Komodo 4 Initial Impression
Posted: Sun Jan 01, 2012 4:08 pm
Komodo 4 first impression is that it's a little more aggressive, and a slight improvement over version 3. One thing noted immediately is the sudden death time management (at least at 1 minute) is very aggressive, and forces opponents to get into time trouble and lose.
The author posted on talkchess that komodo, paraphrasing, "has the most accurate evaluation of any chess program today" which I seriously doubt; if anything, it can be a bit inflated at times -- see attached screen-shot.
The more accurate a program evaluates a position, the fewer losses it is expected to produce. This is how evaluation is measured because chess is not yet solved. Right now, Komodo is close in strength to IvanHoe, so, it does not have the most accurate evaluation of current chess engines. Looking forward to the SMP release...
One wonders how this Komodo release would fair against IvanHoe 999964h (with updated time management) at long time control where it is said to do better. It would be surprising if Komodo comes out ahead.
Some sample head-to-head matches:
[Event "Computer Chess Game"]
[Site "openSUSE"]
[Date "2011.12.31"]
[Round "1"]
[White "Komodo64 SSE Version 4"]
[Black "IvanHoe 9.46b x64"]
[Result "0-1"]
[TimeControl "900+10"]
[Annotator "1. +0.28 1... +0.12"]
1. d4 {+0.28/20} d5 {+0.12/21 39} 2. c4 {+0.20/21 54} dxc4 {+0.14/20 36} 3.
e3 {+0.24/20 39} Be6 {+0.21/21 0.2} 4. Nf3 {+0.21/19 29} Nf6
{+0.15/22 1:47} 5. Nc3 {+0.42/20 35} h6 {+0.22/21 45} 6. Ne5 {+0.35/21 5}
Nbd7 {+0.20/21 14} 7. Nxc4 {+0.37/21 31} c6 {+0.22/20 20} 8. e4
{+0.49/21 10} Bxc4 {+0.31/20 43} 9. Bxc4 {+0.45/23 2.7} b5 {+0.37/22 26}
10. Be2 {+0.44/22 58} b4 {+0.29/22 0.2} 11. Na4 {+0.38/22 31} Nxe4
{+0.37/22 0.1} 12. Bf4 {+0.33/21 43} g5 {+0.29/21 1:16} 13. Be3
{+0.64/16 5} Rc8 {+0.16/22 2:33} 14. O-O {+0.37/19 34} e6 {+0.14/20 17} 15.
Qc2 {+0.20/18 15} Nef6 {+0.06/19 0.2} 16. Nc5 {+0.08/19 1:06} Nxc5
{-0.16/20 0.2} 17. dxc5 {+0.11/19 4} Bg7 {-0.28/20 24} 18. a3 {+0.14/20 10}
a5 {-0.28/20 0.2} 19. Rfd1 {-0.11/17 27} Nd5 {-0.36/19 19} 20. axb4
{-0.14/18 10} axb4 {-0.37/20 5} 21. Ba6 {-0.25/19 45} Rb8 {-0.65/20 39} 22.
Bd4 {-0.37/19 26} Bxd4 {-0.75/21 28} 23. Rxd4 {-0.47/20 18} Ra8
{-0.87/21 32} 24. g3 {-0.58/21 1:02} O-O {-0.95/21 15} 25. Rdd1
{-0.63/20 22} Qe7 {-0.95/21 0.2} 26. Bd3 {-0.63/20 13} Rfb8 {-0.98/21 40}
27. Rac1 {-0.59/21 22} Ra5 {-0.99/22 0.2} 28. Qc4 {-0.65/21 21} Qf6
{-1.04/23 0.2} 29. Qb3 {-0.74/19 8} Kg7 {-1.03/22 22} 30. Kg2 {-0.76/21 32}
h5 {-1.03/21 36} 31. Rd2 {-0.79/21 10} g4 {-1.04/21 0.1} 32. Kg1
{-0.79/20 21} Qe7 {-1.15/21 0.2} 33. Rdc2 {-0.81/21 23} Rba8 {-1.21/21 15}
34. Qc4 {-0.81/20 19} Ra1 {-1.21/23 0.2} 35. Rxa1 {-0.86/22 38} Rxa1+
{-1.24/25 0.2} 36. Rc1 {-0.97/22 11} Ra5 {-1.25/25 0.1} 37. Kg2
{-1.07/20 18} Qg5 {-1.59/20 18} 38. Kg1 {-1.40/19 36} Qd2 {-1.75/21 18} 39.
Rb1 {-1.55/21 0.9} Nf6 {-1.69/23 10} 40. Kg2 {-1.46/22 4} Qg5 {-1.71/23 6}
41. Rc1 {-1.74/21 39} Ra2 {-1.98/25 0.2} 42. Rc2 {-1.90/22 23} Ra1
{-2.53/22 32} 43. Be2 {-1.75/21 20} Re1 {-2.61/24 0.2} 44. f4 {-2.03/20 15}
Qd5+ {-2.68/24 0.2} 45. Qxd5 {-2.33/21 3} exd5 {-2.73/26 15} 46. Kf2
{-2.54/24 13} Rh1 {-2.96/27 32} 47. Kg2 {-2.72/26 14} Rb1 {-2.96/28 0.2}
48. Bd3 {-2.97/24 17} b3 {-3.12/26 0.2} 49. Re2 {-2.96/20 1.4} Rd1
{-3.83/23 24} 50. Bf5 {-3.26/24 40} d4 {-4.18/24 0.2} 51. Kf2
{-3.19/20 0.8} Nd5 {-4.43/22 14} 52. Re5 {-3.57/22 16} d3 {-4.81/21 18} 53.
Re1 {-4.36/24 1.1} Rd2+ {-5.61/22 23} 54. Kg1 {-4.94/25 4} Rxb2
{-6.02/22 15} 55. Bxd3 {-5.15/24 0.3} Rd2 {-6.19/23 24} 56. Be4
{-5.42/23 5} b2 {-6.32/23 11} 57. Bf5 {-5.57/23 3} Kf6 {-7.06/25 1:06} 58.
Bh7 {-5.88/26 15} Nc3 {-7.06/25 0.2} 59. Kf1 {-5.95/22 1.6} Rxh2
{-7.88/22 19} 60. Re3 {-6.15/27 54} Nd5 {-8.34/24 0.2} 61. Rb3
{-5.57/19 11} h4 {-8.42/23 0.1} 62. gxh4 {-5.79/19 7} Nxf4 {-8.84/22 39}
63. Kg1 {-6.17/22 8} Re2 {-10.34/22 34} 64. Kf1 {-5.95/19 4} Ke5
{-10.40/22 19} 65. Bb1 {-6.45/22 5} Rh2 {-10.93/22 37} 66. Re3+
{-6.60/23 4} Kd5 {-10.96/22 10} 67. Bf5 {-6.87/22 23} Rxh4 {-11.03/22 0.2}
68. Rb3 {-6.72/21 19} g3 {-11.76/22 0.2} 69. Rxg3 {-9.09/22 10} Rh1+
{-11.76/22 0.2} 70. Kf2 {-9.36/20 1.0} Ke5 {-12.66/21 23} 71. Rg7
{-9.88/25 12} Kf6 {-13.12/21 0.2} 72. Rxf7+ {-10.73/23 19} Kxf7
{-17.32/18 16} 73. Be4 {-99.02/23 1:01} Rd1 {-99.73/21 0.1} 74. Ke3
{-99.78/20 12} Nd5+ {-99.73/20 0.2} 75. Kf2 {-11.43/21 11} Kf6
{-99.75/20 0.1} 76. Kg3 {-99.74/21 20} Nb4 {-99.87/18 28} 77. Kh3
{-99.84/20 10} Re1 {-99.87/17 9} 78. Bb1 {-99.88/22 15} Rxb1 {-99.89/18 10}
79. Kh2 {-99.90/23 5} Re1 {-99.91/19 23} 80. Kg3 {-99.92/23 24} Re3+
{-99.93/18 13} 81. Kf2 {-99.92/21 4} Rd3 {-99.93/19 27} 82. Kf1
{-99.94/19 1.4} b1=Q+ {-99.93/16 20} 83. Ke2 {-99.96/23 17} Qc2+
{-99.97/17 0.2} 84. Kf1 {-99.98/21 0.8} Rd1# {-99.99/125 0.3}
{Xboard adjudication: Checkmate} 0-1
[Event "Computer Chess Game"]
[Site "openSUSE"]
[Date "2011.12.31"]
[Round "3"]
[White "IvanHoe 9.46b x64"]
[Black "Komodo64 SSE Version 4"]
[Result "1-0"]
[TimeControl "900+10"]
[Annotator "1. +0.10 1... +0.28"]
1. d4 {+0.10/21} d5 {+0.28/17 7} 2. Nf3 {+0.13/21 1:17} Bf5 {+0.17/19 45}
3. c4 {+0.24/19 26} e6 {+0.15/20 24} 4. cxd5 {+0.23/20 0.3} exd5
{+0.09/20 46} 5. Nc3 {+0.15/20 56} c6 {+0.10/20 26} 6. g3 {+0.09/20 39} Be7
{+0.02/20 31} 7. Bg2 {+0.01/21 47} Nf6 {+0.02/22 2:09} 8. Nh4 {+0.05/22 54}
Be6 {-0.08/19 5} 9. O-O {+0.03/21 40} O-O {-0.07/21 0.6} 10. Qc2
{+0.06/21 49} Qc8 {-0.05/19 11} 11. Nf3 {+0.05/19 33} Bf5 {-0.17/20 20} 12.
Qb3 {+0.00/21 0.2} Nbd7 {-0.06/20 1:03} 13. Bf4 {+0.01/20 46} Rd8
{-0.09/20 23} 14. Nh4 {+0.01/18 53} Be6 {-0.21/19 32} 15. Nf3
{+0.00/21 0.2} Nb6 {-0.19/18 20} 16. Ng5 {-0.04/19 17} Bd7 {-0.22/19 8} 17.
