OpenChess

Independent Computer Chess Discussion Forum
https://open-chess.org/

Rybka / IvanHoe / Houdini etc.

https://open-chess.org/viewtopic.php?f=4&t=186

Page 1 of 1

Rybka / IvanHoe / Houdini etc.

Posted: Fri Jun 18, 2010 10:38 am
by TheKnilch
Hi all,

my private tournament is finished.

Vista64Bit, Q9550, 4 Core, 512MB Hash, TC 2'+1" , ponder Off, Fritz12 book (10 moves), Robbo & Nalimov (for Critter no TBs), all engines with standard parameters

After 990 matches

Code: Select all

18.06.2010 11:22:46 :

    Program                          Elo    +   -   Games   Score   Av.Op.  Draws

  1 IvanHoe-B 63Mod12c             : 3008   38  37   198    70.7 %   2855   42.4 %
  2 Deep Rybka 4 x64               : 2968   36  35   198    65.2 %   2859   46.5 %
  3 Houdini 1.01 x64 4_CPU         : 2956   35  34   198    63.4 %   2861   50.0 %
  4 Fire 1.31 x64 - Base           : 2944   37  37   198    61.6 %   2862   42.4 %
  5 Stockfish 1.7.1 JA 64bit       : 2886   37  37   198    52.5 %   2869   42.4 %
  6 Naum 4.2                       : 2840   35  35   198    45.2 %   2874   48.0 %
  7 Deep Fritz 12                  : 2801   37  38   198    39.1 %   2878   40.9 %
  8 Deep Shredder 12 x64           : 2800   37  38   198    38.9 %   2878   41.4 %
  9 Critter 0.70 64-bit            : 2791   36  37   198    37.6 %   2879   43.9 %
10 Protector 1.3.5 x64             : 2705   40  41   198    25.8 %   2889   36.4 %
 
18.06.2010 11:22:46 :
Individual statistics:

1 IvanHoe-B 63Mod12c        : 3008  198 (+ 98,= 84,- 16), 70.7 %

Deep Fritz 12                 :  22 (+ 13,=  6,-  3), 72.7 %
Protector 1.3.5 x64           :  22 (+ 15,=  6,-  1), 81.8 %
Deep Rybka 4 x64              :  22 (+  5,= 16,-  1), 59.1 %
Fire 1.31 x64 - Base          :  22 (+  6,= 12,-  4), 54.5 %
Deep Shredder 12 x64          :  22 (+ 13,=  7,-  2), 75.0 %
Stockfish 1.7.1 JA 64bit      :  22 (+ 13,=  6,-  3), 72.7 %
Houdini 1.01 x64 4_CPU        :  22 (+  4,= 17,-  1), 56.8 %
Critter 0.70 64-bit           :  22 (+ 17,=  5,-  0), 88.6 %
Naum 4.2                      :  22 (+ 12,=  9,-  1), 75.0 %

2 Deep Rybka 4 x64          : 2968  198 (+ 83,= 92,- 23), 65.2 %

Deep Fritz 12                 :  22 (+ 14,=  6,-  2), 77.3 %
Protector 1.3.5 x64           :  22 (+ 16,=  6,-  0), 86.4 %
Fire 1.31 x64 - Base          :  22 (+  6,= 12,-  4), 54.5 %
Deep Shredder 12 x64          :  22 (+ 12,=  9,-  1), 75.0 %
Stockfish 1.7.1 JA 64bit      :  22 (+  6,= 11,-  5), 52.3 %
Houdini 1.01 x64 4_CPU        :  22 (+  7,= 11,-  4), 56.8 %
Critter 0.70 64-bit           :  22 (+ 12,=  9,-  1), 75.0 %
IvanHoe-B 63Mod12c            :  22 (+  1,= 16,-  5), 40.9 %
Naum 4.2                      :  22 (+  9,= 12,-  1), 68.2 %

