.7                            2810   15   15  1870   43%  2868   32% 
 443 Scorpio 1.82                             2809   23   23  1030   52%  2780   22% 
 444 Cyrano 06b17 64-bit                      2809   12   12  3051   50%  2816   28% 
 445 Deuterium 11.01.28.159                   2808   15   15  2046   52%  2793   30% 
 446 CM10th Xperience                         2808   15   15  2317   36%  2930   26% 
 447 Delfi 5.3B 2CPU                          2806   23   23   796   41%  2876   31% 
 448 WildCat 8                                2806    9    9  6361   45%  2846   30% 
 449 RedQueen 1.1.1 64-bit                    2805   18   18  1395   47%  2834   27% 
 450 Scorpio 1.9 (egbb tbc)                   2803   17   17  1614   32%  2948   27% 
 451 Scorpio 1.84                             2802   22   22  1036   27%  2994   26% 
 452 Movei 00.8.438 (10 10 10)                2801    8    8  6678   44%  2854   29% 
 453 ProDeo 1.7                               2800   16   16  1711   44%  2854   22% 
 454 Hamsters 0.7.1 2CPU                      2798   18   18  1201   52%  2778   33% 
 455 Brutus 8.05 64-bit 2CPU                  2797   18   18  1258   53%  2766   31% 
 456 Booot 4.14.0                             2797   18   18  1367   44%  2850   30% 
 457 Alfil 8.1.1 Optimized                    2794    9    9  5824   45%  2834   28% 
 458 Rodent 0.13 64-bit                       2793   30   30   452   53%  2772   27% 
 459 Gandalf 6                                2792   11   11  3670   42%  2858   28% 
 460 Alfil 12 MT                              2791   16   16  1584   54%  2763   29% 
 461 Scorpio 1.8                              2791   16   16  1868   40%  2872   27% 
 462 Sloppy 0.2.2 64-bit                      2790   11   11  4100   45%  2835   30% 
 463 ProDeo 1.71                              2788   17   17  1480   44%  2834   29% 
 464 Alaric 704                               2787   16   16  1584   50%  2788   31% 
 465 Sloppy 0.2.0 64-bit                      2785   15   15  2054   41%  2862   31% 
 466 Delfi 5.1                                2784   13   13  2671   51%  2774   30% 
 467 Frenzee 3.0 64-bit                       2784   15   15  1808   50%  2787   29% 
 468 Colossus 2007d                           2783   13   13  2510   45%  2825   31% 
 469 CM10th Default                           2782   28   28   556   37%  2891   26% 
 470 ProDeo 1.6                               2782   15   15  1853   48%  2800   29% 
 471 Slow Chess Blitz WV2.1                   2782    7    7  9965   43%  2839   29% 
 472 Deuterium 10.01.27.213                   2781   11   11  3632   53%  2757   29% 
 473 Glaurung 1.0.2 32-bit                    2779   32   32   427   36%  2893   29% 
 474 Crafty 20.14 32-bit 2CPU                 2779   34   34   351   43%  2833   34% 
 475 Delfi 5.2                                2778   12   12  3399   42%  2845   30% 
 476 Pro Deo 1.2                              2778   11   11  3706   43%  2839   27% 
 477 Ruffian 2.1.0                            2777   12   12  2942   45%  2819   30% 
 478 WildCat 7                                2775   11   11  4052   46%  2805   31% 
 479 Philou 3.7 64-bit                        2774   17   17  1365   51%  2769   35% 
 480 Movei 00.8.438                           2774   17   17  1472   41%  2846   30% 
 481 Lemming 0.34 64-bit                      2772   18   18  1370   45%  2814   30% 
 482 Naum 1.91 32-bit                         2772   20   20  1065   43%  2834   29% 
 483 Rodent 0.12 64-bit                       2772   30   30   481   52%  2751   25% 
 484 Philou 3.71 64-bit                       2772   23   23   824   48%  2785   30% 
 485 Rodent 0.14 64-bit                       2771   34   34   359   47%  2803   33% 
 486 BugChess2 1.6.2 64-bit                   2771   21   21   948   51%  2762   27% 
 487 GNU Chess 5.07.173b 64-bit               2771   14   14  2112   49%  2779   28% 
 488 GarboChess 2.20 64-bit                   2771   15   15  1837   49%  2774   25% 
 489 Pharaon 3.5.1                            2770   10   10  5173   44%  2823   28% 
 490 Alfil 11 MT 2CPU                         2770   21   21   953   46%  2798   31% 
 491 Zappa 1.1 64-bit                         2769   12   12  3263   46%  2802   30% 
 492 Cheng3 1.05 64-bit                       2769   16   16  1625   51%  2764   29% 
 493 Glass 1.9 64-bit                         2765   18   18  1309   53%  2741   28% 
 494 Rodent 0.11 64-bit                       2765   33   33   390   58%  2700   27% 
 495 Arasan 14.0.1 64-bit                     2764  154  154    20   18%  3016   25% 
 496 GNU Chess 5.07.1705b (TCEC) 64-bit       2764   16   16  1771   54%  2729   28% 
 497 GarboChess 2.10 64-bit                   2763   12   12  3013   42%  2833   26% 
 498 Gaviota 0.83 64-bit                      2763   19   19  1235   54%  2731   26% 
 499 Amyan 1.72                               2762   10   10  4220   49%  2773   28% 
 500 Colossus 2008a                           2762   30   30   464   42%  2823   30% 
 501 ProDeo 1.74                              2762   20   20  1115   46%  2791   25% 
 502 Arasan 13.1 64-bit 2CPU                  2761   32   32   491   44%  2815   20% 
 503 Hamsters 0.7 2CPU                        2761   20   20  1004   42%  2820   35% 
 504 Lemming 0.24 64-bit                      2760   23   23   847   41%  2832   29% 
 505 List 5.12                                2759   12   12  3243   48%  2778   32% 
 506 Movei 00.8.423                           2757   27   27   575   52%  2736   32% 
 507 N2 0.4 64-bit                            2756   12   12  3162   50%  2757   32% 
 508 Arasan 14.1 64-bit                       2755   31   31   438   47%  2783   29% 
 509 Chiron 0.8.7                             2755   18   18  1434   47%  2784   27% 
 510 Godel 2.0.5 64-bit                       2753   14   14  2413   61%  2655   27% 
 511 ProDeo 1.1                               2753   12   12  3397   46%  2790   26% 
 512 Colossus 2007c                           2752   16   16  1600   47%  2778   33% 
 513 Ruffian 1.0.5                            2751    9    9  5348   47%  2774   30% 
 514 Bobcat 20110414 64-bit                   2749   32   32   418   62%  2645   30% 
 515 CuckooChess 1.12 64-bit                  2748   16   16  1736   53%  2722   26% 
 516 Arasan 13.2 64-bit                       2746   17   17  1588   51%  2738   27% 
 517 Cheng3 1.04 64-bit                       2746   18   18  1322   49%  2752   29% 
 518 Hamsters 0.7.1                           2743   13   13  2577   47%  2773   30% 
 519 Arasan 12.3 64-bit 2CPU                  2743   33   33   419   43%  2801   27% 
 520 Pseudo 0.7c                              2743    9    9  5378   49%  2747   29% 
 521 Delfi 5.0                                2742   17   17  1622   40%  2830   31% 
 522 Alaric 0702b                             2741   32   32   401   45%  2774   32% 
 523 Francesca MAD 0.19                       2741   16   16  1766   52%  2720   28% 
 524 Tornado 3.67 64-bit                      2741   26   26   592   56%  2692   29% 
 525 Rotor 0.6                                2740   12   12  2854   50%  2739   29% 
 526 Arasan 13.1 64-bit                       2740   19   19  1131   53%  2715   26% 
 527 SOS 5.1                                  2740    9    9  5534   46%  2772   28% 
 528 Deep Sjeng 1.6 1CPU                      2739   37   37   320   40%  2812   28% 
 529 Bobcat 20110220 DC 64-bit                2738   29   29   509   59%  2668   29% 
 530 Rodent 0.15 64-bit                       2738   32   32   418   42%  2808   33% 
 531 Rebel 12                                 2737   39   39   291   37%  2838   30% 
 532 Critter 0.40                             2736   20   20  1131   56%  2664   28% 
 533 Arasan 11.3 64-bit 4CPU                  2735   25   25  1386   12%  3115   13% 
 534 RedQueen 0.9.5 64-bit                    2735   19   19  1146   54%  2702   26% 
 535 Francesca MAD 0.18                       2734   18   18  1288   54%  2705   30% 
 536 Colossus 2007b                           2734   23   23   765   47%  2757   30% 
 537 Movei 00.8.421                           2732   27   27   573   49%  2736   28% 