Nf3 {-0.04/20 19} Nc4 {-0.23/19 20} 18. Rfe1 {+0.00/20 27} b5 {-0.16/18 11}
19. e4 {+0.06/20 24} dxe4 {-0.11/21 14} 20. Nxe4 {+0.06/20 0.2} Nd5
{-0.14/21 35} 21. Bc1 {+0.04/20 0.3} Bb4 {-0.08/18 43} 22. Bd2
{+0.07/20 0.3} Nxd2 {-0.14/20 30} 23. Nfxd2 {+0.04/19 0.3} a5 {-0.11/21 31}
24. a3 {+0.06/21 24} a4 {-0.13/22 42} 25. Qd3 {+0.00/22 0.2} Ba5
{-0.16/20 11} 26. Nc5 {+0.00/22 0.3} Bf5 {-0.10/21 21} 27. Be4
{+0.00/21 10} Bg6 {-0.09/22 56} 28. Bxg6 {+0.15/21 31} hxg6 {-0.15/20 10}
29. Rac1 {+0.14/23 34} Qf5 {-0.09/21 46} 30. Re2 {+0.06/22 21} Qg5
{-0.10/22 4} 31. h4 {+0.38/21 19} Qg4 {-0.15/20 9} 32. Re4 {+0.30/20 0.4}
Qc8 {-0.01/21 27} 33. Nf3 {+0.26/21 38} Ra7 {-0.03/22 46} 34. Ne5
{+0.25/21 1:17} Bb6 {-0.15/20 16} 35. Qf3 {+0.25/21 0.3} Rc7 {+0.01/20 19}
36. Ree1 {+0.23/21 0.3} Nf6 {+0.03/21 22} 37. Red1 {+0.23/21 0.5} Rd5
{-0.03/21 30} 38. Kg2 {+0.12/20 25} Rd6 {-0.03/22 7} 39. Rc2 {+0.24/20 17}
Ba7 {+0.05/20 34} 40. Rd3 {+0.21/20 0.3} Bb6 {+0.05/19 15} 41. Rdd2
{+0.24/20 15} Nd5 {+0.05/19 15} 42. Ne4 {+0.28/20 16} Re6 {+0.15/19 5} 43.
Ng5 {+0.24/21 15} Rf6 {+0.05/18 4} 44. Qd3 {+0.24/22 43} Rf4 {+0.05/19 16}
45. Ngf3 {+0.24/22 0.3} Rf6 {+0.05/22 16} 46. Rd1 {+0.27/20 0.3} Rd6
{+0.05/20 20} 47. Re2 {+0.27/21 0.4} Nf6 {-0.13/18 6} 48. Rc1
{+0.27/20 0.4} Qb8 {-0.08/19 13} 49. Qe3 {+0.27/20 31} Qe8 {+0.05/20 18}
50. b4 {+0.34/20 25} Qd8 {+0.05/18 16} 51. Qg5 {+0.35/21 0.4} Qf8
{+0.05/18 15} 52. Qf4 {+0.39/21 28} Nd5 {+0.05/22 13} 53. Qd2
{+0.47/20 0.4} Qc8 {+0.38/19 29} 54. Rce1 {+0.63/22 0.4} Rd8 {+0.41/19 13}
55. Qd3 {+0.54/20 18} Rf8 {+0.50/20 7} 56. Rc2 {+0.54/20 11} Ne7
{+0.56/20 1.3} 57. Rcc1 {+0.57/19 36} Nd5 {+0.47/20 16} 58. Re2
{+0.54/21 0.4} Ne7 {+0.48/22 16} 59. Qd2 {+0.54/19 9} Ba7 {+0.46/19 46} 60.
Qa2 {+0.72/19 12} Bb6 {+0.76/18 32} 61. Ng5 {+0.78/20 0.4} Nd5
{+0.72/20 15} 62. Rxc6 {+0.97/21 0.4} Rxc6 {+0.69/21 14} 63. Qxd5
{+0.89/21 7} Rf6 {+0.80/21 0.3} 64. Nd7 {+0.89/22 14} Qa8 {+0.70/24 10} 65.
Qe4 {+0.89/24 8} Rd8 {+0.71/24 11} 66. Nxf6+ {+0.89/24 0.5} gxf6
{+0.72/22 1.1} 67. Nf3 {+0.89/25 22} Qxe4 {+0.70/22 9} 68. Rxe4
{+0.89/25 0.4} Kg7 {+0.74/23 7} 69. Re3 {+0.89/24 11} Rd7 {+0.83/21 5} 70.
Rd3 {+0.89/24 11} Rd5 {+0.80/18 1.4} 71. g4 {+0.89/23 5} Kf8 {+0.56/18 2.6}
72. Rd1 {+0.89/22 16} Ke7 {+0.63/17 1.8} 73. Kf1 {+1.02/22 6} f5
{+0.85/22 14} 74. g5 {+0.96/24 0.4} Rd8 {+0.98/23 24} 75. Ke2
{+1.06/24 0.4} Re8 {+0.49/20 6} 76. Kd3 {+1.17/23 13} Kd7 {+0.62/22 1.9}
77. Re1 {+1.17/24 9} Rxe1 {+0.74/26 7} 78. Nxe1 {+1.17/27 0.4} Kc6
{+0.74/26 5} 79. Ng2 {+1.17/28 13} Bc7 {+1.18/22 2.6} 80. Ne3 {+1.33/27 16}
Bf4 {+1.17/26 6} 81. Ke2 {+1.40/27 19} Bd6 {+1.36/25 4} 82. Nd1
{+1.40/26 6} Kd5 {+1.35/26 16} 83. Kd3 {+1.64/27 0.4} Kc6 {+1.25/24 7} 84.
Nc3 {+1.72/26 0.6} Kb6 {+1.48/24 7} 85. Ne2 {+1.85/25 0.5} Kc6
{+1.59/25 11} 86. d5+ {+1.85/24 0.3} Kxd5 {+1.40/21 0.7} 87. Nd4
{+1.91/23 9} Bf4 {+1.40/24 15} 88. Nxb5 {+1.90/24 0.4} Ke5 {+1.55/20 0.7}
89. Kc4 {+2.00/23 26} Bd2 {+1.74/24 31} 90. Nd4 {+2.24/24 0.5} Kd6
{+1.77/24 13} 91. Kd3 {+2.23/22 0.4} Bc1 {+1.92/25 14} 92. Kc2
{+2.40/23 21} Bf4 {+2.28/25 9} 93. Nb5+ {+2.40/23 0.4} Ke6 {+2.29/24 11}
94. Nc3 {+2.56/23 0.3} f6 {+2.35/24 14} 95. gxf6 {+2.68/22 0.5} Be5
{+2.42/24 14} 96. f7 {+2.80/22 0.4} Kxf7 {+2.42/21 1.2} 97. Nxa4
{+2.84/21 10} Bd4 {+2.52/24 2.5} 98. f4 {+3.09/21 9} Ke6 {+2.69/24 7} 99.
Kd3 {+3.41/22 18} Bf2 {+2.69/23 4} 100. Nc5+ {+3.56/21 6} Kd5 {+2.72/27 11}
101. Nd7 {+3.58/22 0.4} Bxh4 {+3.10/22 5} 102. Ne5 {+3.58/22 3} Bg3
{+3.27/25 9} 103. Nxg6 {+3.69/23 19} Bf2 {+4.07/25 6} 104. a4 {+4.82/22 12}
Be1 {+5.36/25 0.5} 105. b5 {+5.62/21 24} Kd6 {+5.53/26 12} 106. Kc4
{+6.82/20 16} Bd2 {+5.73/29 1.3} 107. Nh4 {+7.72/19 12} Kc7 {+8.30/31 1:03}
108. Nxf5 {+9.89/22 0.3} Bxf4 {+8.30/21 0.5} 109. a5 {+15.22/20 1:01} Be5
{+98.62/27 6} 110. Kc5 {+15.27/20 20} Kb7 {+99.62/23 30} 111. Nd6+
{+17.90/19 0.4} Ka7 {+317.94/23 8} 112. a6 {+99.69/22 20} Bg3
{+99.72/24 11} 113. Kc6 {+99.75/23 30} Bf2 {+99.74/24 3} 114. Nc8+
{+99.77/22 7} Kb8 {+99.76/26 4} 115. b6 {+99.79/23 3} Bxb6 {+99.80/25 2.9}
116. Kxb6 {+99.81/24 9} Kxc8 {+99.82/24 1.8} 117. a7 {+99.83/32 8} Kd7
{+99.84/23 1.1} 118. a8=Q {+99.87/38 17} Ke6 {+99.86/24 12} 119. Qe4+
{+99.89/45 21} Kf7 {+99.86/21 4} 120. Qf5+ {+99.89/47 4} Kg7
{+99.88/21 2.8} 121. Qg5+ {+99.89/55 26} Kh8 {+99.90/21 6} 122. Qh6+
{+99.91/56 15} Kg8 {+99.88/20 1.1} 123. Kc7 {+99.91/58 8} Kf7 {+99.90/23 3}
124. Kd6 {+99.93/57 18} Kg8 {+99.92/24 5} 125. Ke5 {+99.93/57 2.0} Kf7
{+99.94/21 0.1} 126. Qh7+ {+99.93/56 56} Ke8 {+99.96/26 23} 127. Ke6
{+99.97/84 44} Kd8 {+99.98/25 18} 128. Qd7# {+99.99/125 0.3}
{Xboard adjudication: Checkmate} 1-0
[Event "Computer Chess Game"]
[Site "openSUSE"]
[Date "2012.01.01"]
[Round "1"]
[White "IvanHoe 9.46b x64"]
[Black "Komodo64 SSE Version 4"]
[Result "1/2-1/2"]
[TimeControl "600"]
[Annotator "1. +0.10 1... +0.21"]
1. d4 {+0.10/21} d5 {+0.21/16 2.8} 2. Bf4 {+0.14/20 32} Nc6 {+0.14/21 42}
3. Nf3 {+0.12/20 16} Bf5 {+0.09/19 7} 4. e3 {+0.03/20 29} e6 {+0.09/21 16}
5. Bd3 {+0.07/21 0.3} Bxd3 {+0.15/19 25} 6. Qxd3 {+0.03/21 0.3} Nf6
{+0.15/19 12} 7. O-O {+0.14/20 10} Bd6 {+0.17/19 6} 8. Bg5 {+0.14/20 0.3}
h6 {+0.11/18 14} 9. Bxf6 {+0.27/19 7} Qxf6 {+0.10/20 4} 10. c4 {+0.23/20 7}
O-O {+0.18/19 16} 11. c5 {+0.26/22 1:22} Be7 {+0.08/18 5} 12. Nc3
{+0.26/22 0.3} a6 {+0.10/20 25} 13. Rad1 {+0.26/19 14} Rad8 {+0.10/20 9}
14. Qc2 {+0.29/19 0.3} Qg6 {+0.03/20 25} 15. Qxg6 {+0.29/19 20} fxg6
{+0.05/23 29} 16. h3 {+0.29/20 0.3} g5 {+0.04/21 8} 17. Rd2 {+0.31/19 9} g6
{-0.03/18 5} 18. Rb1 {+0.34/19 7} Rf7 {+0.08/19 7} 19. b4 {+0.46/20 4} Bf6
{+0.05/19 0.3} 20. b5 {+0.46/21 4} Na5 {+0.07/16 2.0} 21. bxa6 {+0.47/18 4}
bxa6 {+0.05/21 1.3} 22. Rdd1 {+0.43/21 15} Kg7 {+0.05/19 8} 23. Rb4
{+0.43/22 0.3} Nc6 {+0.10/20 8} 24. Ra4 {+0.43/20 4} Ra8 {+0.09/16 2.2} 25.