3 Houdini 1.01 x64 4_CPU    : 2956  198 (+ 76,= 99,- 23), 63.4 %

Deep Fritz 12                 :  22 (+  9,= 13,-  0), 70.5 %
Protector 1.3.5 x64           :  22 (+ 15,=  7,-  0), 84.1 %
Deep Rybka 4 x64              :  22 (+  4,= 11,-  7), 43.2 %
Fire 1.31 x64 - Base          :  22 (+  4,= 15,-  3), 52.3 %
Deep Shredder 12 x64          :  22 (+ 14,=  6,-  2), 77.3 %
Stockfish 1.7.1 JA 64bit      :  22 (+ 10,= 10,-  2), 68.2 %
Critter 0.70 64-bit           :  22 (+ 11,=  9,-  2), 70.5 %
IvanHoe-B 63Mod12c            :  22 (+  1,= 17,-  4), 43.2 %
Naum 4.2                      :  22 (+  8,= 11,-  3), 61.4 %

4 Fire 1.31 x64 - Base      : 2944  198 (+ 80,= 84,- 34), 61.6 %

Deep Fritz 12                 :  22 (+ 12,=  8,-  2), 72.7 %
Protector 1.3.5 x64           :  22 (+ 16,=  4,-  2), 81.8 %
Deep Rybka 4 x64              :  22 (+  4,= 12,-  6), 45.5 %
Deep Shredder 12 x64          :  22 (+ 11,=  7,-  4), 65.9 %
Stockfish 1.7.1 JA 64bit      :  22 (+  8,= 10,-  4), 59.1 %
Houdini 1.01 x64 4_CPU        :  22 (+  3,= 15,-  4), 47.7 %
Critter 0.70 64-bit           :  22 (+  9,= 10,-  3), 63.6 %
IvanHoe-B 63Mod12c            :  22 (+  4,= 12,-  6), 45.5 %
Naum 4.2                      :  22 (+ 13,=  6,-  3), 72.7 %

5 Stockfish 1.7.1 JA 64bit  : 2886  198 (+ 62,= 84,- 52), 52.5 %

Deep Fritz 12                 :  22 (+ 12,=  8,-  2), 72.7 %
Protector 1.3.5 x64           :  22 (+ 12,=  9,-  1), 75.0 %
Deep Rybka 4 x64              :  22 (+  5,= 11,-  6), 47.7 %
Fire 1.31 x64 - Base          :  22 (+  4,= 10,-  8), 40.9 %
Deep Shredder 12 x64          :  22 (+ 10,=  8,-  4), 63.6 %
Houdini 1.01 x64 4_CPU        :  22 (+  2,= 10,- 10), 31.8 %
Critter 0.70 64-bit           :  22 (+ 10,=  8,-  4), 63.6 %
IvanHoe-B 63Mod12c            :  22 (+  3,=  6,- 13), 27.3 %
Naum 4.2                      :  22 (+  4,= 14,-  4), 50.0 %

6 Naum 4.2                  : 2840  198 (+ 42,= 95,- 61), 45.2 %

Deep Fritz 12                 :  22 (+  7,= 12,-  3), 59.1 %
Protector 1.3.5 x64           :  22 (+ 12,=  8,-  2), 72.7 %
Deep Rybka 4 x64              :  22 (+  1,= 12,-  9), 31.8 %
Fire 1.31 x64 - Base          :  22 (+  3,=  6,- 13), 27.3 %
Deep Shredder 12 x64          :  22 (+  5,= 14,-  3), 54.5 %
Stockfish 1.7.1 JA 64bit      :  22 (+  4,= 14,-  4), 50.0 %
Houdini 1.01 x64 4_CPU        :  22 (+  3,= 11,-  8), 38.6 %
Critter 0.70 64-bit           :  22 (+  6,=  9,-  7), 47.7 %
IvanHoe-B 63Mod12c            :  22 (+  1,=  9,- 12), 25.0 %