 538 Aristarch 4.50                           2730    9    9  5327   47%  2753   27% 
 539 Hermann 2.8 64-bit 2CPU                  2729   20   20  1133   48%  2742   26% 
 540 Booot 4.13.1                             2728   15   15  1948   49%  2732   33% 
 541 Movei 00.8.418 (10 10 10)                2726   27   27   575   49%  2737   28% 
 542 Hamsters 0.6                             2726   14   14  2008   51%  2721   31% 
 543 Petir 4.39                               2725   12   12  2804   46%  2754   32% 
 544 Deuterium 09.01.26.492                   2723   18   18  1386   50%  2723   26% 
 545 Glass 1.7 64-bit                         2722   14   14  2113   50%  2717   30% 
 546 Petir 4.999999                           2722   10   10  4066   49%  2729   30% 
 547 WildCat 6                                2722   19   19  1265   54%  2680   25% 
 548 Gaviota 0.80 64-bit 2CPU                 2721   22   22   853   48%  2738   31% 
 549 Colossus 2007a                           2720   17   17  1404   44%  2769   30% 
 550 Arasan 12.3 64-bit                       2720   18   18  1371   51%  2708   28% 
 551 The Baron 2.23 64-bit                    2719    9    9  5325   47%  2740   27% 
 552 NanoSzachy 4.0 64-bit                    2715   18   18  1257   48%  2731   28% 
 553 Junior 7                                 2715   66   66    98   64%  2602   26% 
 554 Jonny 2.83 32-bit                        2714   12   12  3324   46%  2747   25% 
 555 Movei 00.8.418                           2712   27   27   576   47%  2736   31% 
 556 Movei 00.8.403 (10 10 10)                2712   27   27   572   47%  2737   26% 
 557 Philou 3.60                              2711   16   16  1691   53%  2680   27% 
 558 Brutus 8.05 64-bit                       2711   15   15  1949   42%  2771   28% 
 559 The Baron 2.23 32-bit                    2710   21   21  1035   47%  2733   28% 
 560 Movei 00.8.418 (3 7 10)                  2708   27   27   574   46%  2736   34% 
 561 BugChess2 1.5.2                          2708   15   15  1793   51%  2699   28% 
 562 Hermann 2.4 64-bit 2CPU                  2707   17   17  1524   55%  2658   24% 
 563 The Baron 1.8.1                          2706   15   15  1959   48%  2720   25% 
 564 Anaconda 2.0.1                           2706   12   12  3027   51%  2699   30% 
 565 Arasan 11.7 64-bit                       2706   15   15  2036   43%  2761   26% 
 566 Ktulu 4.2                                2705   12   12  3007   50%  2708   27% 
 567 Crafty 21.5 PS 64-bit                    2705   15   15  1970   47%  2734   30% 
 568 Pharaon 3.3                              2705   36   36   343   33%  2845   29% 
 569 Colossus 2006f                           2704   19   19  1125   47%  2727   30% 
 570 Arasan 12.0 64-bit                       2704   19   19  1216   48%  2723   27% 
 571 Amyan 1.62                               2704   19   19  1256   54%  2645   27% 
 572 Dirty 11D-27                             2703   17   17  1478   51%  2690   29% 
 573 Fritz 5.32                               2702   14   14  2199   53%  2678   33% 
 574 Hermann 2.6 64-bit                       2700   15   15  2092   46%  2732   25% 
 575 Movei 00.8.418 (2 4 10)                  2700   30   30   476   46%  2732   27% 
 576 CuckooChess 1.11 64-bit                  2699   17   17  1506   49%  2710   27% 
 577 SmarThink 0.17a                          2697   11   11  3923   47%  2721   28% 
 578 AnMon 5.75                               2697   10   10  4974   47%  2720   25% 
 579 Thinker 4.7a                             2696   12   12  2816   53%  2671   31% 
 580 Rotor 0.5                                2695   14   14  2117   50%  2691   27% 
 581 Fritz 6 Light                            2695   16   16  1565   50%  2694   30% 
 582 Philou 3.5                               2694   20   20   986   49%  2700   35% 
 583 Movei 00.8.397                           2693   29   29   508   54%  2662   27% 
 584 Gaviota 0.80 64-bit                      2693   15   15  1873   54%  2662   26% 
 585 Atlas 3.20 64-bit                        2693   35   35   410   61%  2588   19% 
 586 Cheng3 1.03 64-bit                       2693   20   20  1039   54%  2664   29% 
 587 Movei 00.8.403                           2692   17   17  1380   51%  2679   30% 
 588 Ufim 8.02                                2692    8    8  7181   50%  2688   28% 
 589 BBChess 1.3b 64-bit 2CPU                 2691   16   16  1698   54%  2651   29% 
 590 Frenzee 2.0                              2691   37   37   318   46%  2721   24% 
 591 Zappa 1.1 32-bit                         2691   27   27   605   43%  2749   29% 
 592 Movei 00.8.383                           2690   29   29   538   51%  2681   26% 
 593 DanaSah 4.66                             2689   19   19  1177   49%  2700   25% 
 594 Hermann 2.8 64-bit                       2687   14   14  2371   47%  2711   26% 
 595 Pharaon 3.2                              2686   40   40   285   48%  2703   31% 
 596 Petir 3.99d                              2682   20   20  1152   51%  2665   29% 
 597 Francesca MAD 0.15                       2682   18   18  1215   48%  2699   31% 
 598 GreKo 8.2 64-bit                         2681   15   15  1860   50%  2680   29% 
 599 Delphil 2.8 2CPU                         2675   20   20  1045   59%  2606   32% 
 600 Francesca MAD 0.16                       2675   19   19  1111   47%  2696   29% 
 601 Crafty 20.14 32-bit                      2675   30   30   529   36%  2792   23% 
 602 AnMon 5.60                               2673   13   13  2527   50%  2676   27% 
 603 Dirty 6J-22                              2671   13   13  2430   52%  2651   28% 
 604 AnMon 5.66                               2671   19   19  1149   45%  2708   27% 
 605 Pepito 1.59.2 64-bit                     2671   17   17  1548   45%  2710   28% 
 606 Hermann 2.5 64-bit                       2669   14   14  2449   48%  2683   23% 
 607 E.T. Chess 18.11.05                      2669   13   13  2558   54%  2631   30% 
 608 Rodin 4.0                                2666   14   14  2097   52%  2648   28% 
 609 Little Goliath Evolution 3.12            2665    8    8  7534   49%  2676   28% 
 610 Movei 00.8.378                           2665   29   29   520   50%  2664   28% 
 611 Fritz 4.01                               2664   42   42   232   54%  2630   31% 
 612 Yace 0.99.87                             2664   10   10  4434   49%  2671   28% 
 613 Pupsi2 0.08                              2664   14   14  2293   51%  2656   27% 
 614 AnMon 5.50                               2664   27   27   654   46%  2702   24% 
 615 Green Light Chess 3.01.2.2               2662   11   11  3484   44%  2715   29% 
 616 Trace 1.37a                              2661    9    9  5645   48%  2677   27% 
 617 DanaSah 4.24                             2661   13   13  2522   47%  2685   29% 
 618 Arasan 10.4 64-bit 2CPU                  2659   23   23   841   53%  2635   28% 
 619 Movei 00.8.402                           2659   37   37   319   42%  2722   25% 
 620 Dorky 4.0 64-bit 2CPU                    2658   19   19  1184   60%  2578   31% 
 621 Crafty 18.15 32-bit                      2657   40   40   303   45%  2699   29% 
 622 Trace 1.36                               2657   30   30   514   51%  2652   28% 
 623 Petir 3.95                               2656   26   26   701   42%  2720   27% 
 624 Movei 00.8.383x                          2656   29   29   508   49%  2662   30% 
 625 Arasan 11.2 64-bit 2CPU                  2651   19   19  1267   43%  2711   23% 
 626 Frenzee 3.0                              2650   33   33   426   46%  2683   28% 
 627 NanoSzachy 3.9                           2648   14   14  2092   48%  2663   29% 
 628 Pepito 1.59 32-bit                       2645   14   14  2040   51%  2638   31% 
 629 DanaSah 4.45                             2645   21   21   930   45%  2682   27% 
 630 Bruja 1.9 64-bit JA No-int-book          2641   12   12  2929   46%  2673   26% 
 631 Crafty 19.19 32-bit                      2641   31   31   436   48%  2655   31% 
 632 Scorpio 2.1 64-bit                       2640   36   36   650   11%  3044   12% 
 633 Atlas 3.14b 64-bit 2CPU                  2640   26   26   686   40%  2731   25% 