Ra3 {+0.47/21 7} h5 {+0.05/19 9} 26. Ne1 {+0.49/19 6} g4 {+0.05/20 1.6} 27.
hxg4 {+0.53/18 3} hxg4 {+0.05/16 1.0} 28. Nd3 {+0.59/18 2.1} g3
{+0.12/18 5} 29. f3 {+0.71/18 3} a5 {+0.22/19 5} 30. Ne2 {+0.73/20 0.4} Bh4
{+0.37/18 5} 31. Rb3 {+0.81/19 15} a4 {+0.35/18 12} 32. Rb5 {+0.77/19 13}
Rff8 {+0.35/18 10} 33. Rdb1 {+0.77/18 6} Rh8 {+0.40/18 6} 34. f4
{+0.91/19 16} a3 {+0.52/18 12} 35. Ne1 {+0.92/19 5} Na5 {+0.49/19 6} 36.
Nf3 {+1.03/20 0.4} Nc4 {+0.57/18 1.2} 37. Rb7 {+1.13/19 4} Rac8
{+0.57/18 0.2} 38. Nc3 {+1.08/18 4} Rh5 {+0.73/18 16} 39. Ra7 {+1.20/17 5}
Kg8 {+0.85/16 11} 40. Rbb7 {+1.51/18 4} Rh7 {+1.05/17 6} 41. Ra6
{+1.75/20 0.3} Re8 {+1.29/18 5} 42. Nb5 {+1.40/19 0.4} c6 {+0.82/17 4} 43.
Rxh7 {+1.39/19 0.4} Kxh7 {+0.79/16 0.4} 44. Nxa3 {+0.40/19 35} Rb8
{+0.31/17 2.9} 45. Nxh4 {+0.18/19 6} Rb2 {+0.05/21 1.9} 46. Kf1
{+0.12/19 0.4} Nxe3+ {+0.05/19 2.1} 47. Ke1 {+0.07/21 0.4} Nxg2+
{+0.05/19 1.8} 48. Nxg2 {+0.08/22 0.4} Rxg2 {+0.05/20 1.5} 49. Kf1
{+0.06/22 6} Rxa2 {+0.05/19 1.4} 50. Rxc6 {+0.05/22 0.9} Rxa3
{+0.05/20 1.8} 51. Rxe6 {+0.05/23 2.7} Rf3+ {+0.05/21 0.2} 52. Kg2
{+0.05/24 2.6} Rxf4 {+0.05/22 0.5} 53. Re7+ {+0.00/24 6} Kh6 {+0.05/25 4}
54. Re2 {+0.00/26 0.5} Rxd4 {+0.05/20 0.5} 55. Rc2 {+0.00/25 1.9} Re4
{+0.05/22 0.7} 56. c6 {+0.00/24 2.5} Re8 {+0.05/22 0.2} 57. Kxg3
{+0.00/24 1.0} g5 {+0.05/24 4} 58. Kg4 {+0.00/24 2.8} Kg6 {+0.05/24 5} 59.
c7 {+0.00/26 0.4} Rc8 {+0.05/25 2.7} 60. Rc6+ {+0.00/27 0.4} Kf7
{+0.05/22 0.3} 61. Rd6 {+0.00/27 2.5} Rxc7 {-0.02/14 1.0} 62. Rxd5
{+0.00/26 1.0} Ke6 {-0.02/19 2.7} 63. Ra5 {+0.00/26 2.8} Rc2 {-0.02/21 4}
64. Ra6+ {+0.00/25 1.2} Ke5 {-0.02/21 2.5} 65. Ra5+ {+0.00/26 3} Ke4
{-0.02/19 5} 66. Kxg5 {+0.00/25 3} Rc6 {-0.01/21 1.8} 67. Ra4+
{+0.00/26 1.0} Kd3 {-0.02/18 2.9} 68. Ra3+ {+0.00/24 0.9} Kd4
{-0.02/19 1.4} 69. Ra4+ {+0.00/28 0.3} Kd5 {-0.01/21 5} 70. Ra5+
{+0.00/30 0.5} Kc4 {-0.02/21 1.9} 71. Ra4+ {+0.00/26 1.7} Kc5 {-0.02/22 3}
72. Ra5+ {+0.00/27 0.9} Kb4 {-0.02/22 2.0} 73. Rd5 {+0.00/29 2.0} Kc3
{-0.02/22 2.1} 74. Kf4 {+0.00/27 3} Rc8 {-0.02/22 4} 75. Ra5 {+0.00/26 2.7}
Kd4 {-0.02/22 2.6} 76. Kg5 {+0.00/27 3} Rg8+ {-0.02/23 2.4} 77. Kf5
{+0.00/28 1.5} Rf8+ {-0.02/23 2.2} 78. Kg4 {+0.00/29 0.5} Rf1
{-0.02/23 2.2} 79. Ra4+ {+0.00/28 1.7} Kc5 {-0.02/23 2.1} 80. Kh4
{+0.00/26 1.5} Rg1 {-0.02/24 2.4} 81. Rf4 {+0.00/28 0.5} Rg2 {-0.02/24 1.6}
82. Rf5+ {+0.00/28 0.4} Kd4 {-0.02/24 1.0} 83. Rf4+ {+0.00/28 0.5} Ke5
{-0.02/24 1.5} 84. Rg4 {+0.00/29 2.8} Re2 {-0.02/24 0.4} 85. Rg5+
{+0.00/26 0.9} Kf4 {-0.02/23 0.9} 86. Rg4+ {+0.00/29 0.9} Kf5
{-0.02/22 0.6} 87. Rg5+ {+0.00/29 1.3} Ke4 {-0.02/21 0.5} 88. Rg4+
{+0.00/28 0.7} Kd5 {-0.02/23 0.3} 89. Rg5+ {+0.00/28 0.7} Kc4
{-0.02/24 1.9} 90. Rg4+ {+0.00/29 0.8} Kc5 {-0.02/23 0.9} 91. Rg5+
{+0.00/27 0.7} Kd4 {-0.02/23 0.7} 92. Rg4+ {+0.00/30 4} Kd3 {-0.01/22 0.8}
93. Rg3+ {+0.00/30 0.4} Kc2 {-0.01/20 2.3} 94. Rg5 {+0.00/28 1.6} Kc3
{-0.02/23 2.1} 95. Rg4 {+0.00/30 0.4} Re8 {-0.02/22 1.3} 96. Rg3+
{+0.00/27 1.0} Kc4 {-0.02/23 0.5} 97. Rg4+ {+0.00/27 0.5} Kd5
{-0.02/22 0.3} 98. Rg5+ {+0.00/27 0.9} Kd4 {-0.02/24 1.2} 99. Ra5
{+0.00/29 0.5} Re1 {-0.02/23 2.1} 100. Ra4+ {+0.00/28 0.6} Kc5
{-0.02/22 0.2} 101. Kh3 {+0.00/26 1.2} Kb5 {-0.02/25 2.5} 102. Rf4
{+0.00/27 0.9} Rd1 {-0.02/22 1.3} 103. Rf5+ {+0.00/26 0.7} Kc4
{-0.02/20 0.6} 104. Rf4+ {+0.00/28 0.5} Kd5 {-0.02/20 1.0} 105. Kg4
{+0.00/29 1.1} Rg1+ {-0.01/19 0.7} 106. Kf3 {+0.00/31 0.3} Rf1+
{-0.02/18 11} 107. Kg4 {+0.00/39 0.2} Ra1 {+0.02/16 3} 108. Rf5+
{+0.00/27 0.5} Kd4 {+0.03/15 2.5} 109. Rf4+ {+0.00/32 0.6} Ke3
{+0.05/15 1.7} 110. Rf3+ {+0.00/27 0.5} Ke2 {+0.05/17 1.9} 111. Rb3
{+0.00/29 0.8} Ra6 {+0.05/17 1.5} 112. Rb5 {+0.00/33 0.9} Kd1
{+0.05/21 1.6} 113. Rd5+ {+0.00/33 0.5} Ke2 {+0.05/34 1.9} 114. Re5+
{+0.00/61 0.4} Kd3 {+0.05/34 1.1} 115. Rd5+ {+0.00/67 0.7} Ke4
{+0.05/99 1.1} 116. Rb5 {+0.00/125 0.3}
{Draw by fifty-move rule} 1/2-1/2
[Event "Computer Chess Game"]
[Site "openSUSE"]
[Date "2012.01.01"]
[Round "2"]
[White "Komodo64 SSE Version 4"]
[Black "IvanHoe 9.46b x64"]
[Result "0-1"]
[TimeControl "600"]
[Annotator "1. +0.14 1... +0.10"]
1. e4 {+0.14/17} e5 {+0.10/21 23} 2. Nf3 {+0.14/19 7} Nc6 {+0.10/20 8} 3.