7 Deep Fritz 12             : 2801  198 (+ 37,= 81,- 80), 39.1 %

Protector 1.3.5 x64           :  22 (+ 12,=  6,-  4), 68.2 %
Deep Rybka 4 x64              :  22 (+  2,=  6,- 14), 22.7 %
Fire 1.31 x64 - Base          :  22 (+  2,=  8,- 12), 27.3 %
Deep Shredder 12 x64          :  22 (+  7,=  9,-  6), 52.3 %
Stockfish 1.7.1 JA 64bit      :  22 (+  2,=  8,- 12), 27.3 %
Houdini 1.01 x64 4_CPU        :  22 (+  0,= 13,-  9), 29.5 %
Critter 0.70 64-bit           :  22 (+  6,= 13,-  3), 56.8 %
IvanHoe-B 63Mod12c            :  22 (+  3,=  6,- 13), 27.3 %
Naum 4.2                      :  22 (+  3,= 12,-  7), 40.9 %

8 Deep Shredder 12 x64      : 2800  198 (+ 36,= 82,- 80), 38.9 %

Deep Fritz 12                 :  22 (+  6,=  9,-  7), 47.7 %
Protector 1.3.5 x64           :  22 (+  9,= 12,-  1), 68.2 %
Deep Rybka 4 x64              :  22 (+  1,=  9,- 12), 25.0 %
Fire 1.31 x64 - Base          :  22 (+  4,=  7,- 11), 34.1 %
Stockfish 1.7.1 JA 64bit      :  22 (+  4,=  8,- 10), 36.4 %
Houdini 1.01 x64 4_CPU        :  22 (+  2,=  6,- 14), 22.7 %
Critter 0.70 64-bit           :  22 (+  5,= 10,-  7), 45.5 %
IvanHoe-B 63Mod12c            :  22 (+  2,=  7,- 13), 25.0 %
Naum 4.2                      :  22 (+  3,= 14,-  5), 45.5 %

9 Critter 0.70 64-bit       : 2791  198 (+ 31,= 87,- 80), 37.6 %

Deep Fritz 12                 :  22 (+  3,= 13,-  6), 43.2 %
Protector 1.3.5 x64           :  22 (+  4,= 14,-  4), 50.0 %
Deep Rybka 4 x64              :  22 (+  1,=  9,- 12), 25.0 %
Fire 1.31 x64 - Base          :  22 (+  3,= 10,-  9), 36.4 %
Deep Shredder 12 x64          :  22 (+  7,= 10,-  5), 54.5 %
Stockfish 1.7.1 JA 64bit      :  22 (+  4,=  8,- 10), 36.4 %
Houdini 1.01 x64 4_CPU        :  22 (+  2,=  9,- 11), 29.5 %
IvanHoe-B 63Mod12c            :  22 (+  0,=  5,- 17), 11.4 %
Naum 4.2                      :  22 (+  7,=  9,-  6), 52.3 %

10 Protector 1.3.5 x64       : 2705  198 (+ 15,= 72,-111), 25.8 %

Deep Fritz 12                 :  22 (+  4,=  6,- 12), 31.8 %
Deep Rybka 4 x64              :  22 (+  0,=  6,- 16), 13.6 %
Fire 1.31 x64 - Base          :  22 (+  2,=  4,- 16), 18.2 %
Deep Shredder 12 x64          :  22 (+  1,= 12,-  9), 31.8 %
Stockfish 1.7.1 JA 64bit      :  22 (+  1,=  9,- 12), 25.0 %
Houdini 1.01 x64 4_CPU        :  22 (+  0,=  7,- 15), 15.9 %
Critter 0.70 64-bit           :  22 (+  4,= 14,-  4), 50.0 %
IvanHoe-B 63Mod12c            :  22 (+  1,=  6,- 15), 18.2 %
Naum 4.2                      :  22 (+  2,=  8,- 12), 27.3 %

18.06.2010 11:22:46 :

Games        :    990 (finished)

White Wins   :    324 (32.7 %)
Black Wins   :    236 (23.8 %)
Draws        :    430 (43.4 %)
Unfinished   :      0

White Perf.  : 54.4 %
Black Perf.  : 45.6 %

ECO A =     62 Games ( 6.3 %)
ECO B =    282 Games (28.5 %)
ECO C =    186 Games (18.8 %)
ECO D =    238 Games (24.0 %)
ECO E =    222 Games (22.4 %)
PGN of all games (7z) http://www.mediafire.com/file/nytklnjlg2n/BigTour.7z

Remarks:

- IvanHoe unbelievable goot performance (against all engines). Great compile from PeterPan
- Houdini not so impressive
- Fire gets worse each release
- Rybka 4 not bad, with most feared opponents Stockfish and IvanHoe

Greetings
TK

Re: Rybka / IvanHoe / Houdini etc.