 634 Hamsters 0.5                             2639   20   20  1108   47%  2657   28% 
 635 Colossus 2006d                           2638   34   34   392   39%  2733   26% 
 636 Murka 2 64-bit                           2636   16   16  1735   53%  2611   28% 
 637 Dorky 4.3 64-bit 2CPU                    2635   18   18  1272   50%  2639   26% 
 638 Tao 5.6                                  2635   11   11  3440   49%  2645   25% 
 639 CuckooChess 1.10                         2634   18   18  1307   41%  2707   26% 
 640 Gaviota 0.74 64-bit 2CPU                 2634   19   19  1317   58%  2565   19% 
 641 Cheese 1.4 64-bit                        2632   19   19  1169   50%  2633   28% 
 642 Movei 00.8.373                           2632   29   29   520   46%  2663   26% 
 643 Green Light Chess 3.00                   2630   16   16  1640   49%  2635   32% 
 644 Cerebro 3.03d                            2630   10   10  4795   48%  2647   24% 
 645 Booot 4.12.1                             2628   30   30   472   43%  2685   27% 
 646 Movei 00.8.295                           2627   28   28   533   43%  2685   30% 
 647 Xpdnt 091007                             2623   15   15  1842   52%  2607   27% 
 648 Dorky 4.3 64-bit                         2620   16   16  1679   46%  2650   22% 
 649 Twisted Logic 20080404x                  2619   17   17  1513   52%  2605   22% 
 650 Arasan 10.0 64-bit                       2616   16   16  1604   51%  2609   28% 
 651 Pawny 0.3 64-bit                         2613   14   14  2127   48%  2628   28% 
 652 Amyan 1.597                              2612   12   12  2917   50%  2615   27% 
 653 Kiwi 0.6d 64-bit                         2610   14   14  2366   48%  2625   26% 
 654 Glass 1.6                                2608   14   14  2224   53%  2586   24% 
 655 The Baron 1.7.0                          2608   18   18  1515   48%  2621   23% 
 656 Cerebro 3.03b                            2606   33   33   445   27%  2796   23% 
 657 Delphil 2.6a 2CPU                        2602   19   19  1211   50%  2599   29% 
 658 LittleThought 1.052 64-bit 2CPU          2602   20   20  1145   39%  2691   23% 
 659 Philou 3.14.1                            2600   15   15  1827   52%  2586   27% 
 660 Delphil 2.8                              2599   16   16  1777   50%  2602   26% 
 661 LittleThought 1.052 64-bit               2598   15   15  2067   47%  2623   26% 
 662 Counter 1.2                              2597   12   12  2791   49%  2602   37% 
 663 Tao 5.4                                  2596   40   40   322   37%  2705   21% 
 664 NanoSzachy 3.8                           2596   14   14  2162   50%  2592   26% 
 665 Hamsters 0.4                             2596   36   36   350   38%  2696   26% 
 666 Philou 3.51                              2593  145  145    20   73%  2410   35% 
 667 Matacz 1.4                               2593   13   13  2516   53%  2566   26% 
 668 Matacz 1.3 HT74                          2592   16   16  1753   50%  2594   28% 
 669 SpiderChess 070603                       2588    9    9  5476   47%  2612   31% 
 670 Atlas 3.14b 64-bit                       2586   14   14  2191   50%  2583   24% 
 671 Abrok 5.0                                2585   11   11  4120   44%  2635   26% 
 672 King of Kings 2.56                       2584   13   13  2810   47%  2608   24% 
 673 Gaviota 0.75.7 64-bit                    2581   18   18  1404   46%  2615   22% 
 674 Delphil 2.7 2CPU                         2579   32   32   457   39%  2671   24% 
 675 Eeyore 1.52 64-bit                       2578   17   17  1609   46%  2610   25% 
 676 LambChop 10.99                           2578   10   10  4143   49%  2584   27% 
 677 Quark 2.35                               2577   12   12  3226   49%  2584   26% 
 678 Nejmet 3.07                              2573   10   10  4858   50%  2572   27% 
 679 Hussar 0.4                               2570   15   15  2039   54%  2532   22% 
 680 Snitch 1.6.2 32-bit                      2569   12   12  3086   48%  2583   25% 
 681 Gaia 3.5 64-bit                          2569   12   12  3391   46%  2605   21% 
 682 Delphil 2.7                              2567   28   28   582   49%  2570   27% 
 683 OliThink 5.3.0 64-bit                    2566   15   15  1901   47%  2594   23% 
 684 Dragon 4.6                               2565   10   10  4723   49%  2575   25% 
 685 Simplex 0.9.8 64-bit                     2565   17   17  1506   54%  2530   22% 
 686 GreKo 8.0                                2565   18   18  1256   48%  2577   30% 
 687 NanoSzachy 3.5                           2561   18   18  1504   56%  2503   24% 
 688 Delphil 2.6c                             2561   35   35   364   52%  2544   24% 
 689 Kiwi 0.6d                                2559   17   17  1454   45%  2597   25% 
 690 Typhoon 1.00-358                         2559   18   18  1374   45%  2597   23% 
 691 Pawny 0.2.1 64-bit                       2559   19   19  1266   50%  2557   24% 
 692 Delphil 1.9c                             2557   15   15  1951   48%  2573   29% 
 693 Delphil 2.6a                             2557   18   18  1378   48%  2571   27% 
 694 Little Goliath 2000 3.5c                 2556   22   22   872   54%  2525   26% 
 695 Delphil 1.8                              2554   17   17  1590   50%  2557   27% 
 696 RomiChess P3k 64-bit                     2554   11   11  4108   49%  2562   26% 
 697 Patzer 3.80 2CPU                         2552   17   17  1539   51%  2544   24% 
 698 Ifrit m1.8 64-bit                        2547   34   34   397   55%  2510   21% 
 699 KnightDreamer 3.3                        2547   14   14  2266   51%  2540   27% 
 700 Matacz 1.1                               2545   22   22   950   53%  2516   25% 
 701 LittleThought 1.04 64-bit                2545   18   18  1530   54%  2504   18% 
 702 Arasan 9.5                               2543   30   30   533   51%  2533   23% 
 703 RomiChess P3L 64-bit                     2542   17   17  1416   47%  2568   27% 
 704 Gaia 3.5 32-bit                          2541   17   17  1730   53%  2510   20% 
 705 Francesca MAD 0.13 Nobook                2535   15   15  1966   52%  2522   25% 
 706 Comet B50                                2534   12   12  3269   46%  2566   24% 
 707 Leila 0.53h                              2534   10   10  4412   53%  2505   23% 
 708 GreKo 7.2                                2531   19   19  1130   49%  2536   29% 
 709 Amy 0.8.7b DC                            2528   11   11  3915   47%  2548   23% 
 710 Hermann 2.0                              2526   21   21  1077   40%  2615   22% 
 711 Pawny 0.2 64-bit                         2526   17   17  1644   47%  2549   23% 
 712 PostModernist 1016                       2525   15   15  1875   51%  2517   24% 
 713 Diablo 0.5.1                             2524   13   13  2639   48%  2538   28% 
 714 Phalanx XXIII                            2524   19   19  1276   50%  2524   20% 
 715 Gosu 0.16                                2520   10   10  5415   51%  2509   21% 
 716 Muse 0.899b                              2519   10   10  5106   52%  2503   24% 
 717 Comet B68                                2518   10   10  4534   49%  2524   24% 
 718 Sjeng 12.13                              2517   12   12  3203   49%  2524   25% 
 719 Der Bringer 1.9                          2516   10   10  5160   52%  2496   23% 
 720 Patzer 3.80                              2515   13   13  2905   52%  2500   23% 
 721 Ghost 2.0.1 32-bit                       2515   19   19  1206   54%  2485   23% 
 722 Djinn 0.925x                             2514   10   10  4884   50%  2513   25% 
 723 Ifrit m1.6 64-bit                        2513   33   33   399   56%  2468   26% 
 724 Rodin 3.0                                2508   18   18  1374   52%  2491   24% 
 725 Dirty ACCA 3                             2508   16   16  1796   51%  2491   26% 
 726 RomiChess P3kLD                          2508   24   24   806   37%  2617   24% 
 727 Arasan 9.2                               2505   26   26   748   37%  2613   23% 
 728 Ifrit m1.5 64-bit                        2505   33   33   397   54%  2470   23% 
 729 Crazy Bishop 0052                        2504   12   12  3486   53%  2478   24% 