Bc4 {+0.14/19 4} Bc5 {+0.05/19 12} 4. O-O {+0.19/18 19} Nf6 {+0.12/21 34}
5. d3 {+0.24/20 1.8} d6 {+0.13/21 34} 6. c3 {+0.16/19 11} a6 {+0.08/19 11}
7. b4 {+0.15/19 6} Ba7 {+0.09/19 9} 8. Nbd2 {+0.09/19 11} O-O {+0.09/19 11}
9. a4 {+0.08/19 13} Qe7 {+0.08/19 35} 10. Re1 {+0.21/17 11} h6
{+0.07/19 0.2} 11. h3 {+0.21/18 9} Be6 {+0.10/20 28} 12. Rb1 {+0.20/18 29}
Qd7 {+0.04/18 14} 13. Bxe6 {+0.18/18 11} Qxe6 {+0.10/19 0.3} 14. Qb3
{+0.22/18 9} Nd7 {+0.01/19 24} 15. Qxe6 {+0.18/17 12} fxe6 {+0.02/21 0.3}
16. a5 {+0.15/19 22} g5 {+0.04/20 0.2} 17. Nc4 {+0.12/19 24} Kg7
{+0.08/19 0.2} 18. Ne3 {+0.09/18 9} Bxe3 {-0.04/18 8} 19. Bxe3 {+0.25/17 4}
Nf6 {-0.04/19 16} 20. Nh2 {+0.24/19 1.4} Rfd8 {-0.06/20 16} 21. f3
{+0.15/18 10} d5 {-0.05/20 8} 22. Ng4 {+0.20/20 5} d4 {+0.00/21 16} 23.
cxd4 {+0.25/22 5} Nxg4 {+0.00/22 0.2} 24. hxg4 {+0.25/19 0.5} exd4
{+0.00/22 2.5} 25. Bf2 {+0.35/19 1.1} Ne5 {+0.00/23 8} 26. Red1
{+0.39/24 1.3} c6 {+0.00/23 2.8} 27. Bg3 {+0.38/25 1.0} Ng6 {+0.00/24 11}
28. Kf2 {+0.25/26 15} e5 {-0.15/22 8} 29. Rh1 {+0.25/27 4} Re8
{-0.14/23 0.2} 30. Rbc1 {+0.25/27 11} Nh8 {-0.08/23 11} 31. Ke2
{+0.25/25 8} Re6 {-0.08/21 10} 32. Be1 {+0.25/24 6} Rae8 {-0.08/22 7} 33.
Bf2 {+0.26/22 2.6} Nf7 {-0.08/21 5} 34. Rc5 {+0.18/22 3} Rf6 {-0.08/22 3}
35. Bg3 {+0.24/25 12} Kg6 {-0.05/22 0.3} 36. Rf1 {+0.24/23 7} Kh7
{-0.05/22 7} 37. Be1 {+0.24/22 9} Nh8 {-0.05/23 0.3} 38. Rh1 {+0.24/25 8}
Rf7 {-0.08/21 11} 39. Bg3 {+0.24/25 6} Rfe7 {-0.05/23 0.3} 40. Rh5
{+0.24/24 5} Kg7 {-0.08/22 3} 41. Kf2 {+0.24/26 6} Nf7 {-0.08/23 7} 42. Rc1
{+0.24/26 7} Nd6 {-0.12/23 5} 43. Kg1 {+0.24/25 8} Nb5 {-0.08/23 5} 44. Be1
{+0.25/23 5} Rf7 {-0.08/22 11} 45. Kf2 {+0.25/25 17} Nc7 {-0.08/22 4} 46.
Rc5 {+0.25/23 7} Ree7 {-0.07/22 0.3} 47. Bd2 {+0.25/22 1.7} Kg6
{-0.07/21 7} 48. Rh1 {+0.25/21 5} Ne8 {-0.07/22 5} 49. g3 {+0.10/20 0.1}
Nf6 {-0.11/20 3} 50. Ke2 {+0.05/21 2.3} Rf8 {-0.08/21 7} 51. Rh3
{+0.05/21 5} Rc8 {-0.06/20 8} 52. Rc1 {+0.07/20 2.0} Rh7 {+0.00/21 0.3} 53.
Rch1 {+0.05/21 4} Kg7 {+0.00/21 0.3} 54. Kf2 {+0.06/20 2.4} Rf8
{+0.00/22 0.3} 55. Kg2 {+0.05/19 1.0} Rfh8 {+0.00/22 0.3} 56. R1h2
{+0.05/22 5} Rf8 {+0.00/23 1.3} 57. Bc1 {+0.05/22 1.3} Kg6 {+0.00/21 3} 58.
Rh1 {+0.05/20 6} Rc8 {+0.00/23 0.3} 59. Bd2 {+0.05/20 0.9} c5 {-0.24/20 4}
60. bxc5 {-0.05/20 4} Rxc5 {-0.34/21 0.2} 61. Kf2 {-0.05/21 2.8} Rc2
{-0.19/22 2.5} 62. Ke2 {-0.05/19 0.5} Rb2 {-0.19/22 1.7} 63. Rc1
{-0.05/21 1.0} h5 {-0.25/21 0.4} 64. gxh5+ {-0.05/21 2.1} Rxh5
{-0.25/20 0.3} 65. Rxh5 {-0.05/21 6} Nxh5 {-0.30/23 5} 66. Rg1
{-0.05/23 0.5} Ra2 {-0.30/23 1.1} 67. Rg2 {-0.05/20 0.7} Kf7 {-0.25/22 2.6}
68. Rg1 {-0.05/24 2.1} Rb2 {-0.25/22 0.4} 69. Rg2 {-0.05/22 2.0} Kg7
{-0.25/22 3} 70. Ke1 {-0.05/20 1.1} Kg6 {-0.25/21 2.9} 71. Kd1
{+0.05/21 1.2} Nf6 {-0.25/19 3} 72. f4 {-0.04/16 0.5} Rb3 {+0.00/20 9} 73.
f5+ {-0.05/17 3} Kg7 {+0.00/20 2.7} 74. Kc2 {-0.05/19 0.4} Ra3
{-0.32/20 1.0} 75. g4 {-0.05/21 4} Kg8 {+0.00/20 0.3} 76. Rg1 {-0.05/20 3}
Ra2+ {+0.00/22 0.2} 77. Kd1 {-0.05/19 0.2} Ra1+ {+0.00/21 0.9} 78. Bc1
{-0.05/21 1.2} Nd7 {+0.00/22 5} 79. Ke2 {-0.05/22 1.6} Nc5 {+0.00/22 0.3}
80. Rd1 {-0.05/22 3} Kf7 {+0.00/22 0.3} 81. Bxg5 {-0.05/18 1.5} Rxd1
{+0.00/22 0.4} 82. Kxd1 {-0.05/18 0.3} Nxd3 {+0.00/22 2.3} 83. Ke2
{-0.05/20 0.6} Nc5 {+0.00/21 1.8} 84. Bd8 {-0.05/21 2.5} Nxe4
{+0.00/19 2.5} 85. Bc7 {-0.05/22 2.0} Kf6 {+0.00/20 0.4} 86. Bd8+
{-0.05/25 3} Kg7 {+0.00/23 0.3} 87. Bb6 {-0.05/20 2.9} Nc3+ {-0.38/18 2.3}
88. Kd3 {-0.05/19 1.4} Nd5 {-0.39/19 0.3} 89. Bd8 {-0.05/20 2.9} Ne3
{-0.39/20 0.3} 90. f6+ {-0.05/17 0.3} Kf7 {-1.60/17 2.0} 91. g5
{-0.94/16 0.7} Nd5 {-1.60/18 0.2} 92. Kc4 {-0.63/18 3} Nf4 {-1.05/18 1.9}
93. Be7 {-0.83/18 1.6} Ne6 {-1.05/18 0.3} 94. g6+ {-0.63/17 0.8} Kxg6
{-1.09/18 0.3} 95. Kd5 {-0.63/18 0.3} Kf5 {-0.99/18 0.3} 96. f7
{-0.92/17 0.3} d3 {-0.99/19 0.6} 97. Bg5 {-0.86/20 0.9} Nf8 {-1.45/20 0.4}
98. Bd2 {-1.20/20 1.8} Kf6 {-1.41/20 0.4} 99. Bc3 {-1.26/18 0.2} Ng6
{-1.41/19 0.3} 100. Bxe5+ {-1.54/20 2.1} Kxf7 {-1.49/20 0.3} 101. Bc3
{-1.54/21 0.2} Ke7 {-1.77/20 0.9} 102. Bd2 {-1.54/22 0.5} Kd7 {-2.50/19 4}
103. Bc3 {-1.68/24 0.2} Nh4 {-2.51/19 1.0} 104. Ke4 {-1.73/18 0.3} Kc6
{-2.51/20 0.7} 105. Kxd3 {-1.84/19 0.2} Kb5 {-2.52/20 2.0} 106. Kd4
{-1.93/20 0.1} Ng6 {-2.61/19 1.4} 107. Bd2 {-1.97/23 1.6} Ne7
{-2.70/20 0.6} 108. Bf4 {-2.12/21 0.9} Nc6+ {-2.92/18 1.3} 109. Kd3
{-2.22/23 1.9} Nxa5 {-3.16/16 0.6} 110. Kd4 {-2.36/22 3} Kb4 {-3.59/18 0.3}
111. Bd2+ {-2.36/22 1.4} Ka4 {-3.83/20 0.4} 112. Bc3 {-3.30/22 9} b5
{-4.44/17 1.2} 113. Be1 {-3.59/20 1.6} b4 {-4.70/17 0.6} 114. Kc5
{-3.41/18 0.3} Nb7+ {-5.67/15 1.3} 115. Kb6 {-5.50/19 2.8} a5
{-8.22/15 2.4} 116. Bd2 {-5.79/22 0.4} b3 {-8.39/15 0.9} 117. Bc1
{-5.79/17 0.3} Kb4 {-8.63/15 1.3} 118. Kc6 {-7.31/17 0.9} a4 {-11.32/17 9}
119. Bd2+ {-7.83/26 0.6} Kc4 {-16.76/17 6} 120. Bc1 {-10.03/21 3} Nc5
{-17.22/17 0.3} 121. Kd6 {-10.43/17 0.8} Nd3 {-16.88/15 0.6} 122. Ba3
{-317.84/18 0.9} b2 {-18.01/14 0.3} 123. Ke6 {-99.66/18 1.7} b1=Q
{-99.75/14 1.2} 124. Kf5 {-99.70/17 1.0} Kd5 {-99.87/15 2.2} 125. Kg5
{-99.86/18 1.3} Qg1+ {-99.91/14 0.6} 126. Kf5 {-99.88/18 0.2} Ne5
{-99.91/14 0.4} 127. Kf4 {-99.90/17 0.6} Qf2+ {-99.93/12 0.3} 128. Kg5
{-99.92/17 0.3} Ke4 {-99.93/14 0.2} 129. Kh6 {-99.94/17 0.2} Qf7
{-99.95/14 0.2} 130. Kg5 {-99.96/17 0.3} Qg6+ {-99.97/15 0.3} 131. Kh4
{-99.98/18 0.6} Qg4# {-99.99/125 0.3}
{Xboard adjudication: Checkmate} 0-1
The author posted on talkchess that komodo, paraphrasing, "has the most accurate evaluation of any chess program today" which I seriously doubt; if anything, it can be a bit inflated at times -- see attached screen-shot.