Posted: Fri Jun 18, 2010 8:33 pm
by beram
Hi the Knilch (oder Dieter),

I can confirm your good Ivanhoe B-63mod12c results against DR4.

Code: Select all

I am running a 50games match against DR4 on my AMD Phenom II X6 1090T 3200 Mhz,(Fritzmark 23,1)
TC 2m2sec , 512 Mb Hash, 50 privatbook positions, 
after 15 games Ivanhoe B-63mod12c leads +4 -1 10 =
I am watching great games, thanx for tipping this really good Ivanhoe version

kind regards Bram

Re: Rybka / IvanHoe / Houdini etc.

Posted: Fri Jun 18, 2010 8:42 pm
by notyetagm
Where can I find this great version of Ivanhoe?

Thanks

Re: Rybka / IvanHoe / Houdini etc.

Posted: Sat Jun 19, 2010 8:06 am
by beram
beram wrote:Hi the Knilch (oder Dieter),

I can confirm your good Ivanhoe B-63mod12c results against DR4.

Code: Select all

I am running a 50games match against DR4 on my AMD Phenom II X6 1090T 3200 Mhz,(Fritzmark 23,1)
TC 2m2sec , 512 Mb Hash, 50 privatbook positions, 
after 15 games Ivanhoe B-63mod12c leads +4 -1 10 =
I am watching great games, thanx for tipping this really good Ivanhoe version

kind regards Bram
Alas after finishing the 50 games match DR4 wins with 55%, so little disappointing for Iv12C

Code: Select all

1   Deep Rybka 4 SSE42 x64  +12/=31/-7 55.00%   27.5/50
2   IvanHoe-B 63Mod12c      +7/=31/-12 45.00%   22.5/50

Re: Rybka / IvanHoe / Houdini etc.

Posted: Sat Jun 19, 2010 8:07 am
by beram
notyetagm wrote:Where can I find this great version of Ivanhoe?

Thanks
http://www.speedyshare.com/files/226299 ... odB12c.rar

good luck Bram

Re: Rybka / IvanHoe / Houdini etc.

Posted: Mon Jun 21, 2010 11:23 pm
by AnthonyTheSage
The Houdini 64 bit version and the multiple processor versions seem to be lagging behind. But I think the 32 bit single processor Houdini 1.01 cannot be beat. Its a real monster. On my machine, which is a modest p4 2.8 with 1g ram, Houdini x32 runs 100 nodes per second on average faster the ivan mod12c. I ran a tourney between R4, Ivan Mod12c, and Houdini and it wasn't even close. Actually ivan mod12c was last place. It seems that the Ivanhoes and Rybkas are more designed to take advantage of the upgraded hardware.

Re: Rybka / IvanHoe / Houdini etc.

Posted: Tue Jun 22, 2010 2:55 am
by Swaminathan
Is Ivanhoe 63mod12c is any better than the latest 57a?

Re: Rybka / IvanHoe / Houdini etc.

Posted: Tue Jun 22, 2010 3:52 am
by halestorm
mod12c is considered the best Ivanhoe so far (or one of them). 57a has been out for less than 12 hours. If you want to know if it's better, help test it.

Speaking of tests:
1: Houdini 102_x64_POPCNT_4CPU   87.0/150  63-39-48
2: Deep Rybka 4 SSE42 x64        63.0/150  39-63-48
Level: Blitz 2/1
Hardware: Intel(R) Core(TM) i7 CPU 920 @ 2.67GHz8x 2700 MHz with 3,072 MB Memory
Operating system: Windows 7 Ultimate Professional (Build 7600)
All times are UTC+01:00
Page 1 of 1
Powered by phpBB® Forum Software © phpBB Limited
https://www.phpbb.com/