 730 PikoSzachy 3.3                           2501   18   18  1441   52%  2483   23% 
 731 Terra 3.4                                2499   17   17  1583   55%  2460   20% 
 732 Homer 2.01                               2494   12   12  3293   51%  2486   24% 
 733 Glass 1.3                                2494   17   17  1678   54%  2454   22% 
 734 Betsy 6.51 Nobook                        2493   13   13  2621   55%  2446   24% 
 735 Amateur 2.82                             2491   10   10  5167   52%  2471   21% 
 736 Phalanx XXII Reborn JA                   2489   14   14  2536   55%  2436   20% 
 737 GNU Chess 5.07.9b 64-bit JA              2486   16   16  1758   53%  2465   21% 
 738 Alex 2.14a 64-bit                        2484   17   17  1455   45%  2521   23% 
 739 Queen 4.03                               2483   11   11  4064   48%  2496   29% 
 740 Cheese 1.3                               2482   13   13  2641   48%  2501   23% 
 741 Eeyore 1.50                              2481   16   16  1815   49%  2492   24% 
 742 Plisk 0.2.7d 64-bit                      2481   16   16  1685   50%  2480   21% 
 743 Horizon 4.4                              2480   11   11  3771   49%  2491   23% 
 744 EXchess 6.02b 64-bit                     2478   18   18  1275   46%  2508   25% 
 745 GreKo 6.5                                2473   19   19  1162   49%  2480   26% 
 746 Arion 1.7                                2469    9    9  5574   50%  2465   26% 
 747 DanaSah 2.44                             2468   40   40   269   46%  2498   30% 
 748 iCE 0.2                                  2467   21   21   953   43%  2526   26% 
 749 Cheese 1.2                               2466   15   15  2039   44%  2513   23% 
 750 Thor's Hammer 2.28 32-bit                2466   14   14  2412   56%  2406   19% 
 751 Sage 3.53                                2463   11   11  4178   48%  2481   22% 
 752 Tytan 9.32 64-bit                        2463   17   17  1528   49%  2469   24% 
 753 TJchess 1.1 64-bit                       2462   23   23   841   52%  2452   19% 
 754 Plisk 0.2.5n 64-bit                      2460   19   19  1290   57%  2392   21% 
 755 Sorgenkind 0.4                           2459   15   15  2007   48%  2478   21% 
 756 Butcher 1.61 64-bit 2CPU                 2458   22   22   941   47%  2484   22% 
 757 Ares 1.004                               2456   17   17  1673   54%  2418   23% 
 758 Chezzz 1.0.3                             2454   13   13  2841   54%  2413   20% 
 759 Nebiyu 1.2                               2443   45   45   316   28%  2688    9% 
 760 Alex 2.07a                               2442   17   17  1707   55%  2394   20% 
 761 Asterisk 0.6                             2441   12   12  3223   51%  2435   24% 
 762 Averno 0.81                              2440   12   12  3715   57%  2369   22% 
 763 Sungorus 1.4 64-bit                      2439   13   13  3067   56%  2386   22% 
 764 Joker 1.1.14                             2438   14   14  2348   50%  2431   21% 
 765 TJchess 1.01                             2437   16   16  1753   50%  2441   23% 
 766 Aice 0.99.2                              2435   12   12  3314   51%  2426   24% 
 767 Resp 0.19 64-bit JA Nobook               2434   10   10  4688   55%  2389   21% 
 768 KnightX 1.92                             2430    9    9  7108   55%  2386   21% 
 769 Simplex 0.9.7 64-bit                     2429   16   16  1811   53%  2405   18% 
 770 Cheese 1.1b                              2426   28   28   594   52%  2393   20% 
 771 Gibbon 2.57a 64-bit                      2424   16   16  1748   50%  2429   23% 
 772 Ayito 0.2.994                            2418   11   11  4318   57%  2352   18% 
 773 Homer 1.1 beta3                          2418   35   35   415   35%  2543   22% 
 774 Eeyore 1.48                              2417   14   14  2557   52%  2395   23% 
 775 Scidlet 3.61 x64 JA                      2414   11   11  3831   56%  2356   21% 
 776 Matilde 2008 64-bit                      2412   13   13  3075   56%  2364   21% 
 777 Ares 1.003a                              2411   15   15  2178   48%  2428   23% 
 778 KMTChess 1.2.1 64-bit                    2400   46   46   394   82%  2018    8% 
 779 Natwarlal 0.14                           2397    9    9  6487   51%  2381   20% 
 780 Popochin 3.2                             2394    9    9  6134   51%  2386   25% 
 781 Hermann 1.3.1                            2392   25   25   830   37%  2507   21% 
 782 Sjakk 1.1.9                              2392   15   15  2076   52%  2374   25% 
 783 Esc 1.16                                 2392   11   11  4580   58%  2320   22% 
 784 EXchess 5.01b 64-bit                     2391   14   14  2308   51%  2375   23% 
 785 LittleThought 1.03 64-bit 2CPU           2391   22   22   999   40%  2473   20% 
 786 Mediocre 0.5                             2390   29   29   509   54%  2354   24% 
 787 Capivara LK0.08a11 64-bit                2387   15   15  2320   64%  2266   18% 
 788 Horizon 4.3                              2384   27   27   690   46%  2416   20% 
 789 Zeus 1.29                                2380   11   11  4401   52%  2367   25% 
 790 Doctor 3.0                               2379   17   17  1691   58%  2302   26% 
 791 Deuterium 06.07.24.68b                   2374   35   35   501   19%  2662   17% 
 792 Betsabe II 1.09 JA                       2374   45   45   398   81%  2022   12% 
 793 Ant 2006-F                               2368   11   11  4327   52%  2351   21% 
 794 Butcher 1.60n1 64-bit                    2368   19   19  1400   49%  2364   19% 
 795 AliChess 4.25                            2361   13   13  2840   48%  2376   16% 
 796 GNU Chess 5.07 64-bit JA                 2360   22   22  1024   50%  2360   16% 
 797 Sage 2.2a                                2360   29   29   572   47%  2383   21% 
 798 Buzz 0.08 64-bit                         2358   20   20  1334   61%  2263   15% 
 799 Myrddin 0.85 64-bit                      2357   14   14  2570   53%  2333   22% 
 800 Anechka 0.08                             2354    9    9  7272   49%  2356   20% 
 801 EveAnn 1.66                              2352   14   14  2296   48%  2366   23% 
 802 Waxman 2010                              2352   13   13  2713   43%  2406   26% 
 803 Dorky 3.48                               2348   15   15  2259   53%  2319   20% 
 804 Nebiyu 1.4                               2347   32   32   480   39%  2455   16% 
 805 Adam 3.3                                 2346   13   13  2930   49%  2355   18% 
 806 Deuterium 06.07.24.61b                   2343   34   34   561   18%  2650   20% 
 807 Popochin 2.7                             2341   35   35   409   36%  2464   27% 
 808 Hussar 0.2                               2340   19   19  1206   47%  2365   19% 
 809 EveAnn 1.64                              2340   17   17  1585   49%  2352   23% 
 810 Jazz 501 64-bit                          2338   14   14  2389   51%  2333   22% 
 811 OBender 3.2.x                            2334   13   13  2929   49%  2337   19% 
 812 Gibbon 2.52a                             2333   27   27   641   50%  2335   19% 
 813 EXchess 4.03                             2330   17   17  1564   52%  2307   26% 
 814 EXchess 5.01b 64-bit Nobook              2329   22   22   927   39%  2420   24% 
 815 Deuterium 06.07.24.63b                   2329   37   37   505   16%  2663   15% 
 816 Jazz 444 64-bit                          2328   18   18  1358   45%  2372   25% 
 817 GreKo 5.1                                2328   39   39   318   58%  2251   23% 
 818 ECE 11.01                                2323   16   16  1808   48%  2336   21% 
 819 RattateChess 1.0 Nosferatu               2323   19   19  1263   49%  2326   23% 
 820 CyberPagno 2.1                           2322   10   10  5258   53%  2292   20% 
 821 Waxman 2011                              2320   19   19  1300   47%  2342   21% 
 822 Sjakk 1.1.8                              2319   20   20  1083   51%  2306   23% 
 823 Crafty 23.4 64-bit skill 50              2313  126  126   111   96%  1719    5% 
 824 Deuterium 06.07.24.62b                   2313   38   38   500   15%  2663   15% 
 825 EveAnn 1.63                              2310  117  117    30   33%  2438   27% 