The more accurate a program evaluates a position, the fewer losses it is expected to produce. This is how evaluation is measured because chess is not yet solved. Right now, Komodo is close in strength to IvanHoe, so, it does not have the most accurate evaluation of current chess engines. Looking forward to the SMP release...
One wonders how this Komodo release would fair against IvanHoe 999964h (with updated time management) at long time control where it is said to do better. It would be surprising if Komodo comes out ahead.
Some sample head-to-head matches:
[Event "Computer Chess Game"]
[Site "openSUSE"]
[Date "2011.12.31"]
[Round "1"]
[White "Komodo64 SSE Version 4"]
[Black "IvanHoe 9.46b x64"]
[Result "0-1"]
[TimeControl "900+10"]
[Annotator "1. +0.28 1... +0.12"]
1. d4 {+0.28/20} d5 {+0.12/21 39} 2. c4 {+0.20/21 54} dxc4 {+0.14/20 36} 3.
e3 {+0.24/20 39} Be6 {+0.21/21 0.2} 4. Nf3 {+0.21/19 29} Nf6
{+0.15/22 1:47} 5. Nc3 {+0.42/20 35} h6 {+0.22/21 45} 6. Ne5 {+0.35/21 5}
Nbd7 {+0.20/21 14} 7. Nxc4 {+0.37/21 31} c6 {+0.22/20 20} 8. e4
{+0.49/21 10} Bxc4 {+0.31/20 43} 9. Bxc4 {+0.45/23 2.7} b5 {+0.37/22 26}
10. Be2 {+0.44/22 58} b4 {+0.29/22 0.2} 11. Na4 {+0.38/22 31} Nxe4
{+0.37/22 0.1} 12. Bf4 {+0.33/21 43} g5 {+0.29/21 1:16} 13. Be3
{+0.64/16 5} Rc8 {+0.16/22 2:33} 14. O-O {+0.37/19 34} e6 {+0.14/20 17} 15.
Qc2 {+0.20/18 15} Nef6 {+0.06/19 0.2} 16. Nc5 {+0.08/19 1:06} Nxc5
{-0.16/20 0.2} 17. dxc5 {+0.11/19 4} Bg7 {-0.28/20 24} 18. a3 {+0.14/20 10}
a5 {-0.28/20 0.2} 19. Rfd1 {-0.11/17 27} Nd5 {-0.36/19 19} 20. axb4
{-0.14/18 10} axb4 {-0.37/20 5} 21. Ba6 {-0.25/19 45} Rb8 {-0.65/20 39} 22.
Bd4 {-0.37/19 26} Bxd4 {-0.75/21 28} 23. Rxd4 {-0.47/20 18} Ra8
{-0.87/21 32} 24. g3 {-0.58/21 1:02} O-O {-0.95/21 15} 25. Rdd1
{-0.63/20 22} Qe7 {-0.95/21 0.2} 26. Bd3 {-0.63/20 13} Rfb8 {-0.98/21 40}
27. Rac1 {-0.59/21 22} Ra5 {-0.99/22 0.2} 28. Qc4 {-0.65/21 21} Qf6
{-1.04/23 0.2} 29. Qb3 {-0.74/19 8} Kg7 {-1.03/22 22} 30. Kg2 {-0.76/21 32}
h5 {-1.03/21 36} 31. Rd2 {-0.79/21 10} g4 {-1.04/21 0.1} 32. Kg1
{-0.79/20 21} Qe7 {-1.15/21 0.2} 33. Rdc2 {-0.81/21 23} Rba8 {-1.21/21 15}
34. Qc4 {-0.81/20 19} Ra1 {-1.21/23 0.2} 35. Rxa1 {-0.86/22 38} Rxa1+
{-1.24/25 0.2} 36. Rc1 {-0.97/22 11} Ra5 {-1.25/25 0.1} 37. Kg2
{-1.07/20 18} Qg5 {-1.59/20 18} 38. Kg1 {-1.40/19 36} Qd2 {-1.75/21 18} 39.
Rb1 {-1.55/21 0.9} Nf6 {-1.69/23 10} 40. Kg2 {-1.46/22 4} Qg5 {-1.71/23 6}
41. Rc1 {-1.74/21 39} Ra2 {-1.98/25 0.2} 42. Rc2 {-1.90/22 23} Ra1
{-2.53/22 32} 43. Be2 {-1.75/21 20} Re1 {-2.61/24 0.2} 44. f4 {-2.03/20 15}
Qd5+ {-2.68/24 0.2} 45. Qxd5 {-2.33/21 3} exd5 {-2.73/26 15} 46. Kf2
{-2.54/24 13} Rh1 {-2.96/27 32} 47. Kg2 {-2.72/26 14} Rb1 {-2.96/28 0.2}
48. Bd3 {-2.97/24 17} b3 {-3.12/26 0.2} 49. Re2 {-2.96/20 1.4} Rd1
{-3.83/23 24} 50. Bf5 {-3.26/24 40} d4 {-4.18/24 0.2} 51. Kf2
{-3.19/20 0.8} Nd5 {-4.43/22 14} 52. Re5 {-3.57/22 16} d3 {-4.81/21 18} 53.
Re1 {-4.36/24 1.1} Rd2+ {-5.61/22 23} 54. Kg1 {-4.94/25 4} Rxb2
{-6.02/22 15} 55. Bxd3 {-5.15/24 0.3} Rd2 {-6.19/23 24} 56. Be4
{-5.42/23 5} b2 {-6.32/23 11} 57. Bf5 {-5.57/23 3} Kf6 {-7.06/25 1:06} 58.
Bh7 {-5.88/26 15} Nc3 {-7.06/25 0.2} 59. Kf1 {-5.95/22 1.6} Rxh2
{-7.88/22 19} 60. Re3 {-6.15/27 54} Nd5 {-8.34/24 0.2} 61. Rb3
{-5.57/19 11} h4 {-8.42/23 0.1} 62. gxh4 {-5.79/19 7} Nxf4 {-8.84/22 39}
63. Kg1 {-6.17/22 8} Re2 {-10.34/22 34} 64. Kf1 {-5.95/19 4} Ke5
{-10.40/22 19} 65. Bb1 {-6.45/22 5} Rh2 {-10.93/22 37} 66. Re3+
{-6.60/23 4} Kd5 {-10.96/22 10} 67. Bf5 {-6.87/22 23} Rxh4 {-11.03/22 0.2}
68. Rb3 {-6.72/21 19} g3 {-11.76/22 0.2} 69. Rxg3 {-9.09/22 10} Rh1+
{-11.76/22 0.2} 70. Kf2 {-9.36/20 1.0} Ke5 {-12.66/21 23} 71. Rg7
{-9.88/25 12} Kf6 {-13.12/21 0.2} 72. Rxf7+ {-10.73/23 19} Kxf7
{-17.32/18 16} 73. Be4 {-99.02/23 1:01} Rd1 {-99.73/21 0.1} 74. Ke3
{-99.78/20 12} Nd5+ {-99.73/20 0.2} 75. Kf2 {-11.43/21 11} Kf6
{-99.75/20 0.1} 76. Kg3 {-99.74/21 20} Nb4 {-99.87/18 28} 77. Kh3
{-99.84/20 10} Re1 {-99.87/17 9} 78. Bb1 {-99.88/22 15} Rxb1 {-99.89/18 10}
79. Kh2 {-99.90/23 5} Re1 {-99.91/19 23} 80. Kg3 {-99.92/23 24} Re3+
{-99.93/18 13} 81. Kf2 {-99.92/21 4} Rd3 {-99.93/19 27} 82. Kf1
{-99.94/19 1.4} b1=Q+ {-99.93/16 20} 83. Ke2 {-99.96/23 17} Qc2+
{-99.97/17 0.2} 84. Kf1 {-99.98/21 0.8} Rd1# {-99.99/125 0.3}
{Xboard adjudication: Checkmate} 0-1
[Event "Computer Chess Game"]
[Site "openSUSE"]
[Date "2011.12.31"]
[Round "3"]
[White "IvanHoe 9.46b x64"]
[Black "Komodo64 SSE Version 4"]
[Result "1-0"]
[TimeControl "900+10"]
[Annotator "1. +0.10 1... +0.28"]
1. d4 {+0.10/21} d5 {+0.28/17 7} 2. Nf3 {+0.13/21 1:17} Bf5 {+0.17/19 45}
3. c4 {+0.24/19 26} e6 {+0.15/20 24} 4. cxd5 {+0.23/20 0.3} exd5
{+0.09/20 46} 5. Nc3 {+0.15/20 56} c6 {+0.10/20 26} 6. g3 {+0.09/20 39} Be7
{+0.02/20 31} 7. Bg2 {+0.01/21 47} Nf6 {+0.02/22 2:09} 8. Nh4 {+0.05/22 54}
Be6 {-0.08/19 5} 9. O-O {+0.03/21 40} O-O {-0.07/21 0.6} 10. Qc2
{+0.06/21 49} Qc8 {-0.05/19 11} 11. Nf3 {+0.05/19 33} Bf5 {-0.17/20 20} 12.
Qb3 {+0.00/21 0.2} Nbd7 {-0.06/20 1:03} 13. Bf4 {+0.01/20 46} Rd8
{-0.09/20 23} 14. Nh4 {+0.01/18 53} Be6 {-0.21/19 32} 15. Nf3
{+0.00/21 0.2} Nb6 {-0.19/18 20} 16. Ng5 {-0.04/19 17} Bd7 {-0.22/19 8} 17.
Nf3 {-0.04/20 19} Nc4 {-0.23/19 20} 18. Rfe1 {+0.00/20 27} b5 {-0.16/18 11}
19. e4 {+0.06/20 24} dxe4 {-0.11/21 14} 20. Nxe4 {+0.06/20 0.2} Nd5
{-0.14/21 35} 21. Bc1 {+0.04/20 0.3} Bb4 {-0.08/18 43} 22. Bd2
{+0.07/20 0.3} Nxd2 {-0.14/20 30} 23. Nfxd2 {+0.04/19 0.3} a5 {-0.11/21 31}
24. a3 {+0.06/21 24} a4 {-0.13/22 42} 25. Qd3 {+0.00/22 0.2} Ba5
{-0.16/20 11} 26. Nc5 {+0.00/22 0.3} Bf5 {-0.10/21 21} 27. Be4
{+0.00/21 10} Bg6 {-0.09/22 56} 28. Bxg6 {+0.15/21 31} hxg6 {-0.15/20 10}
29. Rac1 {+0.14/23 34} Qf5 {-0.09/21 46} 30. Re2 {+0.06/22 21} Qg5
{-0.10/22 4} 31. h4 {+0.38/21 19} Qg4 {-0.15/20 9} 32. Re4 {+0.30/20 0.4}
Qc8 {-0.01/21 27} 33. Nf3 {+0.26/21 38} Ra7 {-0.03/22 46} 34. Ne5
{+0.25/21 1:17} Bb6 {-0.15/20 16} 35. Qf3 {+0.25/21 0.3} Rc7 {+0.01/20 19}
36. Ree1 {+0.23/21 0.3} Nf6 {+0.03/21 22} 37. Red1 {+0.23/21 0.5} Rd5
{-0.03/21 30} 38. Kg2 {+0.12/20 25} Rd6 {-0.03/22 7} 39. Rc2 {+0.24/20 17}
Ba7 {+0.05/20 34} 40. Rd3 {+0.21/20 0.3} Bb6 {+0.05/19 15} 41. Rdd2
{+0.24/20 15} Nd5 {+0.05/19 15} 42. Ne4 {+0.28/20 16} Re6 {+0.15/19 5} 43.
Ng5 {+0.24/21 15} Rf6 {+0.05/18 4} 44. Qd3 {+0.24/22 43} Rf4 {+0.05/19 16}
45. Ngf3 {+0.24/22 0.3} Rf6 {+0.05/22 16} 46. Rd1 {+0.27/20 0.3} Rd6
{+0.05/20 20} 47. Re2 {+0.27/21 0.4} Nf6 {-0.13/18 6} 48. Rc1
{+0.27/20 0.4} Qb8 {-0.08/19 13} 49. Qe3 {+0.27/20 31} Qe8 {+0.05/20 18}
50. b4 {+0.34/20 25} Qd8 {+0.05/18 16} 51. Qg5 {+0.35/21 0.4} Qf8
{+0.05/18 15} 52. Qf4 {+0.39/21 28} Nd5 {+0.05/22 13} 53. Qd2
{+0.47/20 0.4} Qc8 {+0.38/19 29} 54. Rce1 {+0.63/22 0.4} Rd8 {+0.41/19 13}
55. Qd3 {+0.54/20 18} Rf8 {+0.50/20 7} 56. Rc2 {+0.54/20 11} Ne7
{+0.56/20 1.3} 57. Rcc1 {+0.57/19 36} Nd5 {+0.47/20 16} 58. Re2
{+0.54/21 0.4} Ne7 {+0.48/22 16} 59. Qd2 {+0.54/19 9} Ba7 {+0.46/19 46} 60.
Qa2 {+0.72/19 12} Bb6 {+0.76/18 32} 61. Ng5 {+0.78/20 0.4} Nd5
{+0.72/20 15} 62. Rxc6 {+0.97/21 0.4} Rxc6 {+0.69/21 14} 63. Qxd5
{+0.89/21 7} Rf6 {+0.80/21 0.3} 64. Nd7 {+0.89/22 14} Qa8 {+0.70/24 10} 65.
Qe4 {+0.89/24 8} Rd8 {+0.71/24 11} 66. Nxf6+ {+0.89/24 0.5} gxf6
{+0.72/22 1.1} 67. Nf3 {+0.89/25 22} Qxe4 {+0.70/22 9} 68. Rxe4
{+0.89/25 0.4} Kg7 {+0.74/23 7} 69. Re3 {+0.89/24 11} Rd7 {+0.83/21 5} 70.
Rd3 {+0.89/24 11} Rd5 {+0.80/18 1.4} 71. g4 {+0.89/23 5} Kf8 {+0.56/18 2.6}
72. Rd1 {+0.89/22 16} Ke7 {+0.63/17 1.8} 73. Kf1 {+1.02/22 6} f5
{+0.85/22 14} 74. g5 {+0.96/24 0.4} Rd8 {+0.98/23 24} 75. Ke2
{+1.06/24 0.4} Re8 {+0.49/20 6} 76. Kd3 {+1.17/23 13} Kd7 {+0.62/22 1.9}
77. Re1 {+1.17/24 9} Rxe1 {+0.74/26 7} 78. Nxe1 {+1.17/27 0.4} Kc6
{+0.74/26 5} 79. Ng2 {+1.17/28 13} Bc7 {+1.18/22 2.6} 80. Ne3 {+1.33/27 16}
Bf4 {+1.17/26 6} 81. Ke2 {+1.40/27 19} Bd6 {+1.36/25 4} 82. Nd1
{+1.40/26 6} Kd5 {+1.35/26 16} 83. Kd3 {+1.64/27 0.4} Kc6 {+1.25/24 7} 84.
Nc3 {+1.72/26 0.6} Kb6 {+1.48/24 7} 85. Ne2 {+1.85/25 0.5} Kc6
{+1.59/25 11} 86. d5+ {+1.85/24 0.3} Kxd5 {+1.40/21 0.7} 87. Nd4
{+1.91/23 9} Bf4 {+1.40/24 15} 88. Nxb5 {+1.90/24 0.4} Ke5 {+1.55/20 0.7}
89. Kc4 {+2.00/23 26} Bd2 {+1.74/24 31} 90. Nd4 {+2.24/24 0.5} Kd6
{+1.77/24 13} 91. Kd3 {+2.23/22 0.4} Bc1 {+1.92/25 14} 92. Kc2
{+2.40/23 21} Bf4 {+2.28/25 9} 93. Nb5+ {+2.40/23 0.4} Ke6 {+2.29/24 11}
94. Nc3 {+2.56/23 0.3} f6 {+2.35/24 14} 95. gxf6 {+2.68/22 0.5} Be5
{+2.42/24 14} 96. f7 {+2.80/22 0.4} Kxf7 {+2.42/21 1.2} 97. Nxa4
{+2.84/21 10} Bd4 {+2.52/24 2.5} 98. f4 {+3.09/21 9} Ke6 {+2.69/24 7} 99.
Kd3 {+3.41/22 18} Bf2 {+2.69/23 4} 100. Nc5+ {+3.56/21 6} Kd5 {+2.72/27 11}
101. Nd7 {+3.58/22 0.4} Bxh4 {+3.10/22 5} 102. Ne5 {+3.58/22 3} Bg3
{+3.27/25 9} 103. Nxg6 {+3.69/23 19} Bf2 {+4.07/25 6} 104. a4 {+4.82/22 12}
Be1 {+5.36/25 0.5} 105. b5 {+5.62/21 24} Kd6 {+5.53/26 12} 106. Kc4
{+6.82/20 16} Bd2 {+5.73/29 1.3} 107. Nh4 {+7.72/19 12} Kc7 {+8.30/31 1:03}
108. Nxf5 {+9.89/22 0.3} Bxf4 {+8.30/21 0.5} 109. a5 {+15.22/20 1:01} Be5
{+98.62/27 6} 110. Kc5 {+15.27/20 20} Kb7 {+99.62/23 30} 111. Nd6+
{+17.90/19 0.4} Ka7 {+317.94/23 8} 112. a6 {+99.69/22 20} Bg3
{+99.72/24 11} 113. Kc6 {+99.75/23 30} Bf2 {+99.74/24 3} 114. Nc8+
{+99.77/22 7} Kb8 {+99.76/26 4} 115. b6 {+99.79/23 3} Bxb6 {+99.80/25 2.9}
116. Kxb6 {+99.81/24 9} Kxc8 {+99.82/24 1.8} 117. a7 {+99.83/32 8} Kd7
{+99.84/23 1.1} 118. a8=Q {+99.87/38 17} Ke6 {+99.86/24 12} 119. Qe4+
{+99.89/45 21} Kf7 {+99.86/21 4} 120. Qf5+ {+99.89/47 4} Kg7
{+99.88/21 2.8} 121. Qg5+ {+99.89/55 26} Kh8 {+99.90/21 6} 122. Qh6+
{+99.91/56 15} Kg8 {+99.88/20 1.1} 123. Kc7 {+99.91/58 8} Kf7 {+99.90/23 3}
124. Kd6 {+99.93/57 18} Kg8 {+99.92/24 5} 125. Ke5 {+99.93/57 2.0} Kf7
{+99.94/21 0.1} 126. Qh7+ {+99.93/56 56} Ke8 {+99.96/26 23} 127. Ke6
{+99.97/84 44} Kd8 {+99.98/25 18} 128. Qd7# {+99.99/125 0.3}
{Xboard adjudication: Checkmate} 1-0
[Event "Computer Chess Game"]
[Site "openSUSE"]
[Date "2012.01.01"]
[Round "1"]
[White "IvanHoe 9.46b x64"]
[Black "Komodo64 SSE Version 4"]
[Result "1/2-1/2"]
[TimeControl "600"]
[Annotator "1. +0.10 1... +0.21"]
1. d4 {+0.10/21} d5 {+0.21/16 2.8} 2. Bf4 {+0.14/20 32} Nc6 {+0.14/21 42}
3. Nf3 {+0.12/20 16} Bf5 {+0.09/19 7} 4. e3 {+0.03/20 29} e6 {+0.09/21 16}
5. Bd3 {+0.07/21 0.3} Bxd3 {+0.15/19 25} 6. Qxd3 {+0.03/21 0.3} Nf6
{+0.15/19 12} 7. O-O {+0.14/20 10} Bd6 {+0.17/19 6} 8. Bg5 {+0.14/20 0.3}
h6 {+0.11/18 14} 9. Bxf6 {+0.27/19 7} Qxf6 {+0.10/20 4} 10. c4 {+0.23/20 7}
O-O {+0.18/19 16} 11. c5 {+0.26/22 1:22} Be7 {+0.08/18 5} 12. Nc3
{+0.26/22 0.3} a6 {+0.10/20 25} 13. Rad1 {+0.26/19 14} Rad8 {+0.10/20 9}
14. Qc2 {+0.29/19 0.3} Qg6 {+0.03/20 25} 15. Qxg6 {+0.29/19 20} fxg6
{+0.05/23 29} 16. h3 {+0.29/20 0.3} g5 {+0.04/21 8} 17. Rd2 {+0.31/19 9} g6
{-0.03/18 5} 18. Rb1 {+0.34/19 7} Rf7 {+0.08/19 7} 19. b4 {+0.46/20 4} Bf6
{+0.05/19 0.3} 20. b5 {+0.46/21 4} Na5 {+0.07/16 2.0} 21. bxa6 {+0.47/18 4}
bxa6 {+0.05/21 1.3} 22. Rdd1 {+0.43/21 15} Kg7 {+0.05/19 8} 23. Rb4
{+0.43/22 0.3} Nc6 {+0.10/20 8} 24. Ra4 {+0.43/20 4} Ra8 {+0.09/16 2.2} 25.