 826 Alex 2.03                                2309   27   27   644   53%  2270   20% 
 827 Latista (Sinobyl) 1.5                    2308   11   11  4144   49%  2313   23% 
 828 Chispa 4.0.3                             2307    9    9  6869   52%  2289   35% 
 829 Mediocre 0.4                             2307   14   14  2419   47%  2332   21% 
 830 Madeleine 0.2                            2307   11   11  4227   51%  2295   20% 
 831 Atlas 2.20                               2307   13   13  2797   49%  2311   19% 
 832 Feuerstein 0.4.6.1                       2301   19   19  1494   70%  2104   16% 
 833 Uralochka 1.1b                           2301   13   13  2991   51%  2288   22% 
 834 Beowulf 2.4a 32-bit                      2300   13   13  2989   48%  2314   22% 
 835 LittleThought 0.97                       2297   45   45   249   49%  2304   22% 
 836 Shallow 1.0 64-bit                       2297   14   14  2294   49%  2304   21% 
 837 Atak 6.8                                 2295   12   12  3201   49%  2298   21% 
 838 Neurosis 2.3                             2295   76   76    96   21%  2556   15% 
 839 Chesley r323 64-bit JA                   2287   40   40   414   73%  2033   11% 
 840 Deuterium 06.07.24.71b                   2282   40   40   501   13%  2663   13% 
 841 Genesis 2.0                              2279   10   10  4822   52%  2259   22% 
 842 InmiChess3.06N                           2274   10   10  6073   53%  2250   20% 
 843 BlackBishop 1.0                          2269   11   11  4501   50%  2271   20% 
 844 BlackBishop 0.98                         2269   19   19  1500   41%  2351   17% 
 845 DiscoCheck 1.4 64-bit                    2263   27   27   606   44%  2315   22% 
 846 Kurt 0.9.2.2 64-bit                      2258   12   12  3438   52%  2240   19% 
 847 Lime 66                                  2254    9    9  6537   48%  2266   18% 
 848 NagaSkaki 5.12                           2253   12   12  3611   48%  2274   25% 
 849 Sunsetter 10.3 64-bit                    2252   12   12  3891   53%  2227   19% 
 850 Alarm 0.93.1                             2249   10   10  5434   54%  2218   17% 
 851 Nesik 0.7.0 alpha                        2244   11   11  4584   51%  2235   21% 
 852 WJChess 1.64                             2241   10   10  5658   51%  2229   20% 
 853 Firefly 2.5.8 64-bit                     2239   14   14  2576   54%  2201   18% 
 854 Fortress 1.62                            2237    9    9  6922   52%  2213   21% 
 855 Bearded 06-29                            2230   15   15  2365   65%  2095   17% 
 856 Adam 3.2                                 2228   18   18  1552   50%  2230   17% 
 857 Alex 1.96                                2223   21   21  1269   39%  2325   16% 
 858 Hussar 0.1                               2222   20   20  1135   57%  2165   21% 
 859 TJchess 0.121R                           2219   25   25   765   51%  2213   19% 
 860 KnockOut 0.7.1 32-bit                    2219   15   15  2217   55%  2171   18% 
 861 GK 0.90 64-bit                           2214   11   11  4211   51%  2207   20% 
 862 Alf 1.09                                 2209   13   13  3185   51%  2199   23% 
 863 Clarabit 1.00 64-bit                     2204   13   13  2745   49%  2213   23% 
 864 Ghost 0.14                               2202   18   18  1530   51%  2190   19% 
 865 Wing 2.0a                                2199   10   10  6063   52%  2179   21% 
 866 Uragano 3D 0.87                          2192   12   12  3693   54%  2155   20% 
 867 BikJump 2.01 64-bit                      2182   12   12  3895   50%  2179   20% 
 868 Myrddin 0.83k 64-bit                     2180   19   19  1278   51%  2169   23% 
 869 Prophet 2.0 Epsilon 2                    2177  128  128    26   40%  2256   19% 
 870 Rhetoric 0.10.d                          2175   13   13  3018   46%  2213   18% 
 871 Parrot 070722                            2173   13   13  3028   50%  2171   21% 
 872 Sjakk 1.1.7                              2168   22   22   971   46%  2201   24% 
 873 King's Out 0.2.42                        2156   23   23  1006   53%  2119   16% 
 874 Matheus 2.3                              2149    9    9  6566   49%  2161   21% 
 875 Dolphin 1.0                              2149   15   15  2355   46%  2184   15% 
 876 Monarch 1.7                              2146   11   11  4741   54%  2111   20% 
 877 Bodo 0.2b                                2144   11   11  4782   48%  2165   19% 
 878 ChessMind 0.82                           2142   14   14  2485   49%  2146   17% 
 879 Jabba 1.0 64-bit                         2134   14   14  2368   51%  2128   20% 
 880 Ax 0.8                                   2133   11   11  4746   46%  2172   17% 
 881 RDChess 3.23                             2132   12   12  3783   54%  2095   20% 
 882 Gerbil 0.2 64-bit                        2131   11   11  5019   53%  2107   19% 
 883 Bestia 0.90                              2131    9    9  6882   48%  2152   20% 
 884 ProChess 101 CN                          2128   22   22   978   53%  2101   17% 
 885 Matant 5.02                              2121   55   55   172   54%  2088   16% 
 886 ZCT 0.3.2500 64-bit                      2121   18   18  1563   52%  2107   15% 
 887 PLP 1661571                              2117   15   15  2337   52%  2093   13% 
 888 Gibbon 2.01b                             2110   44   44   272   43%  2189   19% 
 889 Zeta Dva 0210 64-bit                     2110   16   16  2124   51%  2100   14% 
 890 Freyr 1.068 64-bit                       2108   39   39   384   55%  2044   13% 
 891 DelphiMAX 2.9                            2100   11   11  4380   45%  2141   16% 
 892 Crafty 23.4 64-bit skill 40              2098   83   83   111   87%  1719   12% 
 893 Requiem 0.53                             2092   11   11  3823   50%  2092   44% 
 894 AdroitChess 0.3                          2089   16   16  1979   58%  2012   17% 
 895 Armageddon 2.308                         2085   12   12  3529   48%  2098   24% 
 896 Sjaak 399                                2084   16   16  2044   49%  2096   19% 
 897 Small Potato 0.6.1                       2080   10   10  5308   50%  2075   21% 
 898 BigLion 2.23x                            2078    9    9  7333   46%  2106   19% 
 899 Elephant 1.06                            2078   11   11  4549   47%  2101   17% 
 900 Bubble 1.5                               2074   15   15  2502   48%  2088   16% 
 901 Cupcake 1.0                              2074   15   15  2313   44%  2123   17% 
 902 FrankWalter 1.08                         2071   14   14  2478   47%  2094   20% 
 903 Gullydeckel 2.16pl1                      2065   16   16  2050   51%  2051   16% 
 904 La Dame Blanche 2.0c                     2059   14   14  2610   51%  2047   20% 
 905 Faile 1.4.4                              2058    9    9  7131   45%  2105   22% 
 906 Sjakk 1.1.5                              2058   19   19  1390   43%  2115   17% 
 907 Monik 2.2.3 64-bit                       2058   15   15  2448   51%  2047   17% 
 908 Cilian 4.14                              2056   12   12  3960   47%  2084   26% 
 909 Matant 5.04                              2054   13   13  3160   56%  2000   17% 
 910 Firefly 2.1.3                            2053   52   52   204   35%  2197   18% 
 911 Etude 0.1.2                              2051   13   13  2898   49%  2064   22% 
 912 SSEChessII 2.05 DC                       2049   11   11  5008   53%  2018   19% 
 913 BSC 3.9                                  2046   16   16  2034   51%  2040   12% 
 914 Monik 2.2.2                              2043   64   64   189   23%  2369   13% 
 915 Marvin 1.3.0                             2043   10   10  6903   47%  2064   19% 
 916 Monarch 1.5                              2039   38   38   382   41%  2131   18% 
 917 JanWillem 1.13                           2039   10   10  5673   47%  2061   17% 
 918 ChessMind 0.80                           2033   20   20  1382   41%  2120   13% 
 919 Rival 1.18                               2030   11   11  4909   53%  2003   18% 
 920 Micro-Max 4.8                            2028    9    9  7377   48%  2050   23% 
 921 Mustang 4.97                             2020   12   12  3771   52%  1998   25% 
 922 ChessKISS 1.3                            2015   13   13  3530   53%  1992   19% 
 923 Sharper 0.17                             2015   11   11  4928   45%  2053   17% 
 924 Protej 0.57                              2015   40   40   369   46%  2047    9% 
 925 BSC 3.9+ 64-bit 20Jan2012                2014   16   16  2241   40%  2110   12% 
 926 ChessterfieldCL i5a                      2008   39   39   369   62%  1889   12% 
 927 Smash 1.0.3                              2007   10   10  5911   49%  2013   17% 
 928 BibiChess 0.5                            2001   11   11  5028   48%  2012   21% 
 929 Heracles 0.6.16                          1999   10   10  5486   48%  2017   20% 
 930 BamBam                                   1994   17   17  1931   44%  2050   19% 
 931 Myrddin 0.82                             1993   22   22  1173   37%  2118   15% 
 932 Eagle 0.7.5                              1987   12   12  4430   52%  1970   13% 
 933 IACH 0.56z                               1986   13   13  3516   54%  1952   19% 
 934 MrChess 2.1                              1985   37   37   369   60%  1892   20% 
 935 SamChess                                 1984   38   38   371   59%  1892   16% 
 936 Clueless V1.4                            1980   10   10  6174   51%  1969   13% 
 937 Warrior 1.0.3                            1973   11   11  5450   51%  1963   21% 
 938 SnailChess 4.013                         1970   12   12  3806   55%  1927   20% 
 939 Morphy 3.22                              1965   12   12  3906   53%  1934   23% 
 940 Tyrell 1.02                              1950   37   37   369   55%  1896   20% 
 941 Surprise 4.3b13                          1944   17   17  2070   46%  1985   12% 
 942 FreeChessII 2.17                         1943   37   37   367   54%  1896   16% 
 943 ChessKISS 1.3a 64-bit                    1936   42   42   316   34%  2087   13% 
 944 Roce 0.0390                              1925   14   14  2948   50%  1922   19% 
 945 Arabian Knight 1.51 JA                   1924   37   37   367   53%  1896   18% 
 946 Mustang 3.0                              1919   50   50   177   57%  1868   37% 
 947 Simontacchi 1.81                         1910   14   14  3141   54%  1869   13% 
 948 Celes 0.77c                              1906   14   14  2721   53%  1883   19% 
 949 HeavyChess 0.13 beta                     1905   33   33   399   60%  1826   38% 
 950 Ajedrez Tactico 2.73b                    1895   15   15  2397   53%  1867   16% 
 951 JARS 1.75a                               1894   35   35   399   58%  1826   20% 
 952 Ranita 2.4                               1890   14   14  2822   51%  1885   18% 
 953 NoonianChess 3206P2                      1888   35   35   392   57%  1828   20% 
 954 Dabbaba 2.62                             1886   14   14  2997   45%  1931   14% 
 955 MatMoi 7.15.0-cct                        1886   18   18  1624   54%  1855   15% 
 956 RataAeroespacial 0.2.1                   1885   18   18  1648   53%  1857   13% 
 957 Beaches 2.32                             1867   14   14  3286   46%  1894   15% 
 958 Predateur 2.1 64-bit                     1867   13   13  3305   48%  1881   15% 
 959 Cecir 3.5                                1865   14   14  3084   49%  1871   19% 
 960 Alex 1.78                                1864   44   44   316   31%  2078   16% 
 961 BikJump v1.3                             1861   41   41   287   39%  1952   22% 
 962 Milady 3.04                              1860   19   19  1534   48%  1886   14% 
 963 Enigma 1.1.4                             1857   15   15  2401   49%  1859   20% 
 964 Soldat 0.25b                             1854   11   11  6138   38%  1981   19% 
 965 Grizzly 1.40.1b                          1837   13   13  3567   51%  1824   12% 
 966 Heracles 0.5.9                           1833   39   39   331   51%  1826   21% 
 967 Embracer 1.12                            1829   13   13  3228   51%  1816   23% 
 968 Chenard 2010.08.23 64-bit                1828   13   13  3407   48%  1845   14% 
 969 Bremboce 0.6.2                           1824   34   34   401   49%  1832   19% 
 970 Pulsar 2009-9b                           1821   36   36   378   60%  1734   20% 
 971 Chenard 2009.09.19                       1815   23   23  1301   24%  2108   10% 
 972 Mint 2.3                                 1814   35   35   398   59%  1734   19% 
 973 Macromix 2.01                            1813   24   24   790   52%  1793   28% 
 974 Robin 0.983                              1811   12   12  3964   50%  1804   19% 
 975 Crafty 23.4 64-bit skill 30              1799   67   67   106   59%  1714   17% 
 976 Lodocase 240208                          1797   35   35   394   45%  1836   14% 
 977 Vicki 0.041a                             1794   35   35   397   57%  1736   16% 
 978 Laurifer 1.0                             1790   11   11  5672   44%  1840   19% 
 979 Elf 1.3.0                                1790   11   11  6235   42%  1865   15% 
 980 Rocinante 2.0 64-bit (mcts)              1788   18   18  1486   49%  1798   18% 
 981 Kanguruh 1.93                            1772   17   17  1905   58%  1702   18% 
 982 Adamant 1.7                              1769   10   10  6703   43%  1827   15% 
 983 Mephisto MM5.1                           1767   26   26   647   48%  1780   22% 
 984 Aldebaran 0.7.0                          1758   12   12  4017   45%  1796   33% 
 985 Tscp 1.81                                1758   13   13  4072   47%  1783   15% 
 986 GChess IV 0.2.0                          1754   13   13  3252   58%  1677   29% 
 987 SEE 0.6.9                                1750   13   13  3858   52%  1728   19% 
 988 Bace 0.45                                1736   12   12  4510   52%  1707   17% 
 989 Golem 0.441                              1732   63   63   112   52%  1714   18% 
 990 RumbleMinze 1.0.33                       1729   24   24   980   40%  1832   13% 
 991 Roce 0.0360                              1728   38   38   349   34%  1857   26% 
 992 Tristram 3.36                            1720   36   36   399   48%  1741   11% 
 993 Gargamella 0.5.0                         1718   17   17  1888   51%  1705   17% 
 994 Jester 0.84                              1715   19   19  1510   52%  1697   13% 
 995 Zoidberg 0.1                             1715   35   35   397   47%  1741   14% 
 996 Mizar 3.0                                1713   12   12  5486   46%  1749   15% 
 997 RumbleMinze 1.0.30                       1713   25   25   774   46%  1745   19% 
 998 PolarChess 1.3                           1711   13   13  3932   53%  1680   17% 
 999 JaksaH 1.11 64-bit                       1707   14   14  3005   57%  1645   20% 
1000 Belzebub 0.67                            1688   12   12  4121   49%  1697   26% 
1001 DChess 1.0.2                             1686   13   13  3955   50%  1687   17% 
1002 Pooky 2.7                                1683   16   16  2313   52%  1662   17% 
1003 Simon 1.2 64-bit                         1682   16   16  2234   51%  1672   17% 
1004 ALChess 1.5b                             1680   14   14  2944   41%  1765   18% 
1005 Vapor 0.01r12                            1670   14   14  2618   56%  1620   39% 
1006 IQ23                                     1665   15   15  2084   49%  1669   36% 
1007 MSCP 1.44                                1654   13   13  4134   48%  1667   18% 
1008 Storm 0.6                                1651   12   12  4564   46%  1690   16% 
1009 ChessRikus 1.466                         1651   16   16  2274   47%  1678   16% 
1010 Rainman 0.7.5                            1650   26   26   713   39%  1742   26% 
1011 Rocinante 2.0 64-bit (PB*)               1641   34   34   437   31%  1817   17% 
1012 Ziggy 0.7 JA                             1632  164  164    53   95%   975    6% 
1013 Butterfly 0.5 64-bit                     1630   22   22  1022   54%  1616   39% 
1014 Grizzly 2.0.8x                           1629   33   33   653   18%  1957    9% 
1015 Hokus-Pokus 0.6.3                        1604   64   64   112   37%  1718   24% 
1016 Philemon C                               1597   63   63   115   35%  1720   23% 
1017 Zotron 4.4.6                             1597   13   13  3862   46%  1635   24% 
1018 SdBC 0.41.40                             1596   16   16  1990   43%  1652   23% 
1019 Needle 0.531                             1595   12   12  4653   43%  1654   24% 
1020 Damas 9                                  1589   15   15  2785   51%  1578   17% 
1021 Rocinante 1.01 64-bit                    1589   18   18  1679   45%  1636   18% 
1022 Larsen VB 0.05.0001                      1552   14   14  3455   42%  1622   18% 
1023 mACE 0.2.2.616                           1549   17   17  1877   46%  1586   17% 
1024 SharpChess2 2.6                          1541   15   15  2785   43%  1609    8% 
1025 Alibaba 1.38 wb JA                       1528   70   70   104   29%  1718   15% 
1026 VanillaChess 2.6g                        1525   68   68   112   29%  1717   14% 
1027 Crafty 23.4 64-bit skill 20              1518   40   40   303   38%  1620   19% 
1028 Vajolet 0.4.1                            1513   15   15  2644   43%  1574   16% 
1029 Purple Haze 2.0                          1510   14   14  3956   32%  1701   20% 
1030 Piranha 0.5                              1497   13   13  4146   37%  1626   13% 
1031 Butterfly 0.4                            1494   21   21  1093   39%  1583   39% 
1032 St Andersen 1.31 64-bit                  1491   16   16  2243   40%  1576   18% 
1033 Tarrasch Toy Engine 0.906                1488   15   15  2949   41%  1567   18% 
1034 Exacto 0.d                               1486   16   16  2345   45%  1529   24% 
1035 Yawce 0.16                               1481   66   66   154   46%  1454   11% 
1036 APILChess 1.05r1b                        1478   16   16  2312   42%  1551   22% 
1037 Pentagon 1.2                             1471   21   21  1102   40%  1555   32% 
1038 Roque 1.1                                1468   16   16  2311   43%  1531   17% 
1039 HoiChess 0.103 64-bit JA                 1464  130  130    52   88%   953   13% 
1040 Blikskottel 0.8                          1459   19   19  1554   45%  1502   19% 
1041 Braincrack alpha JA                      1439   77   77   105   20%  1725   11% 
1042 Nero 6.1                                 1438   16   16  2249   37%  1548   20% 
1043 Suff 0.3.a                               1435   76   76   109   21%  1717   11% 
1044 MiniMardi 1.3                            1385   15   15  3372   30%  1584   15% 
1045 Goyaz 0.007                              1376   37   37   527   59%  1295   14% 
1046 Tony's Chess 0.02                        1363   25   25   939   43%  1421   10% 
1047 JChess 1.0                               1362   20   20  1427   35%  1494   20% 
1048 Eden 0.0.13                              1358   17   17  2298   32%  1527   15% 
1049 Numpty Omega                             1356   16   16  2575   30%  1541   19% 
1050 Virutor Chess 1.1                        1353   24   24   919   37%  1456   20% 
1051 MiniChessAI 1.19                         1339   39   39   475   56%  1291   14% 
1052 Fimbulwinter 5.00                        1327   34   34   526   50%  1318   14% 
1053 Numpty 0.7pr                             1326   29   29   781   19%  1618   15% 
1054 Joanna 2002 1.03                         1324   29   29   645   41%  1400   27% 
1055 Nanook 0.17                              1318   27   27   695   38%  1408   41% 
1056 Skaki 123                                1316  114  114    49   78%   979   20% 
1057 Gedeone 1620                             1316  112  112    53   77%   961   15% 
1058 Supra 12.0                               1302   44   44   240   35%  1434   21% 
1059 Ozwald 0.43                              1294   39   39   478   53%  1269   13% 
1060 uMax 1.6w                                1275  108  108    52   75%   973   23% 
1061 TRex 1.9                                 1273   37   37   544   51%  1268   16% 
1062 Pierre 1.7 JA                            1257   46   46   487   66%  1046    6% 
1063 KillerQueen 2.0b3                        1248   37   37   524   50%  1261   24% 
1064 SUPRA 11.5.1 64-bit                      1199   45   45   370   70%   945   12% 
1065 Toledo nanoChess v15012010               1198   36   36   573   47%  1232   25% 
1066 BlitzKibitz 5                            1197  116  116    41   73%   908   34% 
1067 Crafty 23.4 64-bit skill 10              1182   43   43   380   32%  1385   19% 
1068 Raffaela                                 1176   37   37   547   42%  1272   24% 
1069 Gringo 1.4.9b                            1162   38   38   560   44%  1237   13% 
1070 QuteChess 1.0.1t r3 JA                   1150  104  104    50   63%   978   26% 
1071 Tikov 0.6.3 JA                           1146   38   38   547   39%  1269   14% 
1072 GrayMatter SVN1604                       1139   83   83   158   21%  1500   16% 
1073 Usurpator II                             1139   65   65   232   80%   716    8% 
1074 DarkFusch 0.9                            1133   97   97    54   64%   961   35% 
1075 Brama 051204                             1124  104  104    50   62%   956   24% 
1076 Frank 0.58                               1095  106  106    53   58%   966   11% 
1077 CmcChess 2.27                            1083   30   30   845   43%  1108   27% 
1078 Xadreco 5.7                              1061   64   64   194   72%   750   11% 
1079 Strategic Deep 1.25                      1055   42   42   604   57%   968    7% 
1080 Blitzter 2.0                             1046   59   59   210   64%   898    4% 
1081 Hanzo The Razor                          1042  109  109    40   50%  1004   40% 
1082 Jchecs 0.1.0                             1033  106  106    46   57%   930   39% 
1083 Neurone XVIII                            1021  116  116    41   51%   957   15% 
1084 Cassandre 0.24                           1019  130  130    33   58%   910   36% 
1085 Talvmenni 0.1 JA                          999  101  101    51   49%   971   39% 
1086 Kace 0.82 JA                              970  109  109    49   49%   952   16% 
1087 Safrad 2.1.35.210                         964   31   31  1243   41%  1052   18% 
1088 Kace 0.82                                 932   58   58   169   55%   899   25% 
1089 Testina 2.2                               916   45   45   396   62%   780   30% 
1090 GIUChess 1.0 beta2 JA                     916   50   50   237   50%   915   38% 
1091 Youk 1.0.5                                897   51   51   232   47%   919   31% 
1092 Iota 1.0 32-bit JA(tcc)                   888   44   44   435   57%   799   24% 
1093 NSVChess v0.14                            887   47   47   308   56%   833   34% 
1094 Chad's Chess 0.15                         860   33   33  1243   35%  1017   14% 
1095 Delfi 5.4 1000 Elo                        834   38   38   848   46%   911   13% 
1096 Crafty 23.4 64-bit skill 1                826   45   45   557   41%   959   11% 
1097 Dika 0.4209                               801   45   45   337   44%   853   50% 
1098 Dreamer                                   766   49   49   373   61%   654   18% 
1099 Hippocampe 0.4.1                          708   48   48   352   58%   648   33% 
1100 Pyotr 0.6 AM                              661   44   44   518   49%   668   28% 
1101 Chess4j 0.1                               624   42   42   791   30%   912   23% 
1102 EasyPeasy 1.0.0.0                         503   43   43   860   26%   869   11% 
1103 ReBorn Mainsworthy 1.30                   479   56   56   324   48%   513   19% 
1104 MicroChess 1976                           433   58   58   249   59%   343   27% 
1105 NEG 0.3d                                  383   50   50   481   35%   580   27% 
1106 Ram 2.0                                   374   49   49   515   33%   577   26% 
1107 LaMoSca 0.10                              299   54   54   310   29%   538   57% 
1108 CPP1                                      258   58   58   293   25%   553   21% 
1109 ACE 0.1                                   128   56   56   615   11%   772   17% 
1110 POS 1.20                                   87   62   62   360   15%   583   19% 
1111 Brutus RND                                  0   64   64   396    8%   593   17%
Hahaha! Look who is ranked 1096? Crafty! It is not even in the top 1000! Bob really does suck, doesn't he?

:roll:

Michel Van den Bergh
Posts: 24
Joined: Thu Jun 10, 2010 4:30 pm

Re: Crafty

Post by Michel Van den Bergh » Wed Sep 12, 2012 7:06 am

"I feel the program Crafty is no longer in the top 100 programs. I feel it is a run of the mill program now much like the author."

I made the above statements at CCC and the post was removed and Julien's PM told me I am libel. I broke some sort of CCC rule.

Telling the truth does not make someone libel and it is not against the CCC rules!
Can you remind me of the name of the top program you have written?

Please stop moaning. Not on CCC. Not here. Not anywhere.

hyatt
Posts: 1242
Joined: Thu Jun 10, 2010 2:13 am
Real Name: Bob Hyatt (Robert M. Hyatt)
Location: University of Alabama at Birmingham
Contact:

Re: Crafty

Post by hyatt » Wed Sep 12, 2012 6:15 pm

"Hahaha! Look who is ranked 1096? Crafty! It is not even in the top 1000! Bob really does suck, doesn't he?"

Actually it does show I have not done quite what I wanted YET. I want skill to be pretty linear, but it is not. But at least it is working. A while back all I did was randomize the eval, and these guys noted that it was impossible to get it to play below 1800-1900. I discovered it was related to "the beal effect" and had to make some changes to get it down to the 800 Elo range...

Adam Hair
Posts: 104
Joined: Fri Jun 11, 2010 4:29 am
Real Name: Adam Hair
Contact:

Re: Crafty

Post by Adam Hair » Wed Sep 12, 2012 6:46 pm

hyatt wrote:"Hahaha! Look who is ranked 1096? Crafty! It is not even in the top 1000! Bob really does suck, doesn't he?"

Actually it does show I have not done quite what I wanted YET. I want skill to be pretty linear, but it is not. But at least it is working. A while back all I did was randomize the eval, and these guys noted that it was impossible to get it to play below 1800-1900. I discovered it was related to "the beal effect" and had to make some changes to get it down to the 800 Elo range...
At some point in the next few months, I will increase the number of games for skill levels 10, 20, 30, 40, and 50 so that relationship between skill level and Elo is more apparent.

Code: Select all

303 Crafty 23.4 64-bit                       3021   14   14  2494   45%  3064   29%
824 Crafty 23.4 64-bit skill 50              2345  126  126   111   96%  1743    5%
892 Crafty 23.4 64-bit skill 40              2129   83   83   111   87%  1744   12%
975 Crafty 23.4 64-bit skill 30              1826   67   67   106   59%  1739   17% 
1027 Crafty 23.4 64-bit skill 20             1540   40   40   303   38%  1643   19%
1067 Crafty 23.4 64-bit skill 10             1199   43   43   380   32%  1405   19% 
1095 Crafty 23.4 64-bit skill 1               838   45   45   557   41%   973   11%
The only thing certain with this number of games is what you pointed out. The connection between skill and Elo is not linear.

By the way, the ratings here are set so that Brutus RND (which is a random mover) is at 0 Elo. Also, these games are played at a repeating time control more or less equivalent to the CCRL 40 moves in 4 minutes.

Post Reply