Ra3 {+0.47/21 7} h5 {+0.05/19 9} 26. Ne1 {+0.49/19 6} g4 {+0.05/20 1.6} 27.
hxg4 {+0.53/18 3} hxg4 {+0.05/16 1.0} 28. Nd3 {+0.59/18 2.1} g3
{+0.12/18 5} 29. f3 {+0.71/18 3} a5 {+0.22/19 5} 30. Ne2 {+0.73/20 0.4} Bh4
{+0.37/18 5} 31. Rb3 {+0.81/19 15} a4 {+0.35/18 12} 32. Rb5 {+0.77/19 13}
Rff8 {+0.35/18 10} 33. Rdb1 {+0.77/18 6} Rh8 {+0.40/18 6} 34. f4
{+0.91/19 16} a3 {+0.52/18 12} 35. Ne1 {+0.92/19 5} Na5 {+0.49/19 6} 36.
Nf3 {+1.03/20 0.4} Nc4 {+0.57/18 1.2} 37. Rb7 {+1.13/19 4} Rac8
{+0.57/18 0.2} 38. Nc3 {+1.08/18 4} Rh5 {+0.73/18 16} 39. Ra7 {+1.20/17 5}
Kg8 {+0.85/16 11} 40. Rbb7 {+1.51/18 4} Rh7 {+1.05/17 6} 41. Ra6
{+1.75/20 0.3} Re8 {+1.29/18 5} 42. Nb5 {+1.40/19 0.4} c6 {+0.82/17 4} 43.
Rxh7 {+1.39/19 0.4} Kxh7 {+0.79/16 0.4} 44. Nxa3 {+0.40/19 35} Rb8
{+0.31/17 2.9} 45. Nxh4 {+0.18/19 6} Rb2 {+0.05/21 1.9} 46. Kf1
{+0.12/19 0.4} Nxe3+ {+0.05/19 2.1} 47. Ke1 {+0.07/21 0.4} Nxg2+
{+0.05/19 1.8} 48. Nxg2 {+0.08/22 0.4} Rxg2 {+0.05/20 1.5} 49. Kf1
{+0.06/22 6} Rxa2 {+0.05/19 1.4} 50. Rxc6 {+0.05/22 0.9} Rxa3
{+0.05/20 1.8} 51. Rxe6 {+0.05/23 2.7} Rf3+ {+0.05/21 0.2} 52. Kg2
{+0.05/24 2.6} Rxf4 {+0.05/22 0.5} 53. Re7+ {+0.00/24 6} Kh6 {+0.05/25 4}
54. Re2 {+0.00/26 0.5} Rxd4 {+0.05/20 0.5} 55. Rc2 {+0.00/25 1.9} Re4
{+0.05/22 0.7} 56. c6 {+0.00/24 2.5} Re8 {+0.05/22 0.2} 57. Kxg3
{+0.00/24 1.0} g5 {+0.05/24 4} 58. Kg4 {+0.00/24 2.8} Kg6 {+0.05/24 5} 59.
c7 {+0.00/26 0.4} Rc8 {+0.05/25 2.7} 60. Rc6+ {+0.00/27 0.4} Kf7
{+0.05/22 0.3} 61. Rd6 {+0.00/27 2.5} Rxc7 {-0.02/14 1.0} 62. Rxd5
{+0.00/26 1.0} Ke6 {-0.02/19 2.7} 63. Ra5 {+0.00/26 2.8} Rc2 {-0.02/21 4}
64. Ra6+ {+0.00/25 1.2} Ke5 {-0.02/21 2.5} 65. Ra5+ {+0.00/26 3} Ke4
{-0.02/19 5} 66. Kxg5 {+0.00/25 3} Rc6 {-0.01/21 1.8} 67. Ra4+
{+0.00/26 1.0} Kd3 {-0.02/18 2.9} 68. Ra3+ {+0.00/24 0.9} Kd4
{-0.02/19 1.4} 69. Ra4+ {+0.00/28 0.3} Kd5 {-0.01/21 5} 70. Ra5+
{+0.00/30 0.5} Kc4 {-0.02/21 1.9} 71. Ra4+ {+0.00/26 1.7} Kc5 {-0.02/22 3}
72. Ra5+ {+0.00/27 0.9} Kb4 {-0.02/22 2.0} 73. Rd5 {+0.00/29 2.0} Kc3
{-0.02/22 2.1} 74. Kf4 {+0.00/27 3} Rc8 {-0.02/22 4} 75. Ra5 {+0.00/26 2.7}
Kd4 {-0.02/22 2.6} 76. Kg5 {+0.00/27 3} Rg8+ {-0.02/23 2.4} 77. Kf5
{+0.00/28 1.5} Rf8+ {-0.02/23 2.2} 78. Kg4 {+0.00/29 0.5} Rf1
{-0.02/23 2.2} 79. Ra4+ {+0.00/28 1.7} Kc5 {-0.02/23 2.1} 80. Kh4
{+0.00/26 1.5} Rg1 {-0.02/24 2.4} 81. Rf4 {+0.00/28 0.5} Rg2 {-0.02/24 1.6}
82. Rf5+ {+0.00/28 0.4} Kd4 {-0.02/24 1.0} 83. Rf4+ {+0.00/28 0.5} Ke5
{-0.02/24 1.5} 84. Rg4 {+0.00/29 2.8} Re2 {-0.02/24 0.4} 85. Rg5+
{+0.00/26 0.9} Kf4 {-0.02/23 0.9} 86. Rg4+ {+0.00/29 0.9} Kf5
{-0.02/22 0.6} 87. Rg5+ {+0.00/29 1.3} Ke4 {-0.02/21 0.5} 88. Rg4+
{+0.00/28 0.7} Kd5 {-0.02/23 0.3} 89. Rg5+ {+0.00/28 0.7} Kc4
{-0.02/24 1.9} 90. Rg4+ {+0.00/29 0.8} Kc5 {-0.02/23 0.9} 91. Rg5+
{+0.00/27 0.7} Kd4 {-0.02/23 0.7} 92. Rg4+ {+0.00/30 4} Kd3 {-0.01/22 0.8}
93. Rg3+ {+0.00/30 0.4} Kc2 {-0.01/20 2.3} 94. Rg5 {+0.00/28 1.6} Kc3
{-0.02/23 2.1} 95. Rg4 {+0.00/30 0.4} Re8 {-0.02/22 1.3} 96. Rg3+
{+0.00/27 1.0} Kc4 {-0.02/23 0.5} 97. Rg4+ {+0.00/27 0.5} Kd5
{-0.02/22 0.3} 98. Rg5+ {+0.00/27 0.9} Kd4 {-0.02/24 1.2} 99. Ra5
{+0.00/29 0.5} Re1 {-0.02/23 2.1} 100. Ra4+ {+0.00/28 0.6} Kc5
{-0.02/22 0.2} 101. Kh3 {+0.00/26 1.2} Kb5 {-0.02/25 2.5} 102. Rf4
{+0.00/27 0.9} Rd1 {-0.02/22 1.3} 103. Rf5+ {+0.00/26 0.7} Kc4
{-0.02/20 0.6} 104. Rf4+ {+0.00/28 0.5} Kd5 {-0.02/20 1.0} 105. Kg4
{+0.00/29 1.1} Rg1+ {-0.01/19 0.7} 106. Kf3 {+0.00/31 0.3} Rf1+
{-0.02/18 11} 107. Kg4 {+0.00/39 0.2} Ra1 {+0.02/16 3} 108. Rf5+
{+0.00/27 0.5} Kd4 {+0.03/15 2.5} 109. Rf4+ {+0.00/32 0.6} Ke3
{+0.05/15 1.7} 110. Rf3+ {+0.00/27 0.5} Ke2 {+0.05/17 1.9} 111. Rb3
{+0.00/29 0.8} Ra6 {+0.05/17 1.5} 112. Rb5 {+0.00/33 0.9} Kd1
{+0.05/21 1.6} 113. Rd5+ {+0.00/33 0.5} Ke2 {+0.05/34 1.9} 114. Re5+
{+0.00/61 0.4} Kd3 {+0.05/34 1.1} 115. Rd5+ {+0.00/67 0.7} Ke4
{+0.05/99 1.1} 116. Rb5 {+0.00/125 0.3}
{Draw by fifty-move rule} 1/2-1/2
[Event "Computer Chess Game"]
[Site "openSUSE"]
[Date "2012.01.01"]
[Round "2"]
[White "Komodo64 SSE Version 4"]
[Black "IvanHoe 9.46b x64"]
[Result "0-1"]
[TimeControl "600"]
[Annotator "1. +0.14 1... +0.10"]
1. e4 {+0.14/17} e5 {+0.10/21 23} 2. Nf3 {+0.14/19 7} Nc6 {+0.10/20 8} 3.
Bc4 {+0.14/19 4} Bc5 {+0.05/19 12} 4. O-O {+0.19/18 19} Nf6 {+0.12/21 34}
5. d3 {+0.24/20 1.8} d6 {+0.13/21 34} 6. c3 {+0.16/19 11} a6 {+0.08/19 11}
7. b4 {+0.15/19 6} Ba7 {+0.09/19 9} 8. Nbd2 {+0.09/19 11} O-O {+0.09/19 11}
9. a4 {+0.08/19 13} Qe7 {+0.08/19 35} 10. Re1 {+0.21/17 11} h6
{+0.07/19 0.2} 11. h3 {+0.21/18 9} Be6 {+0.10/20 28} 12. Rb1 {+0.20/18 29}
Qd7 {+0.04/18 14} 13. Bxe6 {+0.18/18 11} Qxe6 {+0.10/19 0.3} 14. Qb3
{+0.22/18 9} Nd7 {+0.01/19 24} 15. Qxe6 {+0.18/17 12} fxe6 {+0.02/21 0.3}
16. a5 {+0.15/19 22} g5 {+0.04/20 0.2} 17. Nc4 {+0.12/19 24} Kg7
{+0.08/19 0.2} 18. Ne3 {+0.09/18 9} Bxe3 {-0.04/18 8} 19. Bxe3 {+0.25/17 4}
Nf6 {-0.04/19 16} 20. Nh2 {+0.24/19 1.4} Rfd8 {-0.06/20 16} 21. f3
{+0.15/18 10} d5 {-0.05/20 8} 22. Ng4 {+0.20/20 5} d4 {+0.00/21 16} 23.
cxd4 {+0.25/22 5} Nxg4 {+0.00/22 0.2} 24. hxg4 {+0.25/19 0.5} exd4
{+0.00/22 2.5} 25. Bf2 {+0.35/19 1.1} Ne5 {+0.00/23 8} 26. Red1
{+0.39/24 1.3} c6 {+0.00/23 2.8} 27. Bg3 {+0.38/25 1.0} Ng6 {+0.00/24 11}
28. Kf2 {+0.25/26 15} e5 {-0.15/22 8} 29. Rh1 {+0.25/27 4} Re8
{-0.14/23 0.2} 30. Rbc1 {+0.25/27 11} Nh8 {-0.08/23 11} 31. Ke2
{+0.25/25 8} Re6 {-0.08/21 10} 32. Be1 {+0.25/24 6} Rae8 {-0.08/22 7} 33.
Bf2 {+0.26/22 2.6} Nf7 {-0.08/21 5} 34. Rc5 {+0.18/22 3} Rf6 {-0.08/22 3}
35. Bg3 {+0.24/25 12} Kg6 {-0.05/22 0.3} 36. Rf1 {+0.24/23 7} Kh7
{-0.05/22 7} 37. Be1 {+0.24/22 9} Nh8 {-0.05/23 0.3} 38. Rh1 {+0.24/25 8}
Rf7 {-0.08/21 11} 39. Bg3 {+0.24/25 6} Rfe7 {-0.05/23 0.3} 40. Rh5
{+0.24/24 5} Kg7 {-0.08/22 3} 41. Kf2 {+0.24/26 6} Nf7 {-0.08/23 7} 42. Rc1
{+0.24/26 7} Nd6 {-0.12/23 5} 43. Kg1 {+0.24/25 8} Nb5 {-0.08/23 5} 44. Be1
{+0.25/23 5} Rf7 {-0.08/22 11} 45. Kf2 {+0.25/25 17} Nc7 {-0.08/22 4} 46.
Rc5 {+0.25/23 7} Ree7 {-0.07/22 0.3} 47. Bd2 {+0.25/22 1.7} Kg6
{-0.07/21 7} 48. Rh1 {+0.25/21 5} Ne8 {-0.07/22 5} 49. g3 {+0.10/20 0.1}
Nf6 {-0.11/20 3} 50. Ke2 {+0.05/21 2.3} Rf8 {-0.08/21 7} 51. Rh3
{+0.05/21 5} Rc8 {-0.06/20 8} 52. Rc1 {+0.07/20 2.0} Rh7 {+0.00/21 0.3} 53.
Rch1 {+0.05/21 4} Kg7 {+0.00/21 0.3} 54. Kf2 {+0.06/20 2.4} Rf8
{+0.00/22 0.3} 55. Kg2 {+0.05/19 1.0} Rfh8 {+0.00/22 0.3} 56. R1h2
{+0.05/22 5} Rf8 {+0.00/23 1.3} 57. Bc1 {+0.05/22 1.3} Kg6 {+0.00/21 3} 58.
Rh1 {+0.05/20 6} Rc8 {+0.00/23 0.3} 59. Bd2 {+0.05/20 0.9} c5 {-0.24/20 4}
60. bxc5 {-0.05/20 4} Rxc5 {-0.34/21 0.2} 61. Kf2 {-0.05/21 2.8} Rc2
{-0.19/22 2.5} 62. Ke2 {-0.05/19 0.5} Rb2 {-0.19/22 1.7} 63. Rc1
{-0.05/21 1.0} h5 {-0.25/21 0.4} 64. gxh5+ {-0.05/21 2.1} Rxh5
{-0.25/20 0.3} 65. Rxh5 {-0.05/21 6} Nxh5 {-0.30/23 5} 66. Rg1
{-0.05/23 0.5} Ra2 {-0.30/23 1.1} 67. Rg2 {-0.05/20 0.7} Kf7 {-0.25/22 2.6}
68. Rg1 {-0.05/24 2.1} Rb2 {-0.25/22 0.4} 69. Rg2 {-0.05/22 2.0} Kg7
{-0.25/22 3} 70. Ke1 {-0.05/20 1.1} Kg6 {-0.25/21 2.9} 71. Kd1
{+0.05/21 1.2} Nf6 {-0.25/19 3} 72. f4 {-0.04/16 0.5} Rb3 {+0.00/20 9} 73.
f5+ {-0.05/17 3} Kg7 {+0.00/20 2.7} 74. Kc2 {-0.05/19 0.4} Ra3
{-0.32/20 1.0} 75. g4 {-0.05/21 4} Kg8 {+0.00/20 0.3} 76. Rg1 {-0.05/20 3}
Ra2+ {+0.00/22 0.2} 77. Kd1 {-0.05/19 0.2} Ra1+ {+0.00/21 0.9} 78. Bc1
{-0.05/21 1.2} Nd7 {+0.00/22 5} 79. Ke2 {-0.05/22 1.6} Nc5 {+0.00/22 0.3}
80. Rd1 {-0.05/22 3} Kf7 {+0.00/22 0.3} 81. Bxg5 {-0.05/18 1.5} Rxd1
{+0.00/22 0.4} 82. Kxd1 {-0.05/18 0.3} Nxd3 {+0.00/22 2.3} 83. Ke2
{-0.05/20 0.6} Nc5 {+0.00/21 1.8} 84. Bd8 {-0.05/21 2.5} Nxe4
{+0.00/19 2.5} 85. Bc7 {-0.05/22 2.0} Kf6 {+0.00/20 0.4} 86. Bd8+
{-0.05/25 3} Kg7 {+0.00/23 0.3} 87. Bb6 {-0.05/20 2.9} Nc3+ {-0.38/18 2.3}
88. Kd3 {-0.05/19 1.4} Nd5 {-0.39/19 0.3} 89. Bd8 {-0.05/20 2.9} Ne3
{-0.39/20 0.3} 90. f6+ {-0.05/17 0.3} Kf7 {-1.60/17 2.0} 91. g5
{-0.94/16 0.7} Nd5 {-1.60/18 0.2} 92. Kc4 {-0.63/18 3} Nf4 {-1.05/18 1.9}
93. Be7 {-0.83/18 1.6} Ne6 {-1.05/18 0.3} 94. g6+ {-0.63/17 0.8} Kxg6
{-1.09/18 0.3} 95. Kd5 {-0.63/18 0.3} Kf5 {-0.99/18 0.3} 96. f7
{-0.92/17 0.3} d3 {-0.99/19 0.6} 97. Bg5 {-0.86/20 0.9} Nf8 {-1.45/20 0.4}
98. Bd2 {-1.20/20 1.8} Kf6 {-1.41/20 0.4} 99. Bc3 {-1.26/18 0.2} Ng6
{-1.41/19 0.3} 100. Bxe5+ {-1.54/20 2.1} Kxf7 {-1.49/20 0.3} 101. Bc3
{-1.54/21 0.2} Ke7 {-1.77/20 0.9} 102. Bd2 {-1.54/22 0.5} Kd7 {-2.50/19 4}
103. Bc3 {-1.68/24 0.2} Nh4 {-2.51/19 1.0} 104. Ke4 {-1.73/18 0.3} Kc6
{-2.51/20 0.7} 105. Kxd3 {-1.84/19 0.2} Kb5 {-2.52/20 2.0} 106. Kd4
{-1.93/20 0.1} Ng6 {-2.61/19 1.4} 107. Bd2 {-1.97/23 1.6} Ne7
{-2.70/20 0.6} 108. Bf4 {-2.12/21 0.9} Nc6+ {-2.92/18 1.3} 109. Kd3
{-2.22/23 1.9} Nxa5 {-3.16/16 0.6} 110. Kd4 {-2.36/22 3} Kb4 {-3.59/18 0.3}
111. Bd2+ {-2.36/22 1.4} Ka4 {-3.83/20 0.4} 112. Bc3 {-3.30/22 9} b5
{-4.44/17 1.2} 113. Be1 {-3.59/20 1.6} b4 {-4.70/17 0.6} 114. Kc5
{-3.41/18 0.3} Nb7+ {-5.67/15 1.3} 115. Kb6 {-5.50/19 2.8} a5
{-8.22/15 2.4} 116. Bd2 {-5.79/22 0.4} b3 {-8.39/15 0.9} 117. Bc1
{-5.79/17 0.3} Kb4 {-8.63/15 1.3} 118. Kc6 {-7.31/17 0.9} a4 {-11.32/17 9}
119. Bd2+ {-7.83/26 0.6} Kc4 {-16.76/17 6} 120. Bc1 {-10.03/21 3} Nc5
{-17.22/17 0.3} 121. Kd6 {-10.43/17 0.8} Nd3 {-16.88/15 0.6} 122. Ba3
{-317.84/18 0.9} b2 {-18.01/14 0.3} 123. Ke6 {-99.66/18 1.7} b1=Q
{-99.75/14 1.2} 124. Kf5 {-99.70/17 1.0} Kd5 {-99.87/15 2.2} 125. Kg5
{-99.86/18 1.3} Qg1+ {-99.91/14 0.6} 126. Kf5 {-99.88/18 0.2} Ne5
{-99.91/14 0.4} 127. Kf4 {-99.90/17 0.6} Qf2+ {-99.93/12 0.3} 128. Kg5
{-99.92/17 0.3} Ke4 {-99.93/14 0.2} 129. Kh6 {-99.94/17 0.2} Qf7
{-99.95/14 0.2} 130. Kg5 {-99.96/17 0.3} Qg6+ {-99.97/15 0.3} 131. Kh4
{-99.98/18 0.6} Qg4# {-99.99/125 0.3}
{Xboard adjudication: Checkmate} 0